What's new

How can India be BFFs with both Russia and the United States?

Bang Galore

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Feb 21, 2010
Messages
10,685
Reaction score
12
Country
India
Location
India

How can India be BFFs with both Russia and the United States?


Russian President Vladimir Putin is in India signing big deals with Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi, just days after India announced it would host President Obama in late January.

By Howard LaFranchi

Washington — Just days after India announced with great fanfare that new Prime Minister Narendra Modi will host President Obama in late January for Republic Day, Mr. Modi is heaping the love – and lucrative defense and energy contracts – on Russian President Vladimir Putin.

With the shunned Mr. Putin unable to go West for economic succor for an ailing Russian economy and wary of too-tight an embrace with China, the Russian leader has turned south to OBF (Only Best Friend) India.

Given how the Ukrainian crisis has soured Russia’s economic ties to Europe, Putin’s motivations for muscling up longtime relations with the world’s second most populous country seem crystal clear.

But a more intriguing question is what Modi, who was elected in May and who since has by many accounts developed a close relationship with Mr. Obama, is up to by showcasing not just India’s historically close ties to Russia, but also warm relations with Putin.

Modi’s message seems to be that, even as a growing India with global ambitions expands its horizons to new partners, it’s not going to forget old friends.

The Indian leader also may be signaling Washington – which to Indian thinking has run hot and cold on India since relations first swung upward under George W. Bush – that the United States shouldn’t expect an exclusive relationship.

At an all-smiles Modi-Putin summit in New Delhi Thursday, India signed up for 12 Russian nuclear reactors to be built over the next 20 years, and concluded a 10-year contract for Russian crude oil supplies. India also agreed to a deal under which it will purchase and assemble in India hundreds of Russian helicopters.

“Even if India’s [defense procurement] options have increased, Russia remains our most important defense partner,” Modi said at the summit’s conclusion.

New Delhi and Moscow maintained strong ties during the cold war, united in part by suspicions of the West. More recently relations experienced some rough patches, especially when Russia decided to sell attack helicopters to Pakistan, India’s cross-border rival. Russia was also miffed when India opted to buy some defense hardware from the US and France.

But at a July summit of the emerging-economy BRICS – Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa – Modi assured Putin that their two countries’ bonds were as strong as ever. Any Indian child asked to name his country’s “best friend” would answer "Russia," he said, “because Russia has been with India in times of crisis.”

By comparison, US-India relations have been more of a roller-coaster, even over the past decade and despite a high-profile re-launching of ties under President Bush that included the lifting of a three-decade moratorium on civilian nuclear deals with India.

Indian officials say Modi quickly developed a close relationship with Obama after Modi's election in May. The new leader, they said, was willing to forget that since 2005 and until he became prime minister, Modi had been barred from entering the US over alleged human rights violations. Modi had been accused of doing little to stop deadly sectarian riots that broke out in his home state of Gujarat in 2002 when he was chief administrator.

Still, there was a distinct ring of déjà vu when Secretary of State John Kerry proclaimed on a State Department diplomatic blog earlier this month that India’s and America’s “destinies are converging” and that “our time has come.”

Modi will no doubt embrace the promise of closer economic ties with the US when he welcomes Obama next month. But in the meantime, he appears to be signaling with the Putin summit that India plans to play the field and won’t cast aside old friends.

How can India be BFFs with both Russia and the United States? (+video) - CSMonitor.com
 
.
. . .
I think India will have to choose one of them eventually. It cant sit on the fence any longer.
 
. . .
India is still playing the non-alignment game.
As long as it works in national interest, then why not. The issue between the west and Russia is not India's problem, it is their power struggle. And let's face it neither side is going to get anywhere. It is India's interest to sat out of issues that doesn't concern it, the same way we have good relations with Israel and Iran.
 
.
Answer is "Be all things to all people and play both ends against the middle".
 
.
As long as it works in national interest, then why not. The issue between the west and Russia is not India's problem, it is their power struggle. And let's face it neither side is going to get anywhere. It is India's interest to sat out of issues that doesn't concern it, the same way we have good relations with Israel and Iran.

Sure, why not.

The most important thing for any country, is national interests.
 
.
Sure, why not.

The most important thing for any country, is national interests.

Even if a known anti west Communist nation .China also moved much carefully in issues concerning annexation of Crimea and sanctions.
Because it is all about the PRC national interest.
Same goes to India .We both have independent foreign policy.
 
.
India has been doing it since 1947. The only departure came when the US sent it's aircraft carrier to attack us.
 
.
The most important thing for any country, is national interests.
Right! There are no permanent friends. Only permanent interests.

The United States on Thursday expressed its disapproval of India concluding defense and nuclear deals with Russia, saying it is not time for "business as usual" with Moscow in the backdrop of its aggression in Ukraine.

Washington also said it is troubled by the presence of the leader of the breakaway Crimean region in President Putin's delegation to India and has sought clarifications from New Delhi about it.

Pissed off, Uncle Sam? You can't browbeat India. We are a proud nation and will do whatever is in our best national interests. Period!
 
. .
Right! There are no permanent friends. Only permanent interests.

The United States on Thursday expressed its disapproval of India concluding defense and nuclear deals with Russia, saying it is not time for "business as usual" with Moscow in the backdrop of its aggression in Ukraine.

Washington also said it is troubled by the presence of the leader of the breakaway Crimean region in President Putin's delegation to India and has sought clarifications from New Delhi about it.

Pissed off, Uncle Sam? You can't browbeat India. We are a proud nation and will do whatever is in our best national interests. Period!

Right, and Russia has been our most reliable partner for a very long time, we have acquired huge industrial and military tech knowledge from them, besides, they always stood by us in every crisis, military or otherwise. We also must not forget that when every major country imposed the US led sanctions against us after the Pokhran test, Russia and France stood by us, reliability pays, as it is said; a friend in need is a friend indeed. :)
 
.
Back
Top Bottom