Russia can take comfort in that its peer, Nigeria, is in the same boat.
---
http://ftalphaville.ft.com/2014/11/07/2035652/bearwhales-everywhere/
BearWhales everywhere
Izabella Kaminska Author alerts | Nov 07 11:53
BearWhale
n.
/bâr-weil/
1. A large mythical creature known to operate in FX markets with the explicit intention of shattering upstanding and well-managed currencies like bitcoin, the rouble and the naira. If found to display extreme speculative dumping behaviour, defences must be organised by the champions of the superior currency zone so as to scare the wunderbeast away. These defences usually involve feeding the BearWhale large amounts of unwanted inferior dirty currency until it can physically consume no more and withdraws to its BearWhale cave. A successfully slain Bearwhale is usually cause for much jubilation and festivity within the defending community.
As FT Alphaville
reported on Thursday, a BearWhale is stalking the Russian rouble and has been doing so for a few months now. Whilst the Russian central bank was quick to put up defences it seems that, as yet, conventional strategies for dealing with BearWhale threats are failing to scare it away:
Questions are now being asked whether Russia’s CBR may be dealing with a new breed of BearWhale. And, if so, whether the conventional strategy of just throwing dollars at it is actually effective?
(BearWhale Image courtesy of
Reddit)
As the
FT reports, the rouble touched new lows against the dollar on Friday on concerns that Russia’s central bank had decided to put a cap on the amount of dollars it would throw at the BearWhale in the near future.
The Central Bank of Russia said on Wednesday that it would not spend more than $350m a day buying roubles to ease the currency’s slide, pledging to allow the exchange rate to be determined “predominantly by market factors”, although it stands ready to make one-off interventions.
As Citi’s Ivan Tchakarov sums up the CBR’s new defence strategy seems to be focused on unpredictability (our emphasis):
The menu of options to address the RUB weakness are limited, yet well known. The CBR all but eliminated the currency corridor against the RUBBASK on Nov 5th, reducing its fixed interventions and making its presence in the FX market less predictable. While we suspect that the CBR is hoping that next week’s new policy tool of FX Repo will alleviate the tensions, there are two more conventional measures — raise rates even further by a lot (300-500bpts) and/or massively and unpredictably intervene in the FX market. The former measure could weigh on the struggling economy, but overall financial stability should always be of paramount importance. We believe the latter tool should also be employed in addition to the FX Repo.
And if that doesn’t succeed, the Russian Central Bank could well bring out the big guns: namely the building of giant capital control walls that:
Some forms of capital controls may no longer be considered an exotic avenue to pursue, but maybe a legitimate policy tool to be employed to preserve financial stability. We have argued elsewhere that the current policy mix in Russia is characterized by a tight fiscal and tight monetary policy and that the current macroeconomic and geopolitical backdrop correctly necessitates such a policy mixture. However, the sliding currency creates now an environment that may no longer be properly managed only by tightening monetary policy and that may need to be addressed by introducing some restrictions on the ability to freely move capital. These may take the form, for example, of enforcing obligatory sales of FX revenues to alleviate pressures on the FX market.
Meanwhile, over in Nigeria, a declining oil price has led to mounting speculation that the country could be forced to devalue, awakening a BearWhale attack all of its own:
On Friday the Nigerian Central Bank
announced it could no longer ignore the threat, and said it would be prepared to defend the currency via the conventional strategy of BearWhale dollar-feeding, something that has slowed the run at least intermittantly:
But as Bank of America Lynch noted on Friday, while there may be political will to keep the naira stable — especially ahead of February’s elections — it’s not at all clear if the country’s FX reserves are sufficient enough to defer the devaluation option for too much longer, especially if oil prices continue to fall:
As markets digest the normal, we assess the level of FX reserve adequacy in Nigeria. Our own measure of adequate reserves (to safeguard stability in the event of an external shock) is between $44bn and $66bn and the current reserves of $39.4bn are some 10% below this level. Although there’s strong political will to keep Naira stable, the possibility of Naira devaluation will increase if oil prices keep sliding lower.
The Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) remains committed to exchange rate stability before the 2015 Presidential elections and FX reserves may fall to as low as $30bn (as they did earlier this year) to support the currency. However, in the absence of an oil price recovery, we do not rule out a devaluation in 2015, especially given the dovish bias of the new CBN Governor Godwin Emefiele.
So whilst BoAML believe the feeding of the BearWhale is likely to continue by means of the central bank’s twice weekly auctions, they add that it will likely take ever greater dollar sums to keep things stable :