What's new

Flour mills’ turnover: Govt urged to withdraw 400pc hike in tax rate

FOOLS_NIGHTMARE

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Sep 26, 2018
Messages
18,063
Reaction score
12
Country
United Kingdom
Location
United Kingdom
The business community Saturday asked the government to withdraw 400 percent hike in the income tax rate on turnover of flour mills otherwise price of 20-kg of bag will jump by Rs90 by July 1 resulting in a severe nationwide crisis.

Wheat flour is a major staple and part of our daily diet which should remain in the buying power of the masses facing unemployment and reduced income due to pandemic and runaway inflation, they said.

Talking to the business community, President of Islamabad Industrial Association (IIA) Shaikh Tariq Sadiq said that the government has proposed an increase in the income tax rate on the turnover of flour mills from 0.25 to 1.25 percent, which is a 400 percent increase in one go that would cause a sharp rise in flour prices.

He demanded that the government should immediately withdraw the unjustified decision to save the general public from high inflation, otherwise, the food insecurity will engulf the country in a way that has never happened before which can result in unpredicted consequences.

Tariq Sadiq said that the sales tax on bran was abolished four years ago which was welcomed by the flour millers but in the current budget a sales tax of 17 percent has been proposed on bran which will also give rise to inflation resulting in restlessness among the masses.

“Flour is a basic need of the people and the high cost of flour has a direct impact on the life of the common man which is finding it difficult to bring food to the table, therefore, the implications of the recent decision should be reconsidered,” he said.

He demanded that government should immediately withdraw the decision to save the people from further miseries braving facing unprecedented inflation.

The IIA President further said that wheat was not available in the market, despite the government’s claim of a bumper crop, while the ECC has decided to import three million tonnes of wheat for strategic reserves.

He emphasized that the government should focus on controlling the hoarding and stop seizing of wheat loaded trucks otherwise, the flour will become more expensive, which cannot be blamed on the flour mills.

Tariq Sadiq said that if this situation continued, the price of a 20kg bag of flour would go up to Rs1,200, which would make Roti more expensive.

He stressed that to save the people from further hardships and difficulties, the government should immediately restore the income tax rate on the turnover of flour mills to 0.25 percent and also withdraw 17 percent sales tax on bran.

He said there are more than 50 flour mills in the ICT only and over 1,000 operating in the country supplying atta to approximately 220 million people.

The Pakistan Flour Mills Association (PFMA) has in a recent emergency meeting appealed to the Prime Minister and the Finance Minister to revisit the taxation measures; otherwise, hike in the price of flour will create, he said, adding that the government has hinted at slapping more taxes for the small industry which is not a welcome move.

Tariq Sadiq, Omais Khattak, SVP, IIA, Muhammad Ahmed and Mohsin Khalid former Presidents ICCI, Malik Sohail Hussain, former SVP ICCI and others were also present at the occasion.

 
.
the government has proposed an increase in the income tax rate on the turnover of flour mills from 0.25 to 1.25 percent, which is a 400 percent increase in one go that would cause a sharp rise in flour prices

The tax is called "income tax" and is supposed to be collected on basis of "turnover" of mill. So why would it cause increase in prices ? Or the mills trying to charge their own "income tax" from customers ?

MATLAB aap pehle aatay Ka tax b Dy or pir floor mill waly Saab Ka income tax b Dy. Or unki beti Kay waleemy Ka kharcha b uthaay Thora bohat. Qunky Bhai aata Jo le rahy na inse.... Ye sab to krna hoga.

Almost all businesses doing this, collecting their "income tax" from customers. When will government punish them for this practice ?
 
.
What is the current price of a 20kg bag. How much is 1.25% of that. Highly doubt it will translate to 90rs per bag even if mill owners are trying to pass the cost into the consumer.
 
.
The tax is called "income tax" and is supposed to be collected on basis of "turnover" of mill. So why would it cause increase in prices ? Or the mills trying to charge their own "income tax" from customers ?

MATLAB aap pehle aatay Ka tax b Dy or pir floor mill waly Saab Ka income tax b Dy. Or unki beti Kay waleemy Ka kharcha b uthaay Thora bohat. Qunky Bhai aata Jo le rahy na inse.... Ye sab to krna hoga.

Almost all businesses doing this, collecting their "income tax" from customers. When will government punish them for this practice ?
I've said it before and I'll say it again, one of the biggest reasons why Pakistan is a poor country is because Pakistanis, especially among the business owners and the elite, cheat Pakistan's tax system.

This tax should not affect prices, this is merely an income tax.
 
.
What is the current price of a 20kg bag. How much is 1.25% of that. Highly doubt it will translate to 90rs per bag even if mill owners are trying to pass the cost into the consumer.

Pir b Bura sirf Imran khan Hy mehngai wo leky Aya Hy. The increase (even if passed down to consumers) should be only RS 15. Aik 2 floor and sugar mills ko awaam aag lagay ge to sab sedhy ho jayn gy
 
.
Pir b Bura sirf Imran khan Hy mehngai wo leky Aya Hy. The increase (even if passed down to consumers) should be only RS 15. Aik 2 floor and sugar mills ko awaam aag lagay ge to sab sedhy ho jayn gy
I would not shed a tear if it happens
 
.
Pir b Bura sirf Imran khan Hy mehngai wo leky Aya Hy. The increase (even if passed down to consumers) should be only RS 15. Aik 2 floor and sugar mills ko awaam aag lagay ge to sab sedhy ho jayn gy
while I agree with you, a part of blame lies with the govt as well (past and present). this is because the govts have failed to control the prices, and have failed to collect taxes from these cheaters. income tax should not translate into increased prices, and its the govt's job to make sure of that. but clearly, nearly all ministers, with the exception of a few, are busy in enjoying their perks and privileges rather than concentrating on work.
I've said it before and I'll say it again, one of the biggest reasons why Pakistan is a poor country is because Pakistanis, especially among the business owners and the elite, cheat Pakistan's tax system.

This tax should not affect prices, this is merely an income tax.
a wealth tax should be imposed. there are a thousand ways to avoid income and sales taxes. but one cannot hide their wealth. even if you have money in off shore accounts, or in cash, you will have something to show for the wealth one has accumulated.
 
. .
Irony.jpg
 
.
I've said it before and I'll say it again, one of the biggest reasons why Pakistan is a poor country is because Pakistanis, especially among the business owners and the elite, cheat Pakistan's tax system.

This tax should not affect prices, this is merely an income tax.
Increase in direct tax collection could theoretically slow private spending and therefore demand. This can dampen economic growth.

There is always a catch in tax policy. Finding the right balance in policy is more art that science. What works for one country, may not work for another :undecided:
 
.
Increase in direct tax collection could theoretically slow private spending and therefore demand. This can dampen economic growth.

There is always a catch in tax policy. Finding the right balance in policy is more art that science. What works for one country, may not work for another :undecided:
It would slow down spending, but with more government revenue coming in, the government would redirect those funds into creating more jobs and newer services for Pakistan.

Economic growth and increased spending without a proper stable economic foundation are recipies for disaster.
 
.
Time for Pakistani to starve for the sake of freedom. It's unfortunate but necessary. Nothing in life is a free ride.
 
. .
Back
Top Bottom