What's new

German Muslims must obey law, not sharia: Merkel

Nothing

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Jul 2, 2010
Messages
1,205
Reaction score
0
Country
India
Location
United States
BERLIN: Chancellor Angela Merkel said on Wednesday Muslims must obey the constitution and not sharia law if they want to live in Germany, which is debating the integration of its 4 million-strong Muslim population.

In the furore following a German central banker's blunt comments about Muslims failing to integrate, moderate leaders including President Christian Wulff have urged Germans to accept that “Islam also belongs in Germany”.

The debate comes against a backdrop of US and British concerns over the threat of terrorist attacks by militant Islamists living in Germany, with Berlin toning down such fears.

Merkel faces corresponding discussions inside her Christian Democratic Union (CDU) about whether she is conservative enough, and the centre-right leader's latest comments seemed directed at those who think Wulff went too far in appeasing the Muslims.

Wulff, who has a largely ceremonial role, used a speech on Sunday celebrating two decades of German reunification to urge harmonious integration of immigrants who until a decade ago were considered “guest workers” who would eventually return home.

But whereas the media stressed Wulff's comments about Islam, Merkel, the daughter of a Protestant pastor brought up in East Germany, who leads a predominantly Catholic party, said Wulff had emphasised Germany's “Christian roots and its Jewish roots”.

German Christian Democrats often cite shared Judeo-Christian values rooted in the early history of Christianity because of sensitivities about the Holocaust, when the Nazis murdered six million Jews during World War Two.

“Now we obviously also have Muslims in Germany. But it's important in regard to Islam that the values represented by Islam must correspond with our constitution,” said Merkel.

“What applies here is the constitution, not sharia.”

Merkel said Germany needed imams “educated in Germany and who have their social roots here” and concluded: “Our culture is based on Christian and Jewish values and has been for hundreds of years, not to say thousands.”

Opinion polls suggest many Germans sympathise with the views of an outspoken member of Germany's Bundesbank who, in speeches and a book, accused Muslims of sponging off welfare, refusing to integrate and achieving poor levels of education.

Thilo Sarrazin, who also offended Jews with comments about genetics, was forced to quit the central bank. Merkel has tried to accommodate both sides of the debate, saying police should not be afraid of entering immigrant neighbourhoods but also that Germans must accept mosques becoming part of their landscape. -Reuters

DAWN.COM | World | German Muslims must obey law, not sharia: Merkel

One question to all friends - Is that sharia conflict with German laws?It give impression that sharia laws are not good to follow.
 
.
One question to all friends - Is that sharia conflict with German laws?It give impression that sharia laws are not good to follow.

Though I do not have a great deal of knowledge of Sharia but my humble opinion as a human being is that no religion is bad only its interpretation needs review. Interpretation is often done by a select few which is blindly flowed by the rest who form the silent majority.

In the instant case, Merkel is right. If I were to go to my neighbors house or live in new society, I would be expected to abide by the rules of the house / society.

If it irks someone, he is welcome to leave - return to his country of origin in this case.
 
.
Merkel said Germany needed imams “educated in Germany and who have their social roots here” and concluded: “Our culture is based on Christian and Jewish values and has been for hundreds of years, not to say thousands.”

She has been hanging out Bill O'Reily lately ? Or is election around the corner ?
 
.
Merkel said Germany needed imams “educated in Germany and who have their social roots here” and concluded: “Our culture is based on Christian and Jewish values and has been for hundreds of years, not to say thousands.”

Need more ppl like her in India.:agree:
 
.
A wonderful observation by the head of the state.
Cheers.
 
.
Some of her suggestions regarding the assimilation of Muslims into German society are very coherent, but it was impertinent to mention Shariah, as even in Muslims states like Pakistan, we don't follow Shariah then why would Muslims in Germany do so?
 
.
Why India needs people like her, I don't understand. We don't follow Sharia here anyway. Criminal laws are uniform for all Indians regardless of their religion or casts. Yes we have different civil laws(marriage and inheritance) for different religions but there is also an uniform civil law which people can follow if they wish.
 
.
Why India needs people like her, I don't understand. We don't follow Sharia here anyway. Criminal laws are uniform for all Indians regardless of their religion or casts. Yes we have different civil laws(marriage and inheritance) for different religions but there is also an uniform civil law which people have to follow

There, corrected for you.
 
. . .
I would've agreed with the German if she would've pushed for secular values instead of Jewish and Christian values.

This. You can't say culture then push Jewish and Christian values and exclude Sharia law. Hypocritical to say the least. You either run a religious state or a secular one. Seems she is going for the first one.
 
Last edited:
.
She is the head of Christian Democratic Union what else to say. On the positive side German President did mention Jews.
 
.
She is the head of Christian Democratic Union what else to say. On the positive side German President did mention Jews.

We should not bring religion in the matter of law. Germany should integrate muslims in their society with the fact that all laws will be similar for all citizens.
 
.
I would've agreed with the German if she would've pushed for secular values instead of Jewish and Christian values.

This. You can't say culture then push Jewish and Christian values and exclude Sharia law. Hypocritical to say the least. You either run a religious state or a secular one. Seems she is going for the first one.

Many laws originate from the culture of a country, and if the culture of a country is primarily of a Christian origin, the laws will be closer to Christian values as well. It doesn't mean that Muslims (or Hindus) won't have rights, it is just that their customs and culture won't have much of an impact on the law. Of course, culture is just one of the origins, there are many others, otherwise we would still have women burned in the name of Sati in India :tdown:
 
.
I would've agreed with the German if she would've pushed for secular values instead of Jewish and Christian values.

None of them are secular. They just do the drama of being secular, but behind the scenes things are different.

They may have removed religion from state activities, but religion still plays an important role in their lives and perceptions.
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom