Nilgiri
BANNED
- Joined
- Aug 4, 2015
- Messages
- 24,797
- Reaction score
- 81
- Country
- Location
Chsristians do- especially when it comes to the old testament.
The old testament is accepted in Christianity to be a jewish narrative...mostly written by Moses. (at least up to exodus)
Jesus made a new pact (covenant) where the old stuff remains as "context" for reference but it has never been a massive theological imprint for traditional Christianity per se (unlike the jews). However in practice again this could be quite different (Especially if you did not like turning the other cheek as Jesus espoused, but preferred the raw emotion of the old testament god....sacking, pillaging and burning entire cities).
Even today it depends on context. Plenty of church leaders use the most emotionally charged phrases....and they are not all fringe groups like the WBC....I mean even in Catholicism there has been no new council of nicaea to purge the dubious parts of the old testament....given the precedent it would set (which would ultimately doom itself) and inconsistencies and quite possible mass resentment it would create (I doubt they could even technically do it even if they wanted to). You can only whittle away so much from something so straight and narrow to being with. So people often have to leave when things no longer make sense to them to stay on that.
This is the problem when you have only one dimension to offer, and any other dimension = straight to damnation and hell.
The reform to Christianity was imposed from the outside, by revolution, mass uprisings and outright church divisions (like how protestantism was formed) were all quite violent and bloody...and not always in the right direction (as far as humanism is concerned). Each one of these episodes were not ever 100% done cleanly either. Just look at Martin Luther's views on the jews for example. The so called rennaisance and then englightenment was again quite external to religion, in fact religion fought against both quite viciously at certain times, again when human creativity/thought/questioning exceeded what was allowed "morally".
So this "whittling down" is quite open to speculation. I see much looney hatred kind of stuff going on with various evangelical movements, and those are also the fastest growing (they are going all out in Africa as we speak to compete against Islam)....and when all else fails they indulge in a healthy amount of soul vulturing at opportune times.
Their faiths are quite extroverted in practice basically....whereas the Dharmic ones always preach balance between looking in and looking out in my opinion.
Anyways I have had enough talking about Religion for now. I would also watch what you say about Islam here.