What's new

Far right terrorist shoots up synagogue US California

waz

ADMINISTRATOR
Joined
Sep 15, 2006
Messages
21,159
Reaction score
91
Country
Pakistan
Location
United Kingdom
Police are investigating a manifesto apparently posted online by the suspect in a San Diego synagogue shooting that left one dead and several others injured.

John T. Earnest, 19, was taken into custody without incident following the shooting at the Chabad of Poway Jewish congregation around 11.30am PT on Saturday, according to the San Diego County Sheriff's Department.

Killed in the attack was Lori Gilbert-Kaye, 60, according to a family friend.

The three injured victims were identified as: Rabbi Yisroel Goldstein, who was shot in the fingers; an eight-year-old girl visiting from Israel; and the girl's 34-year-old uncle Almog Peretz, also visiting from Israel.

A manifesto posted online shortly before the attack and purporting to be by Earnest cites hatred of Jewish people as the motive for the attack, and takes credit for a separate arson attack on an Escondido mosque last month.

The manifesto also cites as inspiration attacks on mosques in New Zealand last month, and a deadly shooting at a Pittsburgh synagogue exactly six months ago.

Earnest is believed to be a nursing student at California State University and has no known criminal record.

Police say the suspect is a resident of San Diego who was armed with an AR-15-style semi-automatic rifle. There is initial suspicion that the weapon may have jammed during the shooting, limiting the loss of life.

An armed off-duty Border Patrol agent who was inside the synagogue returned fire at the shooter, who then retreated in a vehicle before calling 911 and surrendering to police without incident, according to police.

Earnest was a dean's list student at California State University, San Marcos, university President Karen S. Haynes confirmed in a statement.

In the 4,000-word manifesto posted online before the shooting, which is filled with sarcastic jokes and references to internet and video game culture, the author described himself as a 19-year-old nursing student and native of California.

The author of the manifesto said that he had been playing piano since the age of four. Video from social media shows that Earnest is a talented piano player.

'If you told me even 6 months ago that I would do this I would have been surprised,' the author wrote. 'I’m just a normal dude who wanted to have a family, help and heal people, and play piano.'

Police confirm one dead and shooter in custody after synagogue attack

He wrote that he was inspired by the attack on mosques in Christchurch, New Zealand where 50 died last month and the suspect in that case, Brenton Tarrant.

'Tarrant was a catalyst for me personally,' the manifesto reads. The author also references the shooting at a Pittsburgh mosque exactly six months to the day before the Poway attack, as well as the suspect in that case, Robert Bowers. Both Bowers and Tarrant are in custody.


Like Tarrant in his own writings, the manifesto author states that his end goal is to prompt the U.S. government to begin confiscating guns, predicting that a civil war will ensue. The author said he had been planning the attack for four weeks.

The manifesto author also states that he committed an unsolved arson attack against the Dar-ul-Arqam mosque in Escondido on March 24, adding that he spray-painted the message 'For Brenton Tarrant' in the parking lot of the mosque.

The author of the manifesto says that he does not support President Donald Trump, calling the president 'Jew-loving' and 'anti-White'.

Much of the manifesto consists of a long list of detailed grievances against Jewish people, accusing them of planning a genocide against the 'European race'.

There are indications in online postings that the shooter planned to live-stream the synagogue attack on Facebook, but did not succeed.

An anonymous post on the imageboard 8chan, posted roughly 30 minutes before the attack, linked to the manifesto and Earnest's Facebook page, promising a live stream, which never occurred.

The 8chan post also included a 'playlist' of songs for the attack and a goodbye note.

The post does not specify an intended target, but makes clear that an imminent attack of some kind is planned.

At least one person says they saw the post and alerted the FBI, according to a post on Twitter. The person said that they got off the phone only eight minutes prior to the shooting, making a tactical response all but impossible.

'We are collecting digital evidence and are aware of the manifesto,' San Diego County Sheriff Bill Gore said at a press conference.

Gore said that Earnest had no prior criminal record, and no known ties to white supremacist groups. He said Earnest lived with his parents.

Public records show that Earnest's father is a high school teacher and the president of an orthodox Presbyterian church in Escondido. The manifesto stated that the shooter did not get his beliefs from his family.


Saturday's shooting unfolded during services on the last day of Passover, and there are believed to have been about 100 people inside the synagogue at the time of the attack.

Witnesses say the gunman was wearing a tactical vest and a helmet, according to CBS 8. The reports have not yet been confirmed by police.

Rabbi Goldstein, who founded the Chabad center in 1986, was reportedly shot and lost two fingers.

Witnesses say the rabbi tried to calm the gunman and members of the congregation even after he was wounded.

President Donald Trump responded to the shooting in remarks to reporters on the South Lawn of the White House as he departed for a rally in Green Bay, Wisconsin.

'Based on my last conversations, it looks like a hate crime. Hard to believe,' Trump said. 'My deepest sympathies go to the families who were affected.'

'It looks like the person has been apprehended, no more danger, and law enforcement has done a fantastic job,' he continued.

Once at the rally, Trump made additional remarks, calling the shooting 'horrific' and saying, 'we forcefully condemn the evil of anti-Semitism and hate, which must be defeated.'

'Incredible response today by law enforcement. And I especially want to recognize a certain off-duty border patrol agent who bravely returned fire and helped disrupt the attack and saved so many lives. Border patrol!' added Trump.

President Trump speaks out after the SoCal synagogue shooting


Poway Mayor Steve Vaus, speaking from a police command center, characterized Saturday's shooting as a 'hate crime,' saying his assessment was based on statements uttered by the gunman when he entered the synagogue.

Police disclosed nothing else about a possible motive. But San Diego County Sheriff Bill Gore said investigators were reviewing the suspect's social media posts and 'his open letter.'

Gore told reporters that four people were struck by gunfire and taken to Palomar Medical Center, where one of the victims, an 'older woman,' died.

The attack occurred shortly before 11.30am in Poway, a suburb of about 50,000 residents, when the suspect walked into the synagogue and started shooting, Gore said.

As he was making his getaway, an off-duty U.S. Border Patrol agent who was inside the synagogue opened fire on the suspect, striking the vehicle but apparently missing the suspect, according to Gore.

The gunman was arrested a short time later when he peacefully surrendered to police.

A San Diego officer was en route to the shooting scene when he overheard a California Highway Patrol (CHP) radio dispatch 'of a suspect who had called into CHP to report that he was just involved in this shooting and his location,' San Diego Police Chief David Nisleit recounted.

'The officer was actually on the freeway and he clearly saw the suspect in his vehicle. The suspect pulled over and jumped out of his car with his hands up and was immediately taken into custody,' Nisleit said.

He said the rifle believed to be the murder weapon was found on the front passenger seat of the car.

The synagogue was hosting a holiday celebration beginning at 11 a.m. and due to culminate in a final Passover meal at 7 p.m.

Authorities said about 100 people were inside the temple, where Saturday services marking the Jewish Sabbath would have been under way or have just concluded.

Minoo Anvari, an Iranian refugee who said her husband was attending services inside when gunshots rang out, told KUSI-TV the wounded included a female friend and the rabbi, who was shot in the hand. 'We are united. You can't break us. We are in the U.S.,' Anvari said.

A man who lives nearby, Christopher Folts, said on CNN he heard six to seven gunshots, then a man yelling, followed by six to seven more shots.

Cantor Caitlin Bromberg of Ner Tamid Synagogue, down the street from the shooting scene, said her congregation learned of the shooting at the end of their Passover services and that they were heading to Chabad of Poway to show support and help.

'We are horrified and upset, and we want them to know we are thinking of them,' Bromberg told The Los Angeles Times, adding that she has not heard from Chabad of Poway leadership because they would not normally use the phone during the Sabbath.

'They would only do that on emergency basis, if they do it at all,' Bromberg told the newspape

Major Vaus told CNN that members of the congregation attempted to overpower the gunman.

'This shooter was engaged by people in the congregation and those brave people certainly prevented this from being a much worse tragedy,' Major Vaus stated, adding that the shooter had 'hate' in his heart.

It's believed the man fired between 12 and 14 shots inside the center.

Witnesses say that even after being shot, Rabbi Goldstein called for unity and prayer among the congregation.

'Rabbi said, 'We are united,'' said Anvari, a refugee from Iran.

'This is something bad (that) is happening all over. And we have to believe that this bad thing is real and we don't have to ignore it. We have to open our eyes. He prayed for peace. I respect him -- even in spite of being injured he refused to go to hospital and he spoke. And he finished his speech and he then left the synagogue.'

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/ar...d-gun-man-opens-fire-San-Diego-Synagogue.html



12805816-6967437-image-m-13_1556415439853.jpg
 
.
Just because since 1940s the far right have found 'new' targets in the form Muslims, it does not follow that their original hate has been forgotten about. This should serve a warning to those amongst the Jewish community who indulge in inciting giving fuel to Islamaphobia. The same fire can also take on the form of Anti-Semitism. equally extremists Muslims need to recognize that Jews are also victims in the bigger picture.
 
. . .
This is really sad, And the world thought the Nazi were all done for.
I remember listening to this jewish leader from L/A on Israel Radio telling American jews who called into the show via phone that they need to be careful as eventually Christians are gonna get em in the US. This was like 6 years ago maybe? He spoke more freely about these issues on his webpage but it's probably not there any more. I think it was true torah or something like that ...
 
.
United states is a hotbed and recruitment ground for white nationalists something which their media hides it really well, some of the most vile and hateful material against Muslims and Jewish people comes from the United states and obviously finds avid readers in Europe, Australia etc. In fact Western European Neo-Nazi revival couldn't have happened without Neo Nazis in America, they are well funded and organised organisations whose sole goal is to spread hatred against Jews, Arabs, Muslims and basically anyone non White Christian.
 
.
America needs to do more against right wing white terrorists, Trump needs to stop supporting them


Police are investigating a manifesto apparently posted online by the suspect in a San Diego synagogue shooting that left one dead and several others injured.

John T. Earnest, 19, was taken into custody without incident following the shooting at the Chabad of Poway Jewish congregation around 11.30am PT on Saturday, according to the San Diego County Sheriff's Department.

Killed in the attack was Lori Gilbert-Kaye, 60, according to a family friend.

The three injured victims were identified as: Rabbi Yisroel Goldstein, who was shot in the fingers; an eight-year-old girl visiting from Israel; and the girl's 34-year-old uncle Almog Peretz, also visiting from Israel.

A manifesto posted online shortly before the attack and purporting to be by Earnest cites hatred of Jewish people as the motive for the attack, and takes credit for a separate arson attack on an Escondido mosque last month.

The manifesto also cites as inspiration attacks on mosques in New Zealand last month, and a deadly shooting at a Pittsburgh synagogue exactly six months ago.

Earnest is believed to be a nursing student at California State University and has no known criminal record.

Police say the suspect is a resident of San Diego who was armed with an AR-15-style semi-automatic rifle. There is initial suspicion that the weapon may have jammed during the shooting, limiting the loss of life.

An armed off-duty Border Patrol agent who was inside the synagogue returned fire at the shooter, who then retreated in a vehicle before calling 911 and surrendering to police without incident, according to police.

Earnest was a dean's list student at California State University, San Marcos, university President Karen S. Haynes confirmed in a statement.

In the 4,000-word manifesto posted online before the shooting, which is filled with sarcastic jokes and references to internet and video game culture, the author described himself as a 19-year-old nursing student and native of California.

The author of the manifesto said that he had been playing piano since the age of four. Video from social media shows that Earnest is a talented piano player.

'If you told me even 6 months ago that I would do this I would have been surprised,' the author wrote. 'I’m just a normal dude who wanted to have a family, help and heal people, and play piano.'

Police confirm one dead and shooter in custody after synagogue attack

He wrote that he was inspired by the attack on mosques in Christchurch, New Zealand where 50 died last month and the suspect in that case, Brenton Tarrant.

'Tarrant was a catalyst for me personally,' the manifesto reads. The author also references the shooting at a Pittsburgh mosque exactly six months to the day before the Poway attack, as well as the suspect in that case, Robert Bowers. Both Bowers and Tarrant are in custody.


Like Tarrant in his own writings, the manifesto author states that his end goal is to prompt the U.S. government to begin confiscating guns, predicting that a civil war will ensue. The author said he had been planning the attack for four weeks.

The manifesto author also states that he committed an unsolved arson attack against the Dar-ul-Arqam mosque in Escondido on March 24, adding that he spray-painted the message 'For Brenton Tarrant' in the parking lot of the mosque.

The author of the manifesto says that he does not support President Donald Trump, calling the president 'Jew-loving' and 'anti-White'.

Much of the manifesto consists of a long list of detailed grievances against Jewish people, accusing them of planning a genocide against the 'European race'.

There are indications in online postings that the shooter planned to live-stream the synagogue attack on Facebook, but did not succeed.

An anonymous post on the imageboard 8chan, posted roughly 30 minutes before the attack, linked to the manifesto and Earnest's Facebook page, promising a live stream, which never occurred.

The 8chan post also included a 'playlist' of songs for the attack and a goodbye note.

The post does not specify an intended target, but makes clear that an imminent attack of some kind is planned.

At least one person says they saw the post and alerted the FBI, according to a post on Twitter. The person said that they got off the phone only eight minutes prior to the shooting, making a tactical response all but impossible.

'We are collecting digital evidence and are aware of the manifesto,' San Diego County Sheriff Bill Gore said at a press conference.

Gore said that Earnest had no prior criminal record, and no known ties to white supremacist groups. He said Earnest lived with his parents.

Public records show that Earnest's father is a high school teacher and the president of an orthodox Presbyterian church in Escondido. The manifesto stated that the shooter did not get his beliefs from his family.


Saturday's shooting unfolded during services on the last day of Passover, and there are believed to have been about 100 people inside the synagogue at the time of the attack.

Witnesses say the gunman was wearing a tactical vest and a helmet, according to CBS 8. The reports have not yet been confirmed by police.

Rabbi Goldstein, who founded the Chabad center in 1986, was reportedly shot and lost two fingers.

Witnesses say the rabbi tried to calm the gunman and members of the congregation even after he was wounded.

President Donald Trump responded to the shooting in remarks to reporters on the South Lawn of the White House as he departed for a rally in Green Bay, Wisconsin.

'Based on my last conversations, it looks like a hate crime. Hard to believe,' Trump said. 'My deepest sympathies go to the families who were affected.'

'It looks like the person has been apprehended, no more danger, and law enforcement has done a fantastic job,' he continued.

Once at the rally, Trump made additional remarks, calling the shooting 'horrific' and saying, 'we forcefully condemn the evil of anti-Semitism and hate, which must be defeated.'

'Incredible response today by law enforcement. And I especially want to recognize a certain off-duty border patrol agent who bravely returned fire and helped disrupt the attack and saved so many lives. Border patrol!' added Trump.

President Trump speaks out after the SoCal synagogue shooting


Poway Mayor Steve Vaus, speaking from a police command center, characterized Saturday's shooting as a 'hate crime,' saying his assessment was based on statements uttered by the gunman when he entered the synagogue.

Police disclosed nothing else about a possible motive. But San Diego County Sheriff Bill Gore said investigators were reviewing the suspect's social media posts and 'his open letter.'

Gore told reporters that four people were struck by gunfire and taken to Palomar Medical Center, where one of the victims, an 'older woman,' died.

The attack occurred shortly before 11.30am in Poway, a suburb of about 50,000 residents, when the suspect walked into the synagogue and started shooting, Gore said.

As he was making his getaway, an off-duty U.S. Border Patrol agent who was inside the synagogue opened fire on the suspect, striking the vehicle but apparently missing the suspect, according to Gore.

The gunman was arrested a short time later when he peacefully surrendered to police.

A San Diego officer was en route to the shooting scene when he overheard a California Highway Patrol (CHP) radio dispatch 'of a suspect who had called into CHP to report that he was just involved in this shooting and his location,' San Diego Police Chief David Nisleit recounted.

'The officer was actually on the freeway and he clearly saw the suspect in his vehicle. The suspect pulled over and jumped out of his car with his hands up and was immediately taken into custody,' Nisleit said.

He said the rifle believed to be the murder weapon was found on the front passenger seat of the car.

The synagogue was hosting a holiday celebration beginning at 11 a.m. and due to culminate in a final Passover meal at 7 p.m.

Authorities said about 100 people were inside the temple, where Saturday services marking the Jewish Sabbath would have been under way or have just concluded.

Minoo Anvari, an Iranian refugee who said her husband was attending services inside when gunshots rang out, told KUSI-TV the wounded included a female friend and the rabbi, who was shot in the hand. 'We are united. You can't break us. We are in the U.S.,' Anvari said.

A man who lives nearby, Christopher Folts, said on CNN he heard six to seven gunshots, then a man yelling, followed by six to seven more shots.

Cantor Caitlin Bromberg of Ner Tamid Synagogue, down the street from the shooting scene, said her congregation learned of the shooting at the end of their Passover services and that they were heading to Chabad of Poway to show support and help.

'We are horrified and upset, and we want them to know we are thinking of them,' Bromberg told The Los Angeles Times, adding that she has not heard from Chabad of Poway leadership because they would not normally use the phone during the Sabbath.

'They would only do that on emergency basis, if they do it at all,' Bromberg told the newspape

Major Vaus told CNN that members of the congregation attempted to overpower the gunman.

'This shooter was engaged by people in the congregation and those brave people certainly prevented this from being a much worse tragedy,' Major Vaus stated, adding that the shooter had 'hate' in his heart.

It's believed the man fired between 12 and 14 shots inside the center.

Witnesses say that even after being shot, Rabbi Goldstein called for unity and prayer among the congregation.

'Rabbi said, 'We are united,'' said Anvari, a refugee from Iran.

'This is something bad (that) is happening all over. And we have to believe that this bad thing is real and we don't have to ignore it. We have to open our eyes. He prayed for peace. I respect him -- even in spite of being injured he refused to go to hospital and he spoke. And he finished his speech and he then left the synagogue.'

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/ar...d-gun-man-opens-fire-San-Diego-Synagogue.html



12805816-6967437-image-m-13_1556415439853.jpg

he can't talk as his tongue is stuck up some right wing white arse

@Solomon2 What you say?

12805816-6967437-image-m-13_1556415439853.jpg


The lad looks innocent to me.
 
.
Police say the gunman walked into the suburban San Diego synagogue late on Saturday morning, the last day of the week-long Jewish holiday of Passover, and killed one woman and wounded three other people inside, using an assault-style rifle.

According to authorities, the suspect, John Earnest, then fled in a car before calling police to hand himself in.

“We believe he acted alone and without outside support in carrying out the attack,” San Diego County Sheriff Bill Gore said in a statement.

The suspect, who is also under investigation for a mosque arson, has been booked into custody on one count of murder in the first degree and three counts of attempted murder in the first degree, Gore said.

At an emotional news conference on Sunday, Rabbi Yisroel Goldstein choked back tears as he spoke of the slain victim, Lori Kaye, whom he had known for 25 years.

“She was a pioneer member from our congregation,” he said, his left arm in a sling and his right hand bandaged. “Lori had unconditional love for all.”

Goldstein had surgery at a hospital after his right index finger was blown away by the gunman. He recounted how after he saw the carnage, he grabbed a prayer shawl, wrapped it around his bloody hands and addressed the congregation.

“We are a Jewish nation that will stand tall, we will not let anyone or anything take us down – terrorism like this will not take us down,” Goldstein said he told the worshippers.

The other two wounded in the attack on the Congregation Chabad temple in the town of Poway, about 23 miles (37 km) north of San Diego, were an 8-year-old Israeli girl and her uncle. Their family had moved to the United States in search of a safer life after their home in Sderot on the Gaza border was hit several times by Palestinian rocket attacks.

A candlelight vigil is held at Rancho Bernardo Community Presbyterian Church for victims of a shooting incident at the Congregation Chabad synagogue in Poway, north of San Diego, California, U.S. April 27, 2019. REUTERS/John Gastaldo
The sheriff said they were struck by shrapnel but were “doing well” at a hospital.

Goldstein said U.S. President Donald Trump had called him to offer condolences on behalf of the American people.


https://www.reuters.com/article/us-...ed-alone-san-diego-sheriff-says-idUSKCN1S406S

Police examine motive of man accused of deadly California synagogue attack

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-...dly-california-synagogue-attack-idUSKCN1S50O2
Suicide bombings during Easter Sunday services at several churches in Sri Lanka killed more than 250 people. A gunman who opened fire at two mosques in Christchurch, New Zealand, on March 15 left 49 people dead and more than 40 wounded, some as they knelt in prayer.

Gore told reporters that authorities were investigating Saturday’s attack as a potential hate crime.

A rambling, violently anti-Semitic, anti-Muslim screed written by an individual calling himself John Earnest was found posted online, with links to the content posted on a far-right forum on the internet message board 8chan.

In that letter, the author also claimed credit for the Escondido mosque arson, which was put out by congregants who were sleeping inside and woke up to the smell of smoke. Local media at the time reported that a message scrawled on the driveway of the mosque mentioned the New Zealand massacre.

Earnest was enrolled at California State University in San Marcos. In a statement, the university’s president said the school was “dismayed and disheartened” to learn Earnest was a student and was working with the sheriff’s department.

Earnest attended Mt. Carmel High School in San Diego, where his father taught physics before retiring in 2016, according to the San Diego Union-Tribune newspaper.

Reporting by Bridget Clerkin in Poway, California; Additional reporting by Steve Gorman in Los Angeles, Joseph Ax in Princeton, New Jersey and Keith Coffman in Denver; Editing by Daniel Wallis, Lisa Shumaker and Peter Cooney
 
.
RIP to victims, the kid does not come off as type to do that, it's clear some people beginning to think it is worth it to lose their life over these causes, which is not a good trend for the US/Europe. Another person was arrested in a domestic terrorist plot likely meaning he was trying to target government building/officials and/or places of worship:

 
. .
I hope jew propaganda brigade will learn something, fuelling the fire of islamophobia will not reduce anti semitism. Jews will feel the heat too...
the Jews are incredibly pragmatic there are fine with antisemitism s long as it benefits them
 
.
I hope jew propaganda brigade will learn something, fuelling the fire of islamophobia will not reduce anti semitism. Jews will feel the heat too...

The Jews instigate Islamophobia in the Western world to have temporary security, but the question is until when. The West has a history of anti-Semitic behavior. The far right continues to agitate anti-Jew feelings. Anti-Semitism is all time high. There is no escape for Jews. No matter how much the Zionists try to propagate Jewish Christian unity, they are destined to hate each other. History doesn’t lie.
 
.
RIP to victims, Fast recovery to the injured.
Can't wait to see what that piece of sh!t Ben Shapiro has to say about this!
 
Last edited:
.
This was a sad, yet avoidable incident. This bloke was another product of 8Chan, who was influenced by the ChristChurch Massacre and wanted to replicate the same against the Jews in the synagogue. Luckily his weapon jammed he made a run for it, thus saving countless lives. I was listening to the Rabbi who lost his fingers, it was truly heartfelt. Its about time White Nationalism to be categorized same as Islamist terrorism.


Just because since 1940s the far right have found 'new' targets in the form Muslims, it does not follow that their original hate has been forgotten about. This should serve a warning to those amongst the Jewish community who indulge in inciting giving fuel to Islamaphobia. The same fire can also take on the form of Anti-Semitism. equally extremists Muslims need to recognize that Jews are also victims in the bigger picture.

Any form of discrimination will eventually end up at Jewish targets. The Israeli Right wingers must understand this point, they are trying to befriend Devil, sooner or later it will come calling for its dues.

But overall we must not look at Jews as a monolith group, as not all jews support this rightwing behavior, infact few of the most local opponents of this are mostly Jewish groups.

@Solomon2 What you say?

12805816-6967437-image-m-13_1556415439853.jpg


The lad looks innocent to me.

And how exactly you reached this conclusion?

the Jews are incredibly pragmatic there are fine with antisemitism s long as it benefits them

Yes, just like Muslims are fine with terrorism as long as Jihadists get their goals. Youre being ridiculous here.

The Jews instigate Islamophobia in the Western world to have temporary security, but the question is until when. The West has a history of anti-Semitic behavior. The far right continues to agitate anti-Jew feelings. Anti-Semitism is all time high. There is no escape for Jews. No matter how much the Zionists try to propagate Jewish Christian unity, they are destined to hate each other. History doesn’t lie.

Labeling all jews as supporting Islamophobia is no different to saying all muslims are responsible for what ISIS is doing or for that matter other terrorist groups.
Yes overall the right wing white nationalism will eventually turned against Jews, but those jews who are supporting them are doing it solely for short term geopolitical gains, which in the long run will hurt Jews.
 
.
Yes, just like Muslims are fine with terrorism as long as Jihadists get their goals. Youre being ridiculous here.

the problem with Muslims that they follow there religious text to the word
not like Jews and Christians who routinely break and bend there doctrine for there own benefit im just saying we should be more like them
 
.
Back
Top Bottom