China’s Submarine Fleet, Evolution & news

[hk299792458]

但实际上试射的就是动能3。

Where do you get confirmation that it was DN-3 ?

For the moment I'm scared about what you chinese guys called 脑补...

Henri K.

 

[星海军事]

Where do you get confirmation that it was DN-3 ?

For the moment I'm scared about what you chinese guys called 脑补...

Henri K.

DN-3 is in fact a 脑补 of Bill Gertz

 

[ChineseTiger1986]

Think the Russians have the biggest SLBM. They are known for building bigger things. The Trident will be the same even with the new SSBNX is introduced. Only thing I heard is improved guidance system.

On the contrary, Bulava is actually the smallest intercontinental SLBM out of the P5 nations.

 

[hk299792458]

DN-3 is in fact a 脑补 of Bill Gertz

Thank you for that information.

Bill Gertz is good to let us know something had happeded, but he used to call every chinese test an ASAT, so for this part he is not credible.

Henri K.

 

[ChineseTiger1986]

Where do you get confirmation that it was DN-3 ?

For the moment I'm scared about what you chinese guys called 脑补...

Henri K.

It was a GMD test, but we don't nitpick about its name, so it can be DN-3.

But KKTT claimed it was a terminal phase test like HQ-19, but he was obviously wrong.

Thank you for that information.

Bill Gertz is good to let us know something had happeded, but he used to call every chinese test an ASAT, so for this part he is not credible.

Henri K.

Of course, he got the political purpose and ulterior motive to demonize China's space weaponization, because "it will create more debris which will turn out to be dangerous for other nations' rockets" according to them.

 

[星海军事]

Bill Gertz is good to let us know something had happeded, but he used to call every chinese test an ASAT, so for this part he is not credible.

That's why I called it a 脑补

But KKTT claimed it was a terminal phase test like HQ-19, but he was obviously wrong.

KKTT has never assert that the so called DN-3 is a terminal phase test

 

[ChineseTiger1986]

KKTT has never assert that the so called DN-3 is a terminal phase test

His assertion was clearly wrong, it was a GMD test, not a terminal phase one.

而KKTT则认为种种迹象显示那次试验可能是一次大气上层末段反导拦截试验，试验中地面所观察到的空中异象是高空阳光照射到导弹和尾迹反光所致，并不能表示导弹的真实飞行轨迹。

http://www.guancha.cn/military-affairs/2015_11_03_339829.shtml

 

[星海军事]

His assertion was clearly wrong, it was a GMD test, not a terminal phase one.



http://www.guancha.cn/military-affairs/2015_11_03_339829.shtml

Please read the original article written by KKTT:

http://liuqiankktt.blog.163.com/blog/static/12126421120151014503782/

KKTT has never assert that the so called DN-3 is a terminal phase test

 

[ChineseTiger1986]

Please read the original article written by KKTT:

http://liuqiankktt.blog.163.com/blog/static/12126421120151014503782/

这是马后炮，去年他一开始认定是大气层末端反导，后来才改口。

他是航天武器版的版主，好面子可以把自己一开始的发言修改掉。

 

[Oldman1]

On the contrary, Bulava is actually the smallest intercontinental SLBM out of the P5 nations.

Well the Russians did had the biggest SLBM.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/R-39_Rif

 

[ChineseTiger1986]

Well the Russians did had the biggest SLBM.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/R-39_Rif

Well, this one was made in Ukraine, and it is already retired right now.

 

[Oldman1]

Well, this one was made in Ukraine, and it is already retired right now.

True it was retired. But it was still made in Russia.

The R-39 Rif (NATO reporting name: SS-NX-20 Sturgeon; bilateral arms control designation: RSM-52 ) was a submarine-launched ballistic missile (SLBM) that served with the Soviet Navy from its introduction in 1983 until 1991, after which it served with the Russian Navy until 2004. The missile had GRAU indices of 3M65, 3M20, and 3R65. It was carried on board Typhoon-class submarines.

 

[星海军事]

这是马后炮，去年他一开始认定是大气层末端反导，后来才改口。

他是航天武器版的版主，好面子可以把自己一开始的发言修改掉。

I have followed that post since 1st November and I don't think KKTT had ever suggested that the launch was a endo-atmospheric terminal phase test. No signs of edit on his posts as well.

http://bbs.9ifly.cn/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=15470&extra=&highlight=%B7%B4%B5%BC&page=1

 

[ChineseTiger1986]

I have followed that post since 1st November and I don't think KKTT had ever suggested that the launch was a endo-atmospheric terminal phase test. No signs of edit on his posts as well.

http://bbs.9ifly.cn/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=15470&extra=&highlight=%B7%B4%B5%BC&page=1

He deleted his comment, since he was surprised that his prediction wasn't correct.

I saw his comment about HQ-19 as the test in Xinjiang.

True it was retired. But it was still made in Russia.

The R-39 Rif (NATO reporting name: SS-NX-20 Sturgeon; bilateral arms control designation: RSM-52 ) was a submarine-launched ballistic missile (SLBM) that served with the Soviet Navy from its introduction in 1983 until 1991, after which it served with the Russian Navy until 2004. The missile had GRAU indices of 3M65, 3M20, and 3R65. It was carried on board Typhoon-class submarines.

Not in the same factory, since the R-39 was made in the factory of Ukraine, while Bulava was made in Russia's.

 

[cirr]

094A