First of all I am not a MQM supporter. You got it wrong just form the start.
I have witnessed this among all mqm supporters. The moment one of their own community members criticizes them, their God, Altaf and their militant organization they instantly claim not to be supporters of MQM. I saw this in some other members and now the same thing in you. You defend the MQM thugs with the same intensity. You should be awarded Bharat Varsh for it as you are the successor of Altaf.
Now coming back to your shameless defense of quota system.
We don't have to agree. But what is shameless is your name calling and abuse. You can't engage in debate for a second without abusing your powers as elite member and questioning the ability of other posters.
Karachi was a majority hindu before 1947. So why don't bring all Hindus back from India and have a quota for them too.
Its not about bringing hindus back. Its about calling a spade a spade. There is much more to the qouta than just the demands of MQM and PPPP. Both are flawed political parties responsible for keeping Karachi backwards.
And all ethnicities played a part in 71. I was just claiming it wasn't just them but urdu speakers too. Something none of us will ever admit.
It is fault of sindhis that they are poor in education.
This is a canard. Your post stinks of your negative view of Sindhis and has a complete lack of understanding about their needs.
Interior sindh has such severe lack of resources that you cannot imagine for yourself. Of course giving a computer to a fool will not turn him into a wise man as is evidenced by your posts but there should be an opportunity for him to improve himself. There are no jobs, no education in Sindh. In this way the qouta system attempts to even the field. I cannot fully argue for it because there are advantages of promoting merit too rather than just equal play but I can see clearly that the Sindhis are being pushed into a corner, rather than what altaf hussain claims.
They should try to improve their standards instead of getting an unfair quota for themselves. if someone is "had haram" then you work to end his had harami instead of giving him free food.
Its not free food. Sindh has much talent but interior sindh has few resources. The cities are areas of development and both Hyderabad and Karachi have large populations of muhajirs ruling them. Our refusal to even recognize this as a fact is the source of much tension over resources in Sindh. We control the cities and with it the power and then abuse the Sindhis for being backwards. We could very much be in their situation.
This quota system has destroyed the government institutions of Pakistan. PPP fills all its sympathizers and supporters in government departments and thus adds to a never ending cycle of corruption.
While I agree about your stance about the PPP and its support we are not bereft of such a dogmatic stance with our support to MQM. What has MQM given muhajirs? Look within first, then abuse the Sindhis. When you vote blindly like them for a haati sitting in London who betrays his country, not only his ethnicity like the PPP by refusing to build sindh then who are you to complain? We have been voting not only a corrupt party like the Sindhis but also a militant one.
Sindhis can be even more poor than Africa. That doesn't make them worthy for a quota. They had 3 PM from Sindh and several presidents too. They should have used that power to improve their education and living standards.
This is mavericks old stand which has been debunked multiple times. All MQM supporters give the same arguments that are filled with a feeling of bias against other ethnicities. This is why I think it is far better fr me to support the independence of Lucknow as at least I am not with my own hands breaking Pakistan. We could very much be like them had things not turned out differently.
By giving quota you want to ensure that Sindhis remain uneducated and don't strive to prosper. You are the biggest enemy of Sindhis. Shame on you. They gave you land to settle here and you want Sindhis to remain uneducated and poor by giving them a useless quota. How filthy of you???
Now you are turning this on me. Sweet. But nothing can be done for you. Karachi has a literacy rate far higher than other regions. Lets recognize that as we are more powerful we should help the weaker ethnic groups. This stance is the cause of Balochs and Pashtuns not integrating.
We are not asking for extra rights. Ending quota is nothing extra. And we didn't broke Pakistan. It was a Sindhi PM who was in power when that debacle happened. Yahya Khan was no Muhajir either.
Personally I prefer the parties to sit together and comprehensive study be done before making a decision, qouta or no qouta. But I am sympathetic to the reasons Sindhis demand qouta.
You are a fool. You are a disgrace to all us Pakistanis on this forum. Lucknow is legal part of India just like Karachi, Quetta and Lahore are for Pakistan. Your moronic obsession with this stupid city has made us all feel disgraced.
Atleast my family tried to make Pakistan and free all of it-including Lucknow. You and people like you from the beginning wanted to do politics over the dead bodies of our family members who died in Indian massacres. This debate about qouta system is nothing more than a demand for more power of the various ethnic groups. Nothing more, nothing less and it is much politicized. The government currently is against the MQM and are thus raising it. Otherwise it is like an old book in an old library, gathering dust.
You keep getting embarrassed and ridiculed by Bharati members for your illogical claims about Lucknow and here we Pakistanis feel embarrassed that we have this "Think Tank" who keeps on talking about lucknow even though not even stray dogs of lucknow care about your BS.
My family fought the Bhartis for Pakistan. What did your family do other than whine?
That's what you are. A disgrace to us all. A shame to be called a Think Tank.
And you think you can do a better job with your insults and picking fights.
