Do you consider Pakistan to be a Middle-Eastern nation?

[Maula Jatt]

Pakistan is Pakistan, it doesnt need any association with any region. It's the world most ancient civilisation, an entire ecosystem on it's own.

But, buy, but

I am an indian everything is mine

Your civilization is mine too

Mine, mine, mine, I'll throw tantrums if it's not mine

Do you know ancient Martians were Hindus converted to these Muslims?

They were part of Akhand Bharat too

Need a proper campaign to reclaim Indus cause who is living in the Indus eco-system rn?...

Not "mine, mine, my only, my precious, culture vultures"
...

 

[magra]

But, buy, but

I am an indian everything is mine

Your civilization is mine too

Mine, mine, mine, I'll throw tantrums if it's not mine

Do you know ancient Martians were Hindus converted to these Muslims?

They were part of Akhand Bharat too

Need a proper campaign to reclaim Indus cause who is living in the Indus eco-system rn?...

Not "mine, mine, my only, my precious, culture vultures"
...

Thanda paani piyo, saas phool rahi hai tumhari

 

[Maula Jatt]

Thanda paani piyo, saas phool rahi hai tumhari

This how your hindutava bros sound like to Pakistanis

 

[Novus ordu seclorum]

Put the question to people from the Middle East and you will get the answer.

 

[halupridol]

@Indus Pakistan
I have come to Love this kind of identity crisis threads.
#BhayyaDreams

 

[Maira La]

Maybe he has Indian ancestry who knows, lots of Indians in middle east just saying .
Indians look like Indians mate, a foreigner looking like an Indian is an anomaly not the norm. We have our unique looks that make us alike and differences that vary from person to person. For every example of a Punjabi/Haryana person looking different there will be countless examples of them looking similar to people from other parts of India, same case for other states.
Not that looks really matter as long their citizenship is Indian, Indians can be green Martians for all I care as long as they are proud Indians. Just enough with the aryan propaganda trying to create divide.

Yours is just opinion, but there is scientific basis for what I am saying.

Look at the genetic distance from Punjabi Khatri to Pamiris and an average Indian from Andhra Pradesh.

The Khatri is closer to the Pamiri. If you didn't know what Pamiris look like see below..

So why should they be in a country with you rather than Pamiris?
You could maybe make a cultural case for it, but then again the only Khatri I know told me they don't like Khatris from UP ("cultural difference" according to him but made no sense to me since I know UP Khatris are originally migrants from Punjab) so I doubt they are very fond of identifying with other Indians, and if a large part of the Punjabi population have this psychology then it makes a good case for separation of identity (and country).

 

[magra]

Yours is just opinion, but there is scientific basis for what I am saying.

Look at the genetic distance from Punjabi Khatri to Pamiris and an average Indian from Andhra Pradesh.

View attachment 771233


The Khatri is closer to the Pamiri. If you didn't know what Pamiris look like see below..
View attachment 771234


So why should they be in a country with you rather than Pamiris?
You could maybe make a cultural case for it, but then again the only Khatri I know told me they don't like Khatris from UP ("cultural difference" according to him but made no sense to me since I know UP Khatris are originally migrants from Punjab) so I doubt they are very fond of identifying with other Indians, and if a large part of the Punjabi population have this psychology then it makes a good case for separation of identity (and country).

India is not one country due to similarity of features, or language, or religion. You would have to be an Indian to understand why India is one country.

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

Do you consider Pakistan to be a Middle-Eastern nation?
View attachment 770824
View attachment 770826
View attachment 770827

An interesting question. One that would be best answered using facts rather than conjectures.

Is Pakistan Middle Eastern? The truth is that Pakistan is situated on the fulcrum point where the Middle East, Central and South Asia meet. So in a geographical sense, Pakistan is just as Middle Eastern as it is Central or South Asian. From a racial and genetic point of view, the countries that Pakistan has the most in common with is Afghanistan and parts of South East Iran. Approximately 40% of Pakistan's population has some sort of genetic link to either Afghanistan, Iran or both. Nearly 55% of Pakistan's population is indigenous to the area that is modern day Pakistan.

Due to propaganda and bureaucratic convenience from the days of the British Raj, some falsely believe that Pakistanis are racially the same as indians. That is COMPLETELY FALSE as has been proven many times over the years on PDF, hence I won't go in to detail here again. AT MOST, 2% of indians from north west india have SOME sort of racial or genetic link to Pakistan. So at least 98% of modern day indians have NO racial or genetic links to 100% of modern day Pakistanis, WHATSOEVER.

From a cultural, religious and political point of view, the country that affects Pakistan the most is Afghanistan, as recent events and those going back 40 years have shown. What happens in Afghanistan internally has a DIRECT & PROFOUND impact on Pakistan.

So from looking at all the above facts, one can gather that Pakistan in it's truest sense is neither a Middle Eastern, Central or South Asian country. We are a unique nation with a unique culture and way of life. Do we have a lot in common with the Middle East and Central Asia? Yes we do. We are similar to Middle Eastern nations and peoples but at the same time we are different too. Pakistan's position vis-a-vis Middle Eastern nations can be best compared to the Czech Republic and their connections to Western Europe. The Czech Republic is where Western, Central and Eastern Europe meet. The Czech Republic is very similar to Western Europe in many ways but is also fundamentally different too.

 

[El Sidd]

India is not one country due to similarity of features, or language, or religion. You would have to be an Indian to understand why India is one country.

True.

Despite hosting 1.5bn people, genetic diversity in India is lower than most central African artificial states.

There are three entities forced into a union, Bharat, Hindustan and India.

 

[magra]

There are three entities forced into a union, Bharat, Hindustan and India.

Curious to know what you mean by this statement

 

[Maira La]

India is not one country due to similarity of features, or language, or religion. You would have to be an Indian to understand why India is one country.

Is India one country because you understand something magical or because East India Company army made it one country? You are fooling no one.

 

[El Sidd]

Curious to know what you mean by this statement

Bharat
Hindustan
India

These are 3 distinct nations with different identity and purpose.

 

[magra]

Is India one country because you understand something magical or because East India Company army made it one country? You are fooling no one.

I have no interest in educating you why we are one country unless you are thinking of relocating to India.

Bharat
Hindustan
India

These are 3 distinct nations with different identity and purpose.

These are just different names of the same nation. What distinct nations they are as per you?

 

[Maula Jatt]

India is not one country due to similarity of features, or language, or religion. You would have to be an Indian to understand why India is one country.

Why is India one country?,...

Maybe my argument of indo-centric was wrong, there is no "India"

I have no interest in educating you why we are one country unless you are thinking of relocating to India.

These are just different names of the same nation. What distinct nations they are as per you?

Oh C'mon don't duck now

 

[magra]

Why is India one country?,...

Oh C'mon don't duck now

If you want to be next Adnan Sami, I can tell you