What's new

First of Its Kind, Museum Records Traumatic Legacy of Birth of India and Pakistan

RISING SUN

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jun 1, 2012
Messages
4,015
Reaction score
0
Country
India
Location
India
First of Its Kind, Museum Records Traumatic Legacy of Birth of India and Pakistan
Britain’s division of the Indian subcontinent into two countries 70 years ago led to the largest mass migration in modern history, with more than 12 million people displaced and more than half a million killed.

The traumatic legacy of the birth of India and Pakistan is the focus of a new museum that opened in Amritsar in Punjab, the northern state that witnessed the worst frenzy of violence after its western portions went to Pakistan and the eastern ones to India in 1947.

This violent chapter of history had been almost forgotten, said Mallika Ahluwalia, co-founder of the Partition Museum.

4E44EFBA-457F-4C46-BC77-48FFDD6BE9A8_w650_r0_s.jpg

The CEO of India's new partition museum, Mallika Ahluwalia, looks at a steel trunk, which was among items donated by the relative of a person who had migrated to India during partition in 1947, in New Delhi, India.
Telling their stories

Although fiction and cinema have reflected that troubled time, there was until now no memorial or museum to millions of people caught in partition.

“We found that so many people we talked to say to us that finally someone is hearing their story. For a long time there was no space, either metaphorical or physical, where their story could be told,” Ahluwalia said.

An initiative of the Arts and Cultural Heritage Trust, the museum opened in Amritsar’s restored, British-era Town Hall.

4939A734-8108-4200-87B9-D7FCF3374F45_w650_r0_s.jpg

A worker sorts through photographs, newspaper clippings, and other material, Aug. 12, 2017, that will cover the walls at the Partition Museum, set to open in Amritsar, India, 32 kilometers (20 miles) from the border with Pakistan.
Exhibiting ordinary items that people carried as they fled, as well as photos, newspaper clippings and audio recordings, the museum recreates the time when slaughtering mobs and bloody riots ravaged both sides of the newly created border.

The exhibits tell tales of ruined homes, lives shattered and rebuilt, loved ones lost and found as tens of thousands of Sikhs and Hindus crossed to India and Muslims to Pakistan. They crammed into overcrowded trains, trucks or even crossed rivers clutching whatever they could salvage.

Some displays depict the functional and mundane, such as a sewing machine and boxes. Many had emotional value. A woman carried her wedding sari. A heavy embroidered jacket and a briefcase belonged to a woman and her fiancé, who were separated amid the looting and carnage, but were happily reunited at a refugee camp. A woman has donated a box that as an 8-year-old girl, she pulled out of the rubble of a house hoping to put into it new dolls to replace the ones she left behind.

Violence bore by women

In a section devoted to women, who largely bore the brunt of the violence, the central exhibit is a water well, a tribute to thousands who either jumped into wells or were pushed by their families to keep them from being raped or abducted.

But an embroidered fabric strung on the well exemplifies the many instances of humanity found amid the carnage.

“That phulkari (embroidered fabric) belonged to a woman who jumped into the well along with all her family members when they were attacked, but she was rescued. She was rescued by someone from another community,” Ahluwalia said.

A jute cot, carried by a family, symbolizes the endless stream of refugees, including tens of thousands of affluent families, that huddled in sprawling camps.

7DAEAE34-5CE7-4ADF-B432-BC43D9CCB3A6_w650_r0_s.jpg

A pocket watch of Indian man Pandit Devi Dass, who was killed in mob violence in Pakistan, was later donated by his son to the Partition Museum, in New Delhi, India, July 21, 2017.
Cherished possession

One of them is Jagat Singh, now 90, who traveled from the neighboring city of Jullundur to Amritsar to relate his story.

He escaped the massacre in his village by crossing the Ravi River on a boat when he was a 19-year-old student. Singh still struggles to understand how the harmony between Hindus, Sikhs and Muslims, who lived together in neighboring villages and towns, deteriorated into horrific bloodshed.

“In my hostel, we had friendly and affectionate relations with Muslim students. We used to visit each other’s homes. I don’t know why this turned into violence,” he said.

He has donated his most cherished possession — the documents of an $8 student loan that enabled him to graduate and rebuild his life after he arrived as a penniless refugee.

From stories, understanding

Such stories are helping visitors, especially those of younger generations, understand that it was not just leaders of the freedom struggle from British rule, but also countless ordinary people who paid a heavy price for independence.

Praniti, a law student, said the museum left a deep impression on her.

“It makes me feel so free and so privileged and so aware of how unaware I was,” she said.

It was not just people who were victims. Objects in museums in Punjab also had to be divided between both nations, Ahluwalia said. She points to a necklace dating back to an ancient civilization that had to be split.

We have come across files which have said half of the beads need to go to Pakistan and half to India. Our entire history in a sense they were trying to divide it in a way that is sad — how do you divide a shared heritage?” she asked.

The answer to that question still eludes the South Asian nations that, 70 years on, remain bitter rivals. But even as the scars of partition continue to fester, for many, the exhibit keeps the hope of reconciliation alive.
https://www.voanews.com/a/museum-records-traumatic-birth-of-india-and-pakistan/4039760.html
 
.
Stories of this slaughter should be preserved without nationalistic jargon.

Millions of people were killed, maimed, abducted, raped, and tortured.

The fear many held about the uncertainty of their decision to cross boundaries not yet established or their future in the homes they were given generation after generation. Should be documented and read everyone who increasingly lives a life of expectation.

There are mass graves yet to be found. Hopefully there will be a name for those who occupy them.
 
.
What rank hypocrisy.

Make a similar Museum about the Islamic invasion and see the same "liberal intellectuals" squirm and protest. :sick:

British are the favorite punching bangs while ignoring the rest of history. Bunch of shameless sanctimonious buffoons.

Let them make a similar museum to Terrorism.
 
.
What rank hypocrisy.

Make a similar Museum about the Islamic invasion and see the same "liberal intellectuals" squirm and protest. :sick:

British are the favorite punching bangs while ignoring the rest of history. Bunch of shameless sanctimonious buffoons.

Let them make a similar museum to Terrorism.
Why blame others for the deed done by our forefathers. Yes I say it, it was our own, Hindu, Muslim, Sikh who did the cruel acts in the heat of division which many of us do feel guilty about no matter they were part or not part of our immediate family.
 
.
Why blame others for the deed done by our forefathers. Yes I say it, it was our own, Hindu, Muslim, Sikh who did the cruel acts in the heat of division which many of us do feel guilty about no matter they were part or not part of our immediate family.

The Islamic invaders were not my Forefathers. Maybe they were yours.

What "cruel" act are you referring too ? and what "heat of division" are you talking about ?
 
.
The Islamic invaders were not my Forefathers. Maybe they were yours.

What "cruel" act are you referring too ? and what "heat of division" are you talking about ?
I am talking about the things which happened around both India and Pakistan Independence. What Islamic invadors did to us or not is irrelevant in this disscussion, that can be broader disscussion what impact it had in this Independence violence. You don't believe Islamic invadors came from dark past history and killed all those million if people, don't you?
 
.
I am talking about the things which happened around both India and Pakistan Independence. What Islamic invadors did to us or not is irrelevant in this disscussion, that can be broader disscussion what impact it had in this Independence violence. You don't believe Islamic invadors came from dark past history and killed all those million if people, don't you?

The Isamic invaders killed more than 400 Million Hindus by their own estimate. WTF are you talking about ?

Deaths during partition was PEANUTS compared to that.

I am discussing a Museum to the islamic invaders along the same lines as this museum. What are your thoughts ?
 
.
The Isamic invaders killed more than 400 Million Hindus by their own estimate. WTF are you talking about ?

Deaths during partition was PEANUTS compared to that.

I am discussing a Museum to the islamic invaders along the same lines as this museum. What are your thoughts ?
What you is correct but in wrong way. How can a person or organization build a museum or monument to Islamic invadors? We can only build the museum or monument for those who got silenced or eliminated en masse in distant past history. Too much of hate distorts the history which is already manipulated by all sections of people. Better we should focus on best way possible to salvage what we can before all turns to dust. Thank you.
 
.
What you is correct but in wrong way. How can a person or organization build a museum or monument to Islamic invadors? We can only build the museum or monument for those who got silenced or eliminated en masse in distant past history. Too much of hate distorts the history which is already manipulated by all sections of people. Better we should focus on best way possible to salvage what we can before all turns to dust. Thank you.

Are you kidding me ?

Let me be correct in "right" way.

Build a museum to the 400 million dead Hindus and MILLIONS of Hindu women and child SLAVES and the tens of thousands of castrated Hindus turned into eunuchs in the service of these islamic invaders.

This Museum will put and end to "manipulation of history" that you pretend to hold so dear. Any doubt can be cleared by just one visit to this Museum.

Too much of Hypocrisy distorts your character too. Better you focus on salvaging your principles before the change is irreversible.

What exactly is this museum trying to "salvage" ? and what is turning to dust ?
 
.
Are you kidding me ?

Let me be correct in "right" way.

Build a museum to the 400 million dead Hindus and MILLIONS of Hindu women and child SLAVES and the tens of thousands of castrated Hindus turned into eunuchs in the service of these islamic invaders.

This Museum will put and end to "manipulation of history" that you pretend to hold so dear. Any doubt can be cleared by just one visit to this Museum.

Too much of Hypocrisy distorts your character too. Better you focus on salvaging your principles before the change is irreversible.

What exactly is this museum trying to "salvage" ? and what is turning to dust ?
Let me make it clear to you in one straight line, if you can't understand then don't bother me. You are not obligated to revert if you feel so.
Now on the subject, museum referred to Carnage done by all sides during 20th century is recent and very few of affected people are alive or their belongings are available but it might not be possible to find them 2-3 decades later, forget about a century. Afterwards whatever remains is just hearsay nothing quantifiable. But that doesn't negate the facts that indeed bad things happened in past in both cases of Independence violence or Islamic invadors violance. Now someone has taken the lead to save whatever they could to save the recent historical people accounts or material and that should be applauded appreciated. Same thing applies for Islamic invadors Carnage done to native people in South Asia, will we able to note live tales of people affected during that period, I doubt even with most effective medical tools available, we will get their body samples. It's almost impossible. Can we arrange to get some artifacts or something tangible material of that time period, yes that can and that is being done continuously. I have seen things myself which were at least 2-3 century back(in palace museum). So Ultimately it's upto those who have the means to unearth historical things to bring things and information to light. Thank you.
 
.
At least 2 million died. There can be no other incidence in the history that can be as traumatic as this.
 
.
Let me make it clear to you in one straight line, if you can't understand then don't bother me. You are not obligated to revert if you feel so.
Now on the subject, museum referred to Carnage done by all sides during 20th century is recent and very few of affected people are alive or their belongings are available but it might not be possible to find them 2-3 decades later, forget about a century. Afterwards whatever remains is just hearsay nothing quantifiable. But that doesn't negate the facts that indeed bad things happened in past in both cases of Independence violence or Islamic invadors violance. Now someone has taken the lead to save whatever they could to save the recent historical people accounts or material and that should be applauded appreciated. Same thing applies for Islamic invadors Carnage done to native people in South Asia, will we able to note live tales of people affected during that period, I doubt even with most effective medical tools available, we will get their body samples. It's almost impossible. Can we arrange to get some artifacts or something tangible material of that time period, yes that can and that is being done continuously. I have seen things myself which were at least 2-3 century back(in palace museum). So Ultimately it's upto those who have the means to unearth historical things to bring things and information to light. Thank you.

So to cut the BS short, are you in favor of building a Museum to the survivors of the islamic invasion ?

Don't worry about how to "fill" the museum, leave that to professionals.

At least 2 million died. There can be no other incidence in the history that can be as traumatic as this.

How about the 10 million dead during the Man made Bengal Famine ?

Or about the 2 million death during the man made famine that Auragzeb created by burning down farms and forest ?

Are you looking at "quantity" or "quality" ? I can provide more examples of both if you want to expand your mind. Absolutely free.
 
.
So to cut the BS short, are you in favor of building a Museum to the survivors of the islamic invasion ?

Don't worry about how to "fill" the museum, leave that to professionals.



How about the 10 million dead during the Man made Bengal Famine ?

Or about the 2 million death during the man made famine that Auragzeb created by burning down farms and forest ?

Are you looking at "quantity" or "quality" ? I can provide more examples of both if you want to expand your mind. Absolutely free.

I don't have any idea on that
 
.
So to cut the BS short, are you in favor of building a Museum to the survivors of the islamic invasion ?

Don't worry about how to "fill" the museum, leave that to professionals.



How about the 10 million dead during the Man made Bengal Famine ?

Or about the 2 million death during the man made famine that Auragzeb created by burning down farms and forest ?

Are you looking at "quantity" or "quality" ? I can provide more examples of both if you want to expand your mind. Absolutely free.
Any museum devoted to history is most welcome and yeah to your query I am quite well I'm favor of distant past historical museum. Thank you.
 
.
I don't have any idea on that

Yes, ignorance is bliss.

Funny how museums only come up to re-establish what we already know and not to give us any new information and tell us all that we do not know.

Any museum devoted to history is most welcome and yeah to your query I am quite well I'm favor of distant past historical museum. Thank you.

And do you think the "secular" lobby would allow you to build such a museum dedicated to the victims of the Islamic invasion ?
 
.
Back
Top Bottom