roadrunner
SENIOR MEMBER
- Joined
- Jun 25, 2007
- Messages
- 5,696
- Reaction score
- 0
No answer then..Fair enough. Anyone else?
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
You obviously don't understand my views. My views are these.
- The 3 million figure of war of independence is a figment of Bengali nationalist propaganda.
- The Muktihi Bahini committed war crimes, just like the Razakhars, just like the PA, just like the Bharatis..noone was innocent so holding a "holohoax" war museum in Dhakka is pure hypocrisy
- The Muktihi Bahini and Bengali Nationalists are guilty of propagating myths and lies such as the Jessore Massacre which was committed by Bengalis and blamed on PA. If they can lie so much over one incident, how many more incidents have they lied about?
- The discrimination of Bengalis in particular did not exist - this is agree is controversial, but I have not seen a full proof case to demonstrate there was discrimination between the West and East wings by the government. On the contrary I know Ayub Khan tried to stimulate the enrollment of Bengalis in PA, but it failed because the Bengalis did not want to join.
- The war of independence was a result not of real discrimination between the East and West, it was as a result of the incitement to revolt in the speeched of Mujib that the people from the East wing fell for hook, line & etc.
- My final "point" is more a question. Given all this, why do Bengalis like yourself want to keep the myth alive about there being a one way genocide when this has been proven not to be the case?
If you want to discuss these views instead of resorting to poor quality jokes and insults, then prove to me how my views are wrong..it's better than cursing which only makes you look foolish yourself.
Tough call for you?
The Bangladeshis who have faced the inhuman behaviour of West Pakistanis have answered.
They are the best judge since they suffered!
look first of all i am a Canadian of Indian origin my family did moved to east west Pakistan after partition from India i speak Hindi/Urdu for your kind information so please next time don't rush to conclusion regarding anyone's ethnicity on the basis of ones viewpoint when you don't know the person . next time you shall be reported am i clear ? & can you please show me were did i cursed proof please you can believe whatever you wont it want make a drop of a difference to my viewpoints.
Here's the list of my points, just in case you missed them earlier. What exactly are you disagreeing with me about and why?
- The 3 million figure of war of independence is a figment of Bengali nationalist propaganda.
- The Muktihi Bahini committed war crimes, just like the Razakhars, just like the PA, just like the Bharatis..noone was innocent so holding a "holohoax" war museum in Dhakka is pure hypocrisy
- The Muktihi Bahini and Bengali Nationalists are guilty of propagating myths and lies such as the Jessore Massacre which was committed by Bengalis and blamed on PA. If they can lie so much over one incident, how many more incidents have they lied about?
- The discrimination of Bengalis in particular did not exist - this is agree is controversial, but I have not seen a full proof case to demonstrate there was discrimination between the West and East wings by the government. On the contrary I know Ayub Khan tried to stimulate the enrollment of Bengalis in PA, but it failed because the Bengalis did not want to join.
- The war of independence was a result not of real discrimination between the East and West, it was as a result of the incitement to revolt in the speeched of Mujib that the people from the East wing fell for hook, line & etc.
- My final "point" is more a question. Given all this, why do (people like you - Edited) want to keep the myth alive about there being a one way genocide when this has been proven not to be the case? I suspect this final question has already been answered in your most recent admission that you're from Bharat originally though.
Whatever, you obviously can't answer any of the points with any solid references that haven't been discredited by now. So we don't really disagree at all, no need to get so emotional and curse Pakistan when you don't even know what it is you are arguing about.
Akzaman said:The Baltimore Sun 5/14/71 0.5
The Momento,Caracas 6/13/71 0.5 - 1.0
Washington Daily News 6/30/71 0.2
World Bank Report June, 71 0.2
Die Zeit, Bonn 7/9/71 0.5
New York Times 7/14/71 0.20 - 0.25
Wall Street Journal 7/23/71 0.2 - 1.0
The Christian Sci. Mon. 7/31/71 0.25 - 1.00
Newsweek 8/2/71 0.25
Time 9/2/71 0.2 - 1.0
Newsweek 3/27/72 1.5
National Geographic Sept. 1972 3.0
^^ The person who wrote this on "virtual Bangladesh", which I think is typical of some of the other Bangladeshi websites out there, is obviously a math buffoon. A quick look at those numbers would have any 15 year old Math high school student in hysterics at the point he's trying to prove. Here are his summary statistics.
Mean numbers of people killed = 866,666 illusionary Bengalis
Pooled standard deviation = 794,393 illusionary Bengalis.
Mean±sd = 900,000±800,000 illusionary Bengalis.
In other words, the maximum number of Bengalis killed on the basis of his summary is 1,700,000, the minimum number is 100,000. Both are equally as likely. If you take into account that these are highly inflated since it was the Bharatis who wrote what happened to every foreign news outlet after the war, these figures would in reality be much much less. Still, at least "virtual bangladesh" has managed to prove its other stories of 3 million killed to be statistically impossible
in order to understand that its from a well reputed news paper one needs to have the reading powerLondon, 6/13/71). The Sunday Times:
the report is from the sundaytimes read carefully
in order to understand that its from a well reputed news paper one needs to have the reading power
The virtualbangladesh report said:London, 6/13/71). The Sunday Times....."
Thevirtualbangladeshreport said:Newsweek .....................3/27/72 ...........1.5
National Geographic.........Sept. 1972.........3.0
Oh really!! Your "powers of reading" must have also made you notice this I suppose
The Sunday Times article written in 1971. Then at the end the table quotes at least 2 articles written well after 1971..It would be so unlike virtualbangladesh to invent things though, wouldnt it?
In fact if you look at the " ", you'll see they've used only a small section of a Sunday Times report, but I really wouldn't even trust that all that is accurate. It quotes no figures within the Sunday Times article. Your powers of reading will no doubts prove powerful once again.
Salim Bhai,
You have to think from heart when u are thinking or speaking about your motherland this is not the emotional blackmailing.
i cant understand why people dont realize that those who commited war crimes in 1971 were Indian agents and could be the Indian army Personnel there was no way to identify them.They were mixed with "Mukti Bahini" that was the actual problem i would say.