Evidence that Sikhs are Indians

[- Singh Saab -]

Just because they speak Pashto does not make them Pakhtun. Sikhs are found as far west as Afghanistan but they are all migrants who took on local trades etc. They are no more Pakhtun then I would be Japanese if i spoke Japanese and ate Sushi. Being Pakhtun is about blood.

Don't they look Pashtun to you? They also have afridi surname, how else can they prove if they are pashtun?

 

[Indus Pakistan]

Don't they look Pashtun to you? They also have afridi surname, how else can they prove if they are pashtun?

Some of them do. I have seen Sikhs in UK from Jullunder who could pass off as Pakhtun but this is result of the past wars and miscegnation.

 

[- Singh Saab -]

What do you mean, like taking an *** kicking from hindus? In that case no, that is something only indian Punjabis are capable of.

Are you intellectually incapable of understanding the difference between ethnicity and religion? @waz @WebMaster @The Eagle Please take note of this guys comments.

 

[- Singh Saab -]

Some of them do. I have seen Sikhs in UK from Jullunder who could pass off as Pakhtun but this is result of the past wars and miscegnation.

So if they were really pashtun, how could they prove it to you?

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

btw that's not true, Sikhism is a religion not an ethnicity, there are many non-punjabi sikhs. Even in Pakistan, you can go to peshawar and see pathan afridi-sikhs who are not punjabi.

Those sikhs are not pashtuns but punjabi settlers who settled there during the ranjit era.
They do speak panjabi in their homes but younger generation doesnt speak muh panjabi due to influence of Pashto and urdu.
Sikhs of afghanistan are also panjabi.

 

[- Singh Saab -]

Those sikhs are not pashtuns but punjabi settlers who settled there during the ranjit era.
They do speak panjabi in their homes but younger generation doesnt speak muh panjabi due to influence of Pashto and urdu.
Sikhs of afghanistan are also panjabi.

Please see the videos I have posted above of Pashtun Sikhs while replying to people who made same comment as you.

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

So if they were really pashtun, how could they prove it to you?

By their mother tongue and panjabi castes.
Pashtuns have tribes unlike Panjabis.
You will nevet find any sikh from KPK having Pakhtun surnames like Afridi, Mehsud/Maseed,Wazir, Khattak, Bhittani, Loni, Khilji/Ghilzsi, Yousafzai, Nasir etc.

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

Please see the videos I have posted above of Pashtun Sikhs while replying to people who made same comment as you.

Bro half my family is Pashtun, in my native Balochistan we also have hindus who speak Balochi. We also have marathas (panipat prisoners) who also speak balochi.

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

Please see the videos I have posted above of Pashtun Sikhs while replying to people who made same comment as you.

I have Sikh friends from University bro.

 

[- Singh Saab -]

By their mother tongue and panjabi castes.
Pashtuns have tribes unlike Panjabis.
You will nevet find any sikh from KPK having Pakhtun surnames like Afridi, Mehsud/Maseed,Wazir, Khattak, Bhittani, Loni, Khilji/Ghilzsi, Yousafzai, Nasir etc.

Bro I have literally posted videos of Afridi Sikhs

 

[ARMalik]

I don't know whether Sikhs do toxic office politics and manipulation but I do know some Sikhs do maskebaazi, chaplusi a lot. Since you don't know about my Sikh friends, let me give an example of a famous Sikh: Cricketer Harbhajan Singh. He never misses an opportunity to butter - on camera or off camera. He doesn't spare anyone. Be it umpires or ground staff or teammates or captain or board members or former cricketers or anyone. Once a TV crew was asking questions to Harbhajan after the match. After one sentence, he got started, "Mr X ne bahut achhi fielding kii. Mr Y bahut achche ballebaaz hai. Mr Z sabse mushkil batsman hai bowlers ke liye." He went on for a very long time. All irrelevant flattery. Even in the movie 'Mujhse Shadi Karogi' where he played a cameo, he exploited the opportunity to do buttering by inserting his own dialogue. Be it needlessly socializing with ground ball boys in West Indies, or joking with umpire Rudi Koertzen, or asking unnecessary doubts to ex-bowler Sivaramakrishnan, or breaking into traditional tribal jig with African bowler of SA team, or loudly supporting Ganguly during Greg Chappell controversy, Harbhajan has tremendous energy to praise everyone who comes in his sight. Who else but an Indian would have such a psyche? Such quintessentially Indian trademark. Sikhs are Indians after all. We had a sardar very similar to Harbhajan in our college.

But there is other extreme also. An example is Bishen Singh Bedi. He is brutally frank. He has come very hard on Muralitharan and Ganguly. But if Bishen Bedi is impressed, he is generous with praise also.

- PRTP GWD

India is a geographical term. It is no more a united nation than the Equator.

Winston Churchill

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

Bro I have literally posted videos of Afridi Sikhs

Bro there are no afridi sikhs, Afridi is a karlnari tribe.

 

[- Singh Saab -]

Bro there are no afridi sikhs, Afridi is a karlnari tribe.

Did you see the video I posted above of Inderjeet Singh Afridi?

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

Bro I have literally posted videos of Afridi Sikhs

Its called assimilation bro. These ppl have been living here since generations and so have been christians.. both although are not ethnically Pakhtun but today consider them belong to the clans dominating the regions.

Tirah Sikhs glad at getting status of tribal elders

Sikhs say returning home will be their ultimate happiness.

www.dawn.com

 

[- Singh Saab -]

Its called assimilation bro. These ppl have been living here since generations and so have been christians.. both although are not ethnically Pakhtun but today consider them belong to the clans dominating the regions.

Tirah Sikhs glad at getting status of tribal elders

Sikhs say returning home will be their ultimate happiness.

www.dawn.com

So if they were actually pakhtuns, how could they prove it? First you said they should speak pashto which they do, they you said they should have afridi surname which they do, what else is required from them to prove that they are real pakhtuns?