It is irrelevant whether you 'buy' it or not. The first, true government in South Asia was formed under the representative government of the Republic of India. That is the strongest power till date and reflects the will of the Indian people. Everything before that is an accident of history. One of your pet rulers- Nizam of Hyderabad, was stingy, hoarded cash, lived in the same pair of clothes for weeks, stunk because he wouldn't take a bath for months...you think he is someone people wanted to be a ruler? His existence was an accident of histoy, one that the modern republic extinguished. You can waste your time thinking about whatever theories you want to, it is irrelevant to us,