For Afghan refugees, Pakistan is home

[EagleEyes]

Sorry Sir

Yeah, like WTF does Kashmiri brothers have to do with the topic?

 

[arp2041]

Yeah, like WTF does Kashmiri brothers have to do with the topic?

I think u haven't seen ajtr's posts, all Indian members do the same "WTF"

 

[Spring Onion]

Makes sense.

By the way, either they need to be given citizenship or send them back. The war on terror is over as soon as the Americans leave.

Thousands of them have Pakistani idenity cards thanks to bribes the NADRA people get and fake CNIC factories in tribal belt.


They need to be settled in their own country but the problem is that situation in Afghanistan is worst and they are NOT willing to go back.

But its time Karzai Govt should bring its people back. Give them jobs instead of foreigners .

 

[EagleEyes]

Thousands of them have Pakistani idenity cards thanks to bribes the NADRA people get and fake CNIC factories in tribal belt.


They need to be settled in their own country but the problem is that situation in Afghanistan is worst and they are NOT willing to go back.

But its time Karzai Govt should bring its people back. Give them jobs instead of foreigners .

Bribes to NADRA must be limited and the fake CNIC, how good is the fake? Those holding fake CNIC should be deported for violation of law.

 

[ajtr]

kashmiris will get out of india along with their land.

 

[SHAMK9]

Thousands of them have Pakistani idenity cards thanks to bribes the NADRA people get and fake CNIC factories in tribal belt.


They need to be settled in their own country but the problem is that situation in Afghanistan is worst and they are NOT willing to go back.

But its time Karzai Govt should bring its people back. Give them jobs instead of foreigners .

well he is busy blaming ISI and Pak Army for every other thing that happens in Afghanistan.

 

[Marwat Khan Lodhi]

What's the general notion of Pakistanis about these refugees ?

My observations say that in KPK including hazara they are treated like just as pashtuns, while punjabis strongely dislike them, dont know about sindhis and balochs. While for mohajirs they are same "pathans" like that of balochistan, FATA and KPK

 

[KRAIT]

Yeah, like WTF does Kashmiri brothers have to do with the topic?

See post # 20.

Told ya, don't feed the troll.

 

[EagleEyes]

kashmiris will get out of india along with their land.

See post #16.

See post # 20.

Told ya, don't feed the troll.

 

[RescueRanger]

Some are well integrated and should be allowed to stay, some like those found in Kharotabad are bad news and should be given the option of Voluntary Return or Enforced Removal.

As for fake NADRA cards, there are many things in the pipe line, include these new shiney babies:

Not a perfect solution, but a solution non the less.

 

[Tayyab1796]

they are not loyal to Pakistan and should be sent back to Afghanistan

Loyalty is lower down the piority list of an empty stomach. I know of a few Afghans who sell roasted corn on their small wooden cart in Lahore . I think that's how they earn their living and doing a service , its a win-win for everyone . The seller makes a living and the society gets her demand of corn fulfilled. Now would it be fair to replace him with a local corn seller just bcz he is a local unless he comes up with a unique product or service or the society generally loses her taste for corn. Please don't involve unbridled nationalism into everything.

 

[Safriz]

Loyalty is lower down the piority list of an empty stomach. I know of a few Afghans who sell roasted corn on their small wooden cart in Lahore . I think that's how they earn their living and doing a service , its a win-win for everyone . The seller makes a living and the society gets her demand of corn fulfilled. Now would it be fair to replace him with a local corn seller just bcz he is a local unless he comes up with a unique product or service or the society generally loses her taste for corn. Please don't involve unbridled nationalism into everything.

I am sorry to say this but why many Pushtoons are so blind in Pustoon nationalism that they cant see the obvious?
Aer you loyal to Pakistan or loyal to Pushtoons only?
Just because Afghans are Pushto speakers does not make them Pakistani...They are not,well most are not.

 

[Jaansher]