What's new

Former defence contractor found guilty of sending US military data to India

NKVD

BANNED
Joined
Dec 26, 2013
Messages
5,157
Reaction score
-18
Country
India
Location
Russian Federation
By: Press Trust of India | New York | Updated: April 2, 2015 12:32 pm
A 49-year-old former owner of defence contracting businesses in the US has been pleaded guilty for illegally sending sensitive military technical data to India as part of a conspiracy in which she worked with an Indian resident.

Hannah Robert, 49, of New Jersey pleaded guilty before US District Judge Anne Thompson to charges that she conspired to violate the Arms Export Control Act by exporting to India military technical drawings without prior approval from the US Department of State.

According to documents filed in the case, from June 2010 to December 2012, Robert conspired to export to India defence technical drawings of parts used in the torpedo systems for nuclear submarines, military attack helicopters and F-15 fighter aircrafts.

Robert founded One Source USA and Caldwell Components that contracted with the US Department of Defence to supply defence hardware and spare parts.

Along with an Indian resident, identified in the complaint only as ‘PR’, Robert owned and operated a third firm located in India that manufactured defence hardware and spare parts.

In addition to US’ sales, Robert sent export-controlled technical data to PR in India so that the two could submit bids to foreign actors, including those in the UAE and Pakistan, to supply them or their foreign customers with defence hardware and spare parts.

Neither Robert nor PR had obtained approval from the State Department for these businesses.

The complaint cited an August 2012 email from PR to Robert requesting a technical drawing of a particular military item.

PR had also forwarded to Robert a request from an individual purporting to be “an official contractor of the UAE Ministry of Defence.”

The UAE e-mail requested quotations for a bid for the “blanket assembly” for the CH-47F Chinook military helicopter and listed the “End User” for the hardware as UAE Armed Forces.

Robert transmitted military drawings for these parts to India by posting the technical data to the password-protected website of a New Jersey church where she was a volunteer web administrator.

Through the course of the scheme, Robert uploaded thousands of technical drawings to the church website for PR to download in India.”

The complaint said there were quality issues also with the parts that Robert provided to the Defence Department.

After the department disclosed in 2012 that certain parts used for the wings of the F-15 fighter aircraft, supplied by Robert’s company One Source, failed, Robert and PR provided false and misleading material certifications and inspection reports for the parts.

These documents listed only One Source USA’s New Jersey address and not the address of the actual manufacturer in India, One Source India.

As a result of the failed wing pins, the Defence Department grounded nearly 47 F-15 fighter aircraft for repair and inspection, at a cost estimated to exceed USD 150,000. As part of her plea agreement, Robert will have to pay USD
181,000 to the Defence Department, including the cost of repair for the grounded F-15s.

Robert also consented to a forfeiture money judgement of about USD 78,000, which represents the dollar value of Robert’s fraudulent contracts with the department.

Former defence contractor found guilty of sending US military data to India | The Indian Express

@Chanakya's_Chant @trident2010 @Abingdonboy
 
.
It is gratifying to know that we also ' get' information and not just lose it.
 
.
Every body does it.

Chalo indians ny bhi mana they also indulge in such activities. So welcome aboard. :welcome::welcome:
 
. . . .
We'll have to think like Israel. All of us; just the Super Six powerful folks in Indian govt thinking won't help if we have to progress.

With the right leadership, we will learn to think like that.

Media is not really doing us any great favour here. But its an necessary evil, just need to be reeled in.
 
.
Not sure how correct the news is. However I guess it is a common practice to do industrial espionage to gain upper hand during business dealing with one another.
 
.
Not sure how correct the news is. However I guess it is a common practice to do industrial espionage to gain upper hand during business dealing with one another.

This is not really a case of Industrial espionage. The person indicted was responsible for sending drawings & other information to her Indian partner so as to manufacture the parts at a cheaper price & sell it in the U.S. and to Pakistan & UAE. Nothing really to do with India except that it was where the factory was. I believe there was some problem with those parts and she was caught when there was an investigation.
 
.
Not sure how correct the news is. However I guess it is a common practice to do industrial espionage to gain upper hand during business dealing with one another.

US has laws about distributing data about products. They need to get govt. approval to share ANY such data.

However marketing and sales professionals need to show such data to the prospective customer to make a sale and cannot wait for the US bureaucratic wheels to turn and "approve" the data to be shared.

This enterprising girl just went ahead and did that, share such data without waiting for US approval.

US in true fashion has sent her to jail for it.

There is no "espionage" here, just a US citizen getting crushed by the Judiciary and US state deciding to make her into an example.
 
.
There's hardy any "critical" technology that she exported or what India does "not posses" or is in dire need of -

(01) Wing pins are critical safety parts that are used to secure the wings of F-15 fighter aircraft - You can source them very conveniently from anywhere in the world - like in this case a Phoenix defense contractor was sentenced fr he just passed off some substandard wing pins from a foreign vendor - Phoenix defense contractor sentenced in F-15 fraud case

(02) CH-47F Chinook Thermal/Acoustic Blankets (Composites) - HAL has pretty matured composites manufacturing facility - mature enough to export composites worth $100 Million to countries like Israel - Apart from that we ourselves manufacture the aft pylon and cargo ramp assemblies (aerostructres) for Boeing’s CH-47F Chinook helicopter her in Bangalore through Dynamatics Technologies. - Dynamatic Technologies produces first Chinook Aerostructures for Boeing » Indian Defence Review

All that went wrong was that she couldn't secure an export license from the DoD - Here in India many such components are manufactured like the Aerostructres for Boeing’s CH-47F Chinook helicopter and Boeing F/A 18 Gun Bay Door - not something really critical in nature.

Miss Robert herself represented a defence contractor firm which was supposed to manufacture those components by it's own but instead she outsourced it to some Indian firm to manufacture the very same thing at a cheaper price and hence earn more profit. If it would have been any sort of critical technology - then she herself wouldn't have got her hands onto it in the first place.

@NKVD - Thanks for the tag mate!
 
Last edited:
.
Contractor tried for extra profit by making in India so cheaply .And got a nice reward.
 
. .
Pakistan should also make symbolic trial of Benazir bhutto for transferring blue prints of Pakistani centrifuges to India, via Iran and that retired/dead general... i forgot his full name Malik Hussain something.
 
.
Pakistan should also make symbolic trial of Benazir bhutto for transferring blue prints of Pakistani centrifuges to India, via Iran and that retired/dead general... i forgot his full name Malik Hussain something.
Sure, Pakistan detonated nuclear device in 1974
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom