Guys my article plz support Pakistan

[Spring Onion]

Dear countrymen need you help in supporting Pakistan over Balochistan. im recieving death threats and abusive, threatening mails

Kinldy if anyone of you takeout some time and write to FPC UK about the Seminar conveying to it that it should not indulge in one-sided propoganda type of seminars.

follwoing is my article in this regard kindly take some time.
if therez any problem you can post the content of articles in another post bellow mine.

http://www.paktribune.com/news/index.shtml?150596

 

[Tiki Tam Tam]

Farzana,

I would have loved to support you, but the article itself is rather narrow in outlook!

I am not looking at the aspect regarding the India reference, which seem to be the centre of gravity, but it appears you have not looked at the geostrategic equation wherein, it is not India centric, but there are greater players to include the US and Russia who have a greater stake in the pie.

Neo can brief you on the issue since he knows what I have written on the issue.

 

[Neo]

Sir,

I'm still waiting to see your article on 'sand models', have you finished it yet?
Just curious..:what1:

 

[Tiki Tam Tam]

Sand models?

Just refresh my memory.

 

[Neo]

You mentioned this thru pm during a Kargill thread at WAB, how PA's doctrine was based on 'sand models'...thats all I can recall.

 

[Tiki Tam Tam]

It was the Kargil Plan.

Conceptually daring. However, like sandmodels, the nitty gritties are forgotten or given the go by.

Infiltration is fine, but to maintain secrecy, logistic support and casualty evacuation was forgotten .

Its OK one can infiltrate, but to hang on one requires ammunition, food and medicines in the high altitude and cold. How much can a person carry on his back in the high altitude 18000 ft? If porters and animal transport were used as a regular means for logistics, it would have given away surprise.

Therefore, the plan was not thought through! It was just like a sand model exercises the world over. All think of the tactical plan and all such plans are brilliant; but they never discuss the logistics because that is the hard part of every operation and every plan!

It is like wanting to catch a train based on ideal timings from the house to the railway station and not catering for the traffic jams en route! Naturally, the train is missed and the money lost!

 

[Tiki Tam Tam]

Jana,

Rewrite the article and put it again in the papers.

Just check it out as to who all are interested and the reasons for the same.

Then like a good journalist make conjectures look like the truth and hey presto, it should get you the Pulitzer Prize!

 

[Spring Onion]

Jana,

Rewrite the article and put it again in the papers.

Just check it out as to who all are interested and the reasons for the same.

Then like a good journalist make conjectures look like the truth and hey presto, it should get you the Pulitzer Prize!

Sir its ok you can support your balcoh borthers and government i wont mind :biggrin:

BTW : i dont need a Pulitzer Prize my country is more valuable thn any award

 

[Officer of Engineers]

Therefore, the plan was not thought through! It was just like a sand model exercises the world over. All think of the tactical plan and all such plans are brilliant; but they never discuss the logistics because that is the hard part of every operation and every plan!

Unbelievable, Sir. Just unbelievable. Every command level officer I know must do a 2IC or OpsO. Logistics is pounded into our thinking; especially making sure the Colonel gets his coffee.

 

[Tiki Tam Tam]

Well. Logistics is not a very glamorous thing.

And so the broadbrush.

If you look at the Gulf War, I think the logistics was given a broadbrush inspite of the fact that logistics is a speedier response in the west than our armies.

 

[RAPTOR]

Dear countrymen need you help in supporting Pakistan over Balochistan. im recieving death threats and abusive, threatening mails

Kinldy if anyone of you takeout some time and write to FPC UK about the Seminar conveying to it that it should not indulge in one-sided propoganda type of seminars.

follwoing is my article in this regard kindly take some time.
if therez any problem you can post the content of articles in another post bellow mine.

http://www.paktribune.com/news/index.shtml?150596[/quote]


Love the article Jana, good work. Judging from the nasty coments made by low lives (u get the hint) i believe your article was successful. One way to block the abusive hate mail would be to block all IP addresses from Hindoostan...or as the British named its colony "india".

I fully support your article .:army:

 

[Tiki Tam Tam]

Just to clear the air and let a little sunshine in.

The mineral resources of Pakistan is mostly in Balochistan, The Gas is in abundnace while the largest deposit of copper is there too. In fact, when one wants to know about the mineral resources of Paksitan, it is Balochistan which can say, "You name it, we have it".
http://www.gsp.com.pk/resources/index.html

Therefore, there is no doubt that it is the Crown Jewel of Pakistan.

The Gwadar port in its current state of hinterland development is not of significance, but its strategic value is of utmost interest to China and the USA.

The electronic snooping facilities of China at Gwadar will allow it to monitor the activities of the USA in the Middle East. While the deep water port will allow China to extend its influence in the Indian Ocean and the Arabian Sea to counterbalance the US interest in these areas. Hence, denial of the Gwadar port to China becomes an important strategic issue for the USA.

The US influence in Balochistan is also of importance, apart from the resources which the US companies with better technology can exploit more efficiently than any other country, also allow the US to box in Iran as also permits forays into FATA and NWFP to eliminate the AQ remnants. A pincer from Balochistan and Afghanistan will reap good results.

The Russians are interested in Balochistan so that the US plans to rid the Taleban from Afghanistan is frustrated by encouraging anti US sentiments in the NWFP and FATA so that Afghanistan does not stabilise.

If India is interested in Balochistan then it would be just to copy Pakistan in "extending moral support" to the freedom fighters in Balochistan as Pakistan does in Kashmir.

Pakistan's interest is that it cannot allow its golden goose to be taken away. So air strikes and artillery is but natural against its own citizens.

Given the resources, one can easily surmise as to who is really interested in Balochistan.

 

[Spring Onion]

Just to clear the air and let a little sunshine in.

The mineral resources of Pakistan is mostly in Balochistan, The Gas is in abundnace while the largest deposit of copper is there too. In fact, when one wants to know about the mineral resources of Paksitan, it is Balochistan which can say, "You name it, we have it".
http://www.gsp.com.pk/resources/index.html .

Good on ur part to copycate

China becomes an important strategic issue for the USA..

yeh you think to safeguard US intrestes we should dintergrate our country??
NOWAY MAN.

The US influence in Balochistan is also of importance, apart from the resources which the US companies with better technology can exploit more efficiently than any other country, also allow the US to box in Iran as also permits forays into FATA and NWFP to eliminate the AQ remnants. A pincer from Balochistan and Afghanistan will reap good results.

we are capable of doing that we dont need to allow US grab our land

The Russians are interested in Balochistan so that the US plans to rid the Taleban from Afghanistan is frustrated by encouraging anti US sentiments in the NWFP and FATA so that Afghanistan does not stabilise..

Balochistan has nothing to do with NWFP and FATA.

If India is interested in Balochistan then it would be just to copy Pakistan in "extending moral support" to the freedom fighters in Balochistan as Pakistan does in Kashmir...

Indian involvment can not be justifed bcuz KASHMIR Is an international issue to which India Pakistan and Kashmiries are party.
Its on UN Resolution which if u even dont accept is a reality.

While there is no such resolution about Balochistan cuz its part of Pakistan not an international issue.

Given the resources, one can easily surmise as to who is really interested in Balochistan.

rewrite it as under dear (Given the resources, one can only easily sumarise that who will benefit from toruble in Balochistan {Answer India, US,}
and who is to be benefit from peace in Balochistan ( Answer Pakistan)

So dewar sir Pakistan is only intrested in peace in Balochistan.

 

[Bull]

yeh you think to safeguard US intrestes we should dintergrate our country??NOWAY MAN..

Salim how dare you?

we are capable of doing that we dont need to allow US grab our land.

Who said abt grabbing the land?Salim didnt mention anything even similar.

Indian involvment can not be justifed .

It justifies India's plan ( ie if they are involved),what pakistan think is not India's botheration.

rewrite it as under dear (Given the resources, one can only easily sumarise that who will benefit from toruble in Balochistan {Answer India, US,} and who is to be benefit from peace in Balochistan ( Answer Pakistan)So dewar sir Pakistan is only intrested in peace in Balochistan.

U didnt understand what Salim wrote ,right?

Salim it was a rather poor effort from you, the reciepant didnt understand!!!

 

[Tiki Tam Tam]

The whole exercise was to show who has more interest in the issue of Balochistan amongst the countries people claim are involved and what are their interests, if indeed they are interested..

It in no way suggests that they are!