What's new

Chabahar not a rival to Gwadar, Iranian envoy tells Pakistan

Devil Soul

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Jun 28, 2010
Messages
22,931
Reaction score
45
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Chabahar not a rival to Gwadar, Iranian envoy tells Pakistan
MATEEN HAIDER | MAHNOOR BARI — UPDATED 37 MINUTES AGO
5748265f68dd0.jpg

Iranian Ambassador to Pakistan Mehdi Honerdoost speaking at the Institute of Strategic Studies in Islamabad on May 27, 2016. – Photo by Mateen Haider
ISLAMABAD: Addressing tensions surrounding Chabahar, Mehdi Honerdoost, the Iranian ambassador to Pakistan, on Friday said the Chabahar port agreement between Iran, India and Afghanistan is “not finished” and “not limited to these three countries”.

Speaking on Pakistan-Iran relations at the Institute of Strategic Studies in Islamabad (ISSI), the envoy revealed that the offer to cooperate had first been extended to Pakistan and then China, implying neither had expressed interest.

Ahmed Saffee, a research fellow at the ISSI, quoted the Iranian envoy as saying that the deal is still on the table for both Pakistan and China, assuring that “Chabahar is not a rival to Gwadar”.

The ambassador added that both are sister ports, and Chabahar port authorities would extend cooperation to Gwadar.

“The deal is not finished. We are waiting for new members. Pakistan, our brotherly neighbours and China, a great partner of the Iranians and a good friend of Pakistan, are both welcome,” said the envoy.

“India was a good friend during the sanctions, the only country to import oil from us during sanctions.”

‘Ready for rapprochement’
“We are ready for any rapprochement between regional countries which directly impact the interests of the people of our countries. Trade and business is business, and politics is politics. We should separate them.”

Honerdoost reiterated that trade and business is a key element to bringing peace to the region, and that Iran has friendly trade relations with its neighbours and regional powers, including Turkey, China and Russia.

According to Saffee, the envoy called for cooperation between Pakistani and Iranian universities to increase people-to-people contact, especially between the youth, a major demographic in both countries.

“Iran has undergone the burden of sanctions and international isolation. After the P5+1 deal, Iran is invigorated.”

Three-way accord on Chabahar
Iranian President Hassan Rouhani, Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Afghan President Ashraf Ghani on Monday signed a three-way transit agreement on Iran's southern port of Chabahar.

India said it will invest up to $500 million in a deal to develop a strategic port in Iran and both countries planned a number of projects they say are worth hundreds of millions of dollars.

The development of the port at Chabahar expands a trade route for the land-locked countries of central Asia that bypasses Pakistan, and represents a missed opportunity for Pakistan as post-sanctions Iran opens up.

The deal and plans were announced during a visit by Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi, the first such trip in more than a decade.

‘How could Iran give space to Taliban?’
Honerdoost denied former Afghan Taliban leader Mullah Akhtar Mansour came to Pakistan from Iran, saying the Afghan Taliban is an enemy of Iran as well.

Earlier this week, the Wall Street Journal reported that Mansour was coming to Pakistan after visiting family in Iran.

Iran, however, has repeatedly denied that Mansour entered Pakistan from the Islamic republic.

“Iran would never allow any spy agency or terrorist group to use Iranian territory against Pakistan,” Honderdoost said.

“Iran's territory was never used and will not be used for terror and against Pakistan,” Saffee quoted the ambassador as saying.

“A number of Iranian diplomats were killed by [the Taliban], then how could Iran give space to Taliban leader Mullah Mansour?”

‘Misreporting’
The Iranian envoy also said there was 'misreporting' on the issue of Indian spy Kulbushan Jadhav's arrest and his links with Chabahar, referring to the Indian spy captured in Balochistan, whose suspected base of operations was the Iranian port.

The envoy expressed disappointment that official-level meetings ─ which had gone 'very well' during Rouhani's visit to Pakistan, the first by an Iranian leader in 14 years ─ had been overshadowed by 'vested interests'.

In March, Iranian news agencies had slammed “certain elements in Pakistan” for spreading “undignified and offensive” in the media attributed to Iranian President Rouhani regarding Jadhav’s arrest.
 
.
Both Chabahar and CEP are not Rivals to each other healthy compition but they sure are a grave risk to port cities in side the persian gulf
 
.
People do not understand Iran's tilt towards India but when the time was right to step on American toes and develop relations with Iran despite the sanctions to escape the hold of America we refused the option. India at the time bought oil from Iran. So we were the ones who missed a great opportunity. As a Pakistani the chahbahar project handed to India even worries a Iran sympathizer like me but we have to keep things in perpective. US destroyed an entire plane full of Iranians and we are the same countries satellite state. That is bound to create some ripples in the relationship.

Pakistan should quickly reach out to Iran and allay their concerns. Talks are very important for relations and we should always keep talking.
 
. .
i have no concern of port i am worry abut you how you become saint over night ?:lol:
I was always a Pios person but never a saint you see i am a vegetraian who never even drinks a drop of watewr before my daily Pooja /arty and a trip to nearest temple its only the well wishers and ill wishers who are destroying my reputation ... Sachee Khans saheb :angel:
 
.
Both Chabahar and CEP are not Rivals to each other healthy compition but they sure are a grave risk to port cities in side the persian gulf
I guess you are fully aware of the Rail Link which has been formally started between China and Iran.

Iran is offering China to join the Chabahar deal as a Partner

If China decides in favour of Iran's Chabahar THEN China has the convenience of 1. already well established Rail Link 2. No threat of Terrorism 3. No passage issue with neighbouring countries for transportation. 4. No corruption related delays
 
. .
I guess you are fully aware of the Rail Link which has been formally started between China and Iran.

Iran is offering China to join the Chabahar deal as a Partner

If China decides in favour of Iran's Chabahar THEN China has the convenience of 1. already well established Rail Link 2. No threat of Terrorism 3. No passage issue with neighbouring countries for transportation. 4. No corruption related delays
As Me Always a Namo Bhakat and as he says i too beleve in him

SABKA SAATH SABKA VIKAS @ COOPRATION FROM ALL MEANS GROWTH OF ALL
 
.
I guess you are fully aware of the Rail Link which has been formally started between China and Iran.

Iran is offering China to join the Chabahar deal as a Partner

If China decides in favour of Iran's Chabahar THEN China has the convenience of 1. already well established Rail Link 2. No threat of Terrorism 3. No passage issue with neighbouring countries for transportation. 4. No corruption related delays
There is already a rail link planned between Gwadar and Chabahar.
 
.
I guess you are fully aware of the Rail Link which has been formally started between China and Iran.

Iran is offering China to join the Chabahar deal as a Partner

If China decides in favour of Iran's Chabahar THEN China has the convenience of 1. already well established Rail Link 2. No threat of Terrorism 3. No passage issue with neighbouring countries for transportation. 4. No corruption related delays

Iran china rail link distance is 10,399 kilometers. while Gwadar at max is at 2500km from western China.. do you think Iranian link will be feasible for China's ME, Africa bound trade?

p.gif

682-km rail line to be laid between Pakistan, China

http://gulfnews.com/news/asia/pakistan/682-km-rail-line-to-be-laid-between-pakistan-china-1.1713263
 
Last edited:
.
There is already a rail link planned between Gwadar and Chabahar.
China is already connected to Iran via Rail link

Gwadar will be connected to Chabahar as you have just mentioned.

Then why do you think that China will invest more money for a route from Pakistan with not that friendly Himalayan terrain and other related problems.

Iran china rail link distance is 10,399 kilometers. while Gwadar at max is at 2500km from western China.. do you think Iranian link will be feasible for China's ME, Africa bound trade?
Gwadar and Chabahar are only 80 KM apart.

Therefore recheck your calculations
 
. .
.
Gwadar and Chabahar are only 80 KM apart.

Therefore recheck your calculations

do you know what is China Iran rail link and its route, Iran is not direct neighbor of China like Pakistan?

First train from China to Iran stimulates Silk Road revival
Source: Xinhua 2016-02-16 01:36:05



TEHRAN, Feb. 15 (Xinhua) -- First cargo train from China to Iran arrived in Tehran on Monday, indicating a milestone in reviving the "Silk Road," which has opened a new chapter of win-win cooperation between China and Iran.

The train, also referred to as Silk Road train, has passed through Kazakhstan and Turkmenistan to Iran, travelling a distance of 10,399 kilometers. It had left Yiwu city in east China's Zhejiang Province on January 28.


http://news.xinhuanet.com/english/2016-02/16/c_135100997.htm

while in case of Pakistan, China can reach Iran within 2500km travel..
 
Last edited:
.
Pakistan should quickly reach out to Iran and allay their concerns. Talks are very important for relations and we should always keep talking.

Talks are important but what is MORE important is INVESTMENT

India is investing in Iranian economy through Chahbahar port AND Industries
in and around Chahbahar

Iran needs massive investment to make up for the lost time of sanctions

And since Iran has lots of oil and Gas ; It is an attractive destination for Investment
 
.
Back
Top Bottom