What's new

Embarking on railway carriage manufacture.

Homo Sapiens

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Feb 3, 2015
Messages
9,641
Reaction score
-1
Country
Bangladesh
Location
Bangladesh
Embarking on railway carriage manufacture
Published: November 01, 2017 23:09:52

1509556192.jpg


The move to turn the railway repair workshop at Syedpur into a full-fledged carriage-making plant is an indication of greater focus on the country's railway neglected so far. An efficient railway network cannot be developed without appropriate infrastructure. The Bangladesh Railway (BR) had long been in a moribund state before its indispensability was recognised for mass transportation. It is ludicrous to import luxury buses at astronomical costs and concentrate on developing motorised routes in a country known for its abnormally large population. People's and good's movement - the faster it is the better -is indicative of economic growth. The railway is considered people's transportation for it is fast, smooth and can carry a large number of passengers at a time. Bus, taxi and car journeys are highly costly and common people cannot afford those. A strong comeback for the railway is eagerly awaited with the anticipation that it will be able to meet the growing need of mass transportation in the country.

In that task, the construction of a carriage-producing plant at Syedpur will be a modest step towards fulfilling the objective. Yet it will save the country billions of dollars now spent on import of passenger coaches and freight wagons. But still the carriage manufacturing factory reportedly will not be constructed before 2021. However, there is more to do now. Undeniably, the metre gauge railway tracks cannot serve the purpose of an extensively developed and fast railway system. The option for broad gauge rail tracks is there and all future development programmes for the BR should be undertaken in the light of such tracks. Or, else, there is every chance of a mismatch in the system like the one involving the Demu railway carriages. Compatibility between the platforms and the Demu trains were missing and also the coaches were reportedly unsuitable for weather here.

Clearly, there is need for large investment in the BR if it has to develop into a very efficient and capable service. But impressions it sometimes gives are contrary to expectation. When engineers argue that bamboos can be used to maintain worn-out railway tracks, it sounds puzzling, to say the least. The country's railway tracks are not in the best of shapes. Even the endemically slow trains cannot gather the speed they are capable of lest the tracks give in. So here is a candidate for big investment.

Ultimately, the policymakers should set their sight on introducing electric trains sometimes in the future. True, the government will always feel the financing constraint on embarking on railway development projects. In that case, public-private partnership (PPP) funding can be a way out. What is the harm of gradually dispensing with large investment in import of luxurious buses and persuading private investors to go for investment in railway? Foreign finance in the construction of the factory for carriage production will constitute the bulk of the cost. If this is so, similar initiatives for investment in railway tracks and other facilities for operating electric trains can as well be explored.
https://thefinancialexpress.com.bd/editorial/embarking-on-railway-carriage-manufacture-1509556192
 
. .
Why does BD even need railways, it has such a small land mass, better to spend that money on more roads
 
. . .
Why does BD even need railways, it has such a small land mass, better to spend that money on more roads

No offense. What makes you think like roads are more efficient than rail? Basically if we had enough investment in water and rail way, the roadway would have gone total obsolete. Dont consider Bangladesh as a desert. Regards
 
.
Belated but a great development. This will indeed save a lot of money.

Railway and waterway development and management should be fundamental to a broad national transportation plan.
 
.
No offense. What makes you think like roads are more efficient than rail? Basically if we had enough investment in water and rail way, the roadway would have gone total obsolete. Dont consider Bangladesh as a desert. Regards

no offense taken since i dont work for or own a road constructon company, and where does the desert reference comes from. Railroad becomes obsolete once road are made available its not the other way.

Pakistan also such a small land.Why Pakistan need railway?

From Karachi to Peshawar, its 1500 miles

Railway is the cheapest and most efficient form of transport for both goods and people. Higher density encourages use of rail even further.

true if you have long distances
 
.
true if you have long distances

Plenty of low distance trips in Europe etc. It helps to add alternative to road network. Don't want to hedge on one completely.

Also watch these BD people here celebrating now. When it transpires down the road in reality who will be actually doing the capital-side work like with their "Russian" nuclear reactor project...they will have a month or two of crying rona dona BAL = traitors drama and then go silent about it :P. A funny enjoyable trend.
 
.
I am skeptic about the efficiency of a railway workshop owned by the government ministry producing coaches successfully, efficiently and cheap.

- Not successfully: the coach mission may not see the day light because people in BD are fond of putting cart in front of the horse. Shortly, they cannot prepare working plans.
- Not efficiently: Even if Bangladesh Railway ministry finally starts to build coach in 2021, the work will not be as efficient and smooth as it should be, because people in BD are unable to organize an efficient team. They may not believe in preparing an efficient master plan, and monthly and weekly schedules.
- Not cheap: Because of low efficiency of the engineers, foremen and labors, the production cost will soar. As a result, the value of the coaches will soar and the Railway will again decide to import from Indonesia and India. It will be cheaper to buy from other countries.

I believe, private companies should be offered the opportunity, where they will build the coaches successfully, efficiently and cheap. I also believe that the building of goods wagon should precede the coaches. It will provide the companies an opportunity to build a strong organization that will build the wagons cheap, efficiently and successfully. Wagons are less difficult to build.

For now, I find only one person in BD, Obaidul Qader, who is a very efficient minister. He understands how to tackle an engineering problem with engineering solution. He should be given the charge of this project if the govt finally decides to build the workshop under railway ministry. But, no one has eternal life.
 
.
From Karachi to Peshawar, its 1500 miles
Karachi to Pashawar is 1351 km or 840 miles.You can check this to confirm.
For Bangladesh, Teknaf to Tetulia is 900 km.You can also check this to confirm.

But the point is, Pakistan is also a small country by land area.How can you claim a country, 36th position in land area to be a big one? You can't claim any country of big when it is not even 1 million sq. km.So my point stand correct, If Bangladesh doesn't need railway for such a small size then Pakistan also don't need it due to it's small size.
 
.
no offense taken since i dont work for or own a road constructon company, and where does the desert reference comes from. Railroad becomes obsolete once road are made available its not the other way.

From Karachi to Peshawar, its 1500 miles, true if you have long distances

There are at least three main distances. long, medium and short for railway. In and around Tokyo there are 278 railway stations that serve at least 25 short and medium railway lines. Short lines are within or just around Tokyo and medium ones run from the junction stations within or almost within Tokyo. These are mostly commuter trains. Then, there are 10s of long distance trains from Tokyo to Osaka, Hiroshima, Nagoya, Hakodate and many more destinations.

So, you cannot just say a small country like Bd needs no railway and only a road system will suffice. You are wrong in your assumption. A country needs different modes of transportation for human as well as goods traffic.
 
.
So, you cannot just say a small country like Bd needs no railway and only a road system will suffice. You are wrong in your assumption. A country needs different modes of transportation for human as well as goods traffic.
Do you think he don't know about that? Necessity of railway doesn't depend on country size, Otherwise Czech Republic, a country, geographically half the size of Bangladesh would not have 9,500 km rail track(more than Pakistan).
 
Last edited:
. .
...Undeniably, the metre gauge railway tracks cannot serve the purpose of an extensively developed and fast railway system. The option for broad gauge rail tracks is there and all future development programmes for the BR should be undertaken in the light of such tracks. Or, else, there is every chance of a mismatch in the system like the one involving the Demu railway carriages. Compatibility between the platforms and the Demu trains were missing and also the coaches were reportedly unsuitable for weather here.
What's this? "Demu trains"? What other gauge or gauges are we talking about here?

A country needs different modes of transportation for human as well as goods traffic.
And perhaps different railways for people and goods.

In the U.S. we tried building one or two high-speed railway tracks fifty years ago. They worked fine for a bit, until freight trains - weighing ten times or more what a passenger train does - wore them out fast. Now we use Swedish tilt-trains for higher speeds but we are still decades behind much of the rest of the world when it comes to passenger train travel.
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom