Enough of secular non sense, declare India as Hindu state.

[ebrahym]

birthplace of secularism or go to Pakistan and fight for secular home land of former India. We are not going to give any inch of land to seculars.

now thats funny

 

[Emmie]

A secular constitution doesn't make any difference, it's the secular ideology that makes a difference. Indian constitution is secular, it doesn't necessarily mean India as a state is secular, mr Thackeray knows it better. You can't alter things that don't exist at all. India has some lessons to learn from Pakistan, but then its only the will of Indians that matters. nobody should have any problem.

 

[John Reese]

upreme Court will never allow such thing to happen because you cannot play with the basic structure of the constitution, though there is no proper definition of the word "Basic Structure" given by the Supreme Court but I am quiet sure that Supreme Court will just scrap such Constitutional Amendment.

How Does they Scrap If they all will be Impeached By 2/3 Majority of the Parliament
Since Impeachment is Part of Constitution SC will be Shunned

Remember shah bano case

 

[Abba_Dabba_Jabba]

How Does they Scrap If they all will be Impeached By 2/3 Majority of the Parliament
Since Impeachment is Part of Constitution SC will be Shunned

Remember shah bano case

Yeah heard about that case, it was just pathetic. The congi sycophants of radical muslim mullah just didn't worry about the condition of Shah Bano and went against the rule. That was one of the black day in the history of Parliament and India, where a lady was deprived of justice by some Islamic mullah goons.

Plus I have just read that Shia Law board did support the absolute maintenance for the ladies in case of divorce.

 

[Anubis]

The secular Bengalis are more than welcome to join a secular Bangladesh under the leadership of Sheikh Hasina.
@Rain Man @Joe Shearer

We can send our Islamists and your Hidutvabadis to Myanmar where they start a civil war and we can reclaim Rakhaine state. It can't get any better than this.

 

[Grevion]

Its Udhav Thakrey from the aamchi Shivsena. Do not expect much sane words from him.
Let India stay the way it is. It is the will of the people and the love between the communities that makes a nation stronger.

 

[Indika]

Very big difference. Hindu is no different than Muslim after radical organizations trying to take leaderships representing Hindus (RSS/VHP etc). Hinduism under RSS have a free go if the nation is declared Hindu nation. Besides, 18 crore or Muslims, Christians and other minorities also live here. There lives will be threatened by Hindutva rule. The example of present BJP-RSS rule is enough to tell what can happen if Hindutva fascists are given free hand. Let the Indian union remain one, crush the virat hindus and ummah craving j1hadis and uphold secularism.

BJP came to power on economic agenda any dilution in that will lead to defeat at the hustings. Most of often BJP has won by division of votes but when if they dont deliver on economic progress they will be thrown out no matter whether they claim hindu or non-hindu state.

The secular Bengalis are more than welcome to join a secular Bangladesh under the leadership of Sheikh Hasina.
@Rain Man @Joe Shearer

We can send our Islamists and your Hidutvabadis to Myanmar where they start a civil war and we can reclaim Rakhaine state. It can't get any better than this.

They will never fight each other. They will only make others die.

 

[Joe Shearer]

You have issue with India becoming Hindu state?

Why bring alcohol and non veg out of your rear?

Because of the crap you bring out of your rear and spread over these pages.

UK being a secular country has Anglican churches as part of state ,declaration is useless what matters is how the laws are framed.In fact one can oppose minority communalism/appeasement better in a secular umbrella.

The UK is not a secular state. The Anglican Church is an established church. It is part of the state.

NO , Constitution is secular by its intent .Article 25-28 constitute bedrock of secularism.

Article 25. Freedom of conscience and free profession, practice and propagation of religion.
Article 26. Freedom to manage religious affairs.
Article 27. Freedom as to payment of taxes for promotion of any particular religion.
Article 28. Freedom as to attendance at religious instruction or religious worship in certain education institutions.

Moreover fundamental rights of equality 14 15 and 16 say none can be discriminated on basis of caste,religion and gender.

So 42nd Amendment Act had done only cosmetic change in Preamble about secularism.Nothing more.

Not according to sour malcontents and closet bigots like @ranjeet ; he will not agree with any of this.

We will get our independence. We do not belong to India as RSS and VHP do.

You HAVE GOT your independence.

There is a time and a place for everything, @haviZsultan ; this is not a place for your Lucknow drama. Please stay out.

I think you are in Pakistan , how you get independence from RSS and VHP while living in Pakistan and by last update Pakistan is independent country .... not sure what you are typing

He is a good man, but has a bee in his bonnet about the unfortunates whom he and his near and dear ones were forced to leave behind. This makes him talk with a sense of belonging and ownership, both mingled in an ardent embrace, about Lucknow in particular. Just be indulgent, and overlook his occasional very ill-timed and inappropriate outbursts.

It's this "COSMETIC" product that leftists/rights groups/political parties used liberally to screw over Hindus. The bastardized version of the word was used to paint every hindu who demanded for his/her rights as Sanghi.

Modi was demonized by "Secular" folks for his "role" in 2002 but swear by the word introduced by a lady under whose able leadership more than 6 million males (mostly muslims) were forcible sterilized.

Nobody screwed over Hindus except pseudo-Hindus like you who are confused yourselves and therefore have made it your life's ambition to confuse other Hindus. Fortunately, you are not doing too well. Your distortions are so obvious that only your own level of intellect gets taken in.

 

[DesiGuy1403]

I am in Haryana at the time drinking alcohol and eating non-veg. Which are sins in Hinduism so come and do the deeds.

Drinking and eating non veg are sins for Hindus?!
Oh my...some one forgot to tell me. You see, I am a Sanghi, a proud one and I have been eating meat all my life. Yeah, I have enjoyed wine now and then as well.

Now stop spreading what ever the crap you are trying to spread.

Declare India a hindu state and be ready to part with south, north and east India. You will only have only UP, Bihar etc to graze your cows.

Yeah, come to South Andhra and try to harm a cow...They will show you things that will make you feel UP as heaven.

Instead its me who is declared insane

welcome to the club.
Why your village. There are enough Hindu hating Indian racist bigots here as well to name and shame us

We can send our Islamists and your Hidutvabadis to Myanmar where they start a civil war and we can reclaim Rakhaine state. It can't get any better than this.

well sir, let us evil hindutvavadis graduate to slitting other religious people's throats shouting our gods name before you send us away to battle.

Until then, spare us please.

 

[Anubis]

Drinking and eating non veg are sins for Hindus?!
Oh my...some one forgot to tell me. You see, I am a Sanghi, a proud one and I have been eating meat all my life. Yeah, I have enjoyed wine now and then as well.

Now stop spreading what ever the crap you are trying to spread.



Yeah, come to South Andhra and try to harm a cow...They will show you things that will make you feel UP as heaven.



welcome to the club.
Why your village. There are enough Hindu hating Indian racist bigots here as well to name and shame us



well sir, let us evil hindutvavadis graduate to slitting other religious people's throats shouting our gods name before you send us away to battle.

Until then, spare us please.

Don't worry.....out Islamists will most definitely eat beef and slaughter enough cows infront of you guys during eid for you to kill them.

 

[DesiGuy1403]

Don't worry.....out Islamists will most definitely eat beef and slaughter enough cows infront of you guys during eid for you to kill them.

Oh My...Indian secular posters on PDF will be thrilled by your comments..
Wait for the positive rating for this fantastic post by our own Racist bigots..

 

[Soulspeek]

Who said anything about cow slaughter? Its already banned and out of respect for Hindus most dont do it. Its only extreme fringe like Kancha Illaiya etc who advocate cow slaughter.

Its all about accommodation. Muslims should respect Hindu sentiments and vice versa. Role of the Govt is to ensure that there should be no vote banking politics and appeasement of any kind.

Yeah, come to South Andhra and try to harm a cow...They will show you things that will make you feel UP as heaven.

 

[DesiGuy1403]

Its all about accommodation. Muslims should respect Hindu sentiments and vice versa. Role of the Govt os to ensure that there should be no vote banking politics and appeasement of any

You won't find any Sanghi disagreeing with that.

 

[Anubis]

Oh My...Indian secular posters on PDF will be thrilled by your comments..
Wait for the positive rating for this fantastic post by our own Racist bigots..

I doubt you understand what racism is.....secularism is pretty non-discriminatory...you should know....you haven't been tortured to death by the Christians of Australia for heresy.....paganism doesn't play well with Christianity....the only reason you are breathing in Australia right know is because of secular ideals.

 

[dadeechi]

Could someone define what is a Hindu state?

NO , Constitution is secular by its intent .Article 25-28 constitute bedrock of secularism.

Article 25. Freedom of conscience and free profession, practice and propagation of religion.
Article 26. Freedom to manage religious affairs.
Article 27. Freedom as to payment of taxes for promotion of any particular religion.
Article 28. Freedom as to attendance at religious instruction or religious worship in certain education institutions.

Moreover fundamental rights of equality 14 15 and 16 say none can be discriminated on basis of caste,religion and gender.

So 42nd Amendment Act had done only cosmetic change in Preamble about secularism.Nothing more.

And how any of them contradict India being a Hindu state? The above actually support that India was indeed a Hindu state.