Dalit girl's limbs chopped off for resisting rape in UP, India

[Masterchief]

replaced by BJP Brahmins chopping off more girls limbs, worse than Taliban.

first of all BJP is a party not a criminal organization and you just proved to be an idiot to compare it with taliban, second thing, we are very happy to be democratic, communism doesnt and wont suit us because we love to live at our will, not at government's. So sir you should better shut up when you dont know anything about us .

 

[rockstarIN]

Is the problem political entities' specific ??

No, its more a moral and administrative specific.

In India, the common practice is (I think the whole south asia too incl. Pakistan)

Commit a crime, immediate arrest, few weeks of police custody, then bail.

The case will be fought in court for years, so the guy is free till that time. And once the verdict comes, he might get free or punished. If punished, will go to jail and again court battles for years. And at last, the higest court rules he is guilty (by that time, he might served half or full of his sentence.

The problem is there is a concept in the society that, you commit a crime, there is a higher chance to get out of it. It will take years to find the guilty. And the maximum sentence is life imprisonment, which 14 years.

Now there is a trend in Indian Court verdicts that they impose to serve the terms differently.( like life imprisonment for murder 14yrs + destruction of evidence 3 years over and above), no parole for 20 years & life impresonment with specifie terms (life impresonment means minimum of 35 years without parole)...we need such changes in the judiciary system, we still follow the old British system...

 

[rockstarIN]

Death penalty for the criminals.
Nothing less-Nothing else

slow death damn it. Let them fight for years in court for the case and finally capital one

 

[Roybot]

god save uttar pradesh,i dont know y ppl choose this mayawati again n again...
today her guard was polishing her shoe.shameful moment

Its the demographics of Uttar Pradesh. Not a single community is a majority there. So its all caste based politics and rivalry. And not to forget the population of 190 million. That state needs to be divided into three parts at least for effective governance and development.

 

[cross1993]

Its not that bad, its seems like a huge number probably cause of the huge population. Have a look at the rape statistics here

Rapes statistics - countries compared - NationMaster

Also I think China needs to be colonized by Japan again, so that people like you stop yapping away without any data to back up your claims.

China has never been the Japanese colonial rule, Only occurred in the war. China is the winner of the last.

 

[Kyusuibu Honbu]

replaced by BJP Brahmins chopping off more girls limbs, worse than Taliban.

Mind telling us all how you came to the following conclusions:
1.The perpetrators are Brahmins.?
2.They are from BJP?
3.Did the whole thing have a caste-violence angle?

Please share your intuition with us,i'm sure the UP Govt will be equally interested

 

[Skull and Bones]

slow death damn it. Let them fight for years in court for the case and finally capital one

That's what m afraid of, they are influential people and surely they'll exploit our judicial loopholes

 

[Black Widow]

More proof that only communism can save India.

30 years communists rule West Bengal. Still Naxals are there... Gun can't solve the problem... there is famous saying in India "Communism and communalism can justify the unjustified" ...

@ topic... Its really bad happening these days in India... (especially on ladies). hope the policy makers are looking into this issue... One more thing I need to clarify , The people who did it were from the same community (so called caste), so its not case of racial abuse.

Media is taking good role, they are highlighting all such issue, it may help society to become cautious..

 

[Karachiite]

Oh god this is barbaric and just sad.

 

[LaBong]

Was the girl raped because of her caste? Why Dalit has been added to thread title when the actual news headline doesn't mention it?

Do we say Brahmin girl is raped if the victim is Brahim by caste? :/

Pretty pathetic of people to twist headlines to suit their own agenda. Thread reported.

 

[SpArK]

Sad incident in the lawless lands of UP.

 

[Stumper]

Its the demographics of Uttar Pradesh. Not a single community is a majority there. So its all caste based politics and rivalry.

I disagree. It's not just the politician's. The people of this land are equally to blame.

One of the Indian member suggested "Dont compare this with Taliban". I say "Why Not?"

The only reason, such incident happens in this central states is because of the religious intolerance, caste based discrimination practice, Racial discrimination, gender bias ...and lastly.... no regards for law of the land.

Tell me now, is this any different from the Taliban's?

Sad, the land of Jayprakash Narayan, is reduced to this level.

Regards.

 

[Stumper]

Was the girl raped because of her caste? Why Dalit has been added to thread title when the actual news headline doesn't mention it?

Do we say Brahmin girl is raped if the victim is Brahim by caste? :/

Pretty pathetic of people to twist headlines to suit their own agenda. Thread reported.

Abir: Do you not agree that the people of the state in question does practice caste based discrimination? ... Do you disagree that racial and gender based discrimination prevail's amongst the masses of this state ?

We can always hide behind the usual "She was not raped for her caste". But you and i know , how this hooligans have taken the central state's as a personal dowry. And we stand muted and helpless.

I'm ashamed of this incident and bigotry practiced openly in this state's of ours. Let accept our faults and bravely condemn such incident's.

 

[SQ8]

Was the girl raped because of her caste? Why Dalit has been added to thread title when the actual news headline doesn't mention it?

Do we say Brahmin girl is raped if the victim is Brahim by caste? :/

Pretty pathetic of people to twist headlines to suit their own agenda. Thread reported.

A twist would be implied.. if it said minister rapes, dalit girl..
or Dalit girl raped by brahmin with ministers consent.

While I can sense the low blow in the title..
The girl was dalit..and since that exists in the news and in the context..
nothing wrong there....by the rules.

 

[LaBong]

Tell me now, is this any different from the Taliban's?

Silly, it wasn't act of any organization but an individual, and not driven by any ideology.

There are sickos at every corner of world, they are quarantined once they are found out as this one will be.