and who made you the judge to hand over certificate of Muslim to people?your example makes no sense. Javed Akhtar isnt muslim. he doesnt have islamic knowledge to talk about whether muslims can say vande mataram or anything about islam. its like i go to debate the rocket scientist about rocket science when i dont know anything about the subject, but i show up as an expert because my dad was a rocket scientist. even the most basic islamic knowledge is enough to know that vande mataram isnt allowed in islam. to hell with the hindus feelings.
My logic is the same. Muslim League assumed that it is the judge to decide who can represent Muslims.
Same way you are assuming the role of a judge here.