India may be doing a great deal of good work in your country and you should be thankful although from a Pakistani perspective they are taking full advantage of the porous border by supplying criminals/agents who cross the border to join ranks with extremist groups to carry out acts of terror in our land but god willing we will work alongside Afghans to combat this problem and i hope with time we will be able to build a fruitful and trustworthy relationship with one another.
This is the point brother, even the Afghan army (which needs ALOT of work) and foreign forces are in danger on Afghan-Pak borders, how do you think an Indian will make it there? There's no proof of Indians across the borders as Indians are found mainly in Kabul, Mazar and Herat. They are not even in Jalalabad which is way less dangerous than our southern parts. Nonetheless if Pakistan is convinced India IS in Afghan tribal areas and causing trouble then by no mean, and WITH solid evidences, Pakistan has it's right to take action against it.
And by the way the only history Afghanistan shares with India is through present day Pakistan. Even your Ahmad Shah Durrani was born in Multan, in Punjab province of Pakistan. His empire included all of present day Afghanistan and all of present day Pakistan and only some parts of north-west India (India Occupied Kashmir and India's region of Punjab) that shares historical and cultural links with present day Pakistan. Most of India and most Indians have nothing in common with Afghanistan, Afghanistan's history, or Afghanistan's people whatsoever.
Afghanistan got as much links with Pakistan as Muslims of India. And whether we got less or more in common I don't know, but I do know that Tajiks, Uzbeks and Hazaras in particular hold huge amount of respect for India because of the constructions Indian provided in north of the country over the years. Pashtuns don't interact as much with Indians since you will hardly find an Indian in south of the country. And about Indian deals and all, as I said, an Indian knows better so I won't speak about something I am not sure of.
pakistan is 'building' more in afghanistan and providing it will wheat and rice then india can ever build or invest, and its all just humanitarian, what india is 'building' is facilitating not afghanis but its own workers, why india is pushing indians in afghanistan, even your own kerzai has admittied to the real deal which india is pushing in there..
After US, India is second biggest aid worker in Afghanistan. No offence but if Pakistan has helped Afghanistan then we have also seen ALOT of political tension from Pak side, while it's a fact that India hasn't armed or funded Afghans to fight whatever war in their country. Their neutralism regarding ethnics is one of their plus points which is why no Afghan ethnic got any problem with them.
but guess what if pakistan finds any bi mischief from afghanistan through india than afghanis will be bombed as compared to india, so you should better be cautioned about what sort of gay relationship you are developing with it...
That's why I said, if you have SOLID evidences then present it to the world. If your government can let a murderer go for a few dollars then it can do anything for money, this is your government's task. See that there's absolutely no difference in greed between both our governments?
If the Indians were in neighbouring Iran it would be a different story, but India is in Afghanistan and taking advantage of the porous Afghan-Pak border to cause trouble in Pakistan. That is the reason why General Zia ul Haq helped fight the Soviets, we can not afford to have the enemy on our western border with Afghanistan.
Now I ask you, have you got any evidence of India interfering with Pakistan through Afghanistan BEFORE the wars? I am hoping for an international source though. And every person with a bit knowledge about history would know that Afghan-Russian war was a huge mistake which never should have happened, ever. Don't forget that Indians and Russians both were asked to send troops to southern Afghanistan, both could have easily agreed and cause trouble in Pakistan by blaming anyone at all.
And its almost impossible to fence the entire Pak-Afghan border like the Pak-India border or the Pak-Iran border. That is the reason why whenever Afghanistan is unstable or in a state of war, it also affects Pakistan.
And don't you agree that Pakistan wouldn't have suffered as much if your government had eased it's interferences, or atleast take GOOD advantage of it? Iran also interfered, but it knew it's limits. Through Tajikistan and Uzbekistan Russia also tried to interfere, but at a point it stopped. But Pak's interference was unstoppable, and during Taliban regime it was best period of Afghan-Pak relationship. Had Pak government handled Taliban a bit more wisely, I guarantee you Afghanistan would have been very neutral regarding Pakistan. It's a shame your government interfered till the extend Pakistan got troubled, and it's a shame our government still isn't competent enough to decide it's own destiny rather than becoming a joke in everyone's eyes.
And we can argue all we want, it comes back to that Pakistan-China will keep justifying their friendship, whether it suits an Indian or not. And Indo-Afghan friendship will also be justified, whether it suits a Pakistani or not. So let's keep it just that, agreeing to disagree.
