What's new

Chinese troops incursions in Indian controlled territories - News updates and Discussions

. .
We made a fundamental military mistake of not securing the area in strength before we attempted to improve our border infrastructure in sensitive areas. The PLA preempted us.

India is in a catch-22 situation. No government will survive a setback on the LAC. Every time China precipitates the situation, even with limited forces, we have to be prepared for the worse, which forces us to mobilise at a much larger scale. Ideally, we must seize the initiative for quid pro quo actions either preemptively or in response. However, our military capability imposes caution. But we can certainly give the aggressor a bloody nose and stalemate it.

Be that as it may, we have the capability and the will to stare China down and force it to blink. Neither country wants war, hence diplomacy has to be given the first priority to restore status quo ante 1 April 2020. However, if diplomacy does not work, then India should be prepared for border skirmishes and even a limited war.
India will seek a local conflict in a place where it has some advantage. PLA will open up on the whole front and humiliate the Indians much worse than 1962.

The trigger to the present conflict is the recent Indian forward policy. The PLA detected the construction on the Chinese side of the LAC immediately and moved in to occupy all the strategic points. Now Indian army is in a disadvantageous position. They are afraid but too humiliated to back down.
 
. .
indian credibility has taken a serious hit in this episode.. its hard to take anything coming out of the indian government seriously anymore.

everything is now just blatantly deny plain facts... it becomes annoying and condescending at some point.

when this incident happened. I went quickly to see what both sides were saying. and virtually all indian sources were saying "fake news" "India took Chinese territory actually" and things like that. virtually every other source on earth is saying the opposite.

at some point you lose credibility. its impossible to take any indian statements as facts anymomre and impossible to know whats going on. and i say this as a relatively neutral observer.
 
.
He himself admits it is his opinion and he has real info or intel on ground situation.
Anyways his daughter is a senior memebr of an opposition party:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gul_Panag

So he is not a neutral source.

Also his map of LAC in Pangong Tso is wrong, he claims this is the LAC:
Likely-area-secured-by-PLA-in-North-Bank-Pangong-Tso.jpg


But he is completely wrong as the actual LAC at Pangong Tso is this:

EYzTrtYUwAECRPb
 
.
He himself admits it is his opinion and he has real info or intel on ground situation.
Anyways his daughter is a senior memebr of an opposition party:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gul_Panag

So he is not a neutral source.

Also his map of LAC in Pangong Tso is wrong, he claims this is the LAC:
Likely-area-secured-by-PLA-in-North-Bank-Pangong-Tso.jpg


But he is completely wrong as the actual LAC at Pangong Tso is this:

EYzTrtYUwAECRPb

Yes , A retired 3 star general is less in stature compared to a shit poster that spams every thread with propaganda.

His daughter is not relevant to this discussion. You are just trying to put down a three star general because he doesn't believe in your lies.
 
. . .
exaggerating nothing else .
Indian military wants more fund , they cannot just let the govt cut funds easily.

General Panag is a serious commentator. He is retired for more than 10 years now, and has nothing to do with pressuring the government for funds. He first went to the area as a Lt. Col. under Sunderji, and after various assignments all over the country, became GOC-in-C Northern Command. Things happened, and he was transferred to Central Command by an Army Chief of very questionable reputation.

You may take what he says very seriously.
 
.
very funny....its a serious discussion.

sir we are not vietnam , we are 120 crore people with a fully equipped army , we will not sit with folded hands seeing our land go to china .
 
. . . . .
Back
Top Bottom