You want to understand what logic is , try this:
Lesson No. 1
1) Finger 4 to 8 was an area patrolled by IA and PLA, claimed by both.
2) China encroached ( was an aggressors)
3) China is now going back and restoring all structured built by it there.
4) For now, Neither PLA nor IA will patrol the area.
So who actually was forced to go back. Who conceded defeat now?
Lesson No. 2
1) Galwan Clash. Col Babu went to inspect the area with some soldiers to check if PA honored its commitment to go back.
2) The initial understanding was not more than 20 or some small size in a patrol. No use of firearms.
3) PLA brought more soldiers and with primitive tools attacked. 20 plus Indian soldiers died and 45 plus Chinese.
The video you saw in Chinese propoganda was of next day of this figh and from angel of camera to peddle Chinese bullshit
4) China worked on the lies for 9 months and only conceded 4 now. Thats 10% or so of truth. You want to believe them, go ahead.
5) Once the Chinese pull out, you will see India sharing / busting PLA lies . Have patience, wait for the closure.
Final analysis, China goes back. China is a looser.
All that talk of PLA attacking and taking laddakh ? People have short memory but go and check past 9 month posts here . PLA as per Pakistanis were taking avenge for article 370 etc...kya hua PLA revenge ka
As i had written at very early stages of Indo-china conflict, China's action was never to capture more territory, atleast on laddak front. If they wanted to increase their boundary, they would not have halted at Finger 4 while indian establishment was shellshocked by their action for first few days ( atleast first 1 week or occupation).
For more than one week after news was broken nation wide that china has been sitting pretty on finger 4 by ajai shukla in his blog, he wrote that this action was more than one month old, India did not move any more troops or equipment to the said area.
Had china not stopped at their claim line, they would have faced Indian Border police and very little army deployment on dhan singh thapa post and likewise towards north western areas on Pangong Tso. Dhan singh thapa post was at that time not atall prepared to face an incoming army assault , let alone from well equipped PLA. Now, i am not saying they would have steam rolled all the way with India doing nothing, they sure would have got very bloody battle ground from Indian army. But atleast with element of surprise they had at that time( for first few days), they surely would have over run first 1-3 border posts.
So, why did china just dug in? Because war is what china wants to avoid! Overrunning indian posts would have left india with no choice.
China knows its growing day and night in muscles, world knows that too! And not everyone in the world but atleast Western allied nations want China to be reigned in before it becomes a monster. USA, Uk and to an extent France have tried to be on a common platform and keep the pressure on china through SCS for almost 10 years. It has yielded some results but not nearly enough.
At the same time, India has ambition of becoming a major power too, they can't afford to have a strong china, else china will simply use its growing influence and siphon off money or industry which could have come to india.
With this common goal, India has been shifting to USA anti-china camp more openly in recent times, making comments on Taiwan, one china, SCS, permanent membership of security council, questioning UN etall. How far has India fallen in lap came to for front when India openly demanded Aksai chin and rest of kashmir. Now, Ofcourse no one is going to give it back on a platter, everyone knows that. India is going have to fight big wars to go on that trajectory.
So, it was a signal that we are willing and ready to go to war! And it was at the time when US was every other day threatening China on military action on one pretext or another, be it south china sea or taiwan or trade deficit or North Korea. Lets not forget, any Korean war will be china+north Korea.
China was absorbing the pressure when US navy+ was making threats through SCS. China knows they are not going to make a dent through ScS because as the bodies of US marines pile up, pressure will be right back on US and not on china.
As soon as India started showing willingness to go to war ( on any pretext), china needed action and preparation. China doesn't want to fight a warin SCS, it is quite clear, having to fight on two sides becomes a bit too much for anybody.
With this Laddak adventure, it not only showed that they understand what's going on, they also showed that are going to fight a defensive war if it is shoved in their face. Dug in, prepared defenses and make the others to come get them. Its very difficult for aggressor to make gains against a defensive army, everyone knows that.
World waits to see who will actually take military action against china first. My guess is No One.
