Copy copy copy!!!

[Peshwa]

How about the OP stop using the word "copy" which seems to be the bone of contention here......
because the original and the "refined" versions do have some tweaks with regards to instruments used, added beats, synthesized music...
So to call it a copy ie. suggesting its an identical pick and pack is a bit far fetched...

I believe using the term "based on a Pakistani song" is a better analysis of the situation..

Also, as the OP claims...his/her intention was not to joke but poke...that's definitely quite evident from the use of her words and terminology when speaking about this situation.

Lastly, I do agree that credit should be given to the original song or at least acknowledged..
Nevertheless, if some monetary compensation is being expected, then please give it a rest! Aint gonna happen esp given the amount of piracy of Bollywood films that happens in Pakistan.


Pakistan has a lot of talent...just hidden in a mine full of coal.
Only an expert jewel trader can separate gems from stones....we Indians seem to be those jewel traders!

 

[Dubious]

Bloody Hindu Baniyas!

They will do anything for money!

Too bad I can't listen to any of these because my Hindi is weak

Did I talk about Hindus? Man you are a religious bigot arent you?

@WebMaster @Horus @Manticore @Jungibaaz @Jango @Chak Bamu @waz @Emmie @TaimiKhan @T-Faz @blain2 @Oscar

Mods! I NEVER used the word Hindu on this thread and never used the word Baniyas on this forum! Please remove this troll!

 

[45'22']

Bloody Hindu Baniyas!

They will do anything for money!

Too bad I can't listen to any of these because my Hindi is weak

You missed evil

 

[Dubious]

How about the OP stop using the word "copy" which seems to be the bone of contention here......
because the original and the "refined" versions do have some tweaks with regards to instruments used, added beats, synthesized music...
So to call it a copy ie. suggesting its an identical pick and pack is a bit far fetched...

How about you go through the thread and see Half of them are straight picked up lyrics with no adjustments!

While others are straight picks at tunes with NO ADJUSTMENTS!

I believe using the term "based on a Pakistani song" is a better analysis of the situation..

THAT was the duty of those who copied it...They should have acknowledged where they stole it from then it would not have been called copying! Coz copying is done when you steal...but once you acknowledge then the word drops so till due is given where deserved it is what the English word was made to describe = copy!

Lastly, I do agree that credit should be given to the original song or at least acknowledged..
Nevertheless, if some monetary compensation is being expected, then please give it a rest! Aint gonna happen esp given the amount of piracy of Bollywood films that happens in Pakistan.

You cant cry about piracy when you are stealing the original and making your own pirated version!

Pakistan has a lot of talent...just hidden in a mine full of coal.
Only an expert jewel trader can separate gems from stones....we Indians seem to be those jewel traders!

Very nicely said! It also takes an expert jewel thief to steal while others watch and acknowledge the brilliance in stealing!

It is just you who is biased

Why dont you create your own thread about how many we copied

There is nothing biased in saying my country was looted by our neighbours in the field of music!

 

[Dubious]

I think you doesnt know about Pritam.

Nope...I didnt till I read all that for making this thread

 

[Chronos]

Did I talk about Hindus? Man you are a religious bigot arent you?

@WebMaster @Horus @Manticore @Jungibaaz @Jango @Chak Bamu @waz @Emmie @TaimiKhan @T-Faz @blain2 @Oscar

Mods! I NEVER used the word Hindu on this thread and never used the word Baniyas on this forum! Please remove this troll!

Mods! Ban this person immediately for not understanding a joke and sarcasm.

Just chill, just calm down.

Maybe the textual nature of the internet is inhibiting some of the communication here.

anyhoo, see you later

 

[Force-India]

I dont know what site you have been reading but whatever....

This and few other websites

 

[Dubious]

This and few other websites

lie no.1 you tube is not a website for reading but listening ....
lie no.2 does the video look like quran to you?

i started reading about Islam on internet just to get knowledge. After reading so much stuff online about Islam, Quran, etc to the core

You listened to soo much youtube but couldnt be bothered to verify it but at least opening the Quran

Does the title of the video even look like something authentic? Answering Muslims.com? there is answering Christians . com answering each rubbish uttered on Answering Muslims .com.....wonder how you missed it unless you were googling a particular section about Islam say Islam bashing!

 

[kaku1]

Nope...I didnt till I read all that for making this thread

Lol, btw there are also hollywood songs copied from bollywood.

JLO "chor".

 

[SpArK]

original
Song : Mitthe
Lyric/Tune/Composition : ZooEL
Album : Ekla Prothom
Year: 2010


Song : Nenjodu Cherthu
Album : Yuvvh
Singer : Alaap Raju
Music by : Sachin and Sreejith
Year: 2012

 

[Dubious]

Lol, btw there are also hollywood songs copied from bollywood.

JLO "chor".

That is for your new thread! Mine is only focused on Bollywood stealing business!

Why hide this one and jump and talk about others....finish 1 topic first! Plus Anyone stealing from Bollywood should be your business not mine!

 

[Srinivas]

@Akheilos Indians copy some of the songs because they make thousands of songs every year and Pakistanis play, dance and sing the same Bollywood songs ....

 

[kaku1]

That is for your new thread! Mine is only focused on Bollywood stealing business!

Why hide this one and jump and talk about others....finish 1 topic first! Plus Anyone stealing from Bollywood should be your business not mine!

Definitely bollywood is "CHOR". You cant discuss this on whole thread. :/

 

[Dubious]

original
Song : Mitthe
Lyric/Tune/Composition : ZooEL
Album : Ekla Prothom
Year: 2010


Song : Nenjodu Cherthu
Album : Yuvvh
Singer : Alaap Raju
Music by : Sachin and Sreejith
Year: 2012

Who are they?

@Akheilos Indians copy some of the songs because they make thousands of songs every year and Pakistanis play, dance and sing the same Bollywood songs ....

Errr we dance to the original music/ lyrics which bollywood didnt bother altering while stealing...Oh wait they are stealing after all!

heck most of it is direct lifting....its the same whichever we dance to but giving credit where its due seems to kill many!

 

[kaku1]

@Akheilos Foreigner "Chorani" for you.