What's new

Capitulating to IMF will cause massive unemployment, warns economist

Devil Soul

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Jun 28, 2010
Messages
22,931
Reaction score
45
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Capitulating to IMF will cause massive unemployment, warns economist

Listen





469197_9481259_Dr-Kaiser-Bengali_akhbar.jpg



The International Monetary Fund (IMF) has one-point agenda in Pakistan, namely the privatisation of all the assets of the country which will cause large-scale unemployment.

Economist and former adviser to the Sindh and Balochistan chief ministers Dr Kaiser Bengali stated this while speaking on Thursday evening at a consultation meeting, titled ‘The current economic scenario and its effects on the common man’, at the Arts Council of Pakistan.



Related Stories


The event was held under the aegis of the Pakistan Institute of Labour Education and Research (Piler) and the Shaheed Zulfikar Ali Bhutto Institute of Science and Technology (Szabist).

Dr Bengali said he feared that after selling off all the national assets to foreign conglomerates, the government would also sell off the natural resources. He maintained that the PTCL, which was privatised in the Musharraf era, owed $800million to the Pakistani government which was still not forthcoming.

According to the economist, the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) had been in the grip of the IMF-World Bank duo for the last 16 years during which period it was overseen by Dr Mohammad Yaqub, Dr Ishrat Husain and Dr Shamshad Akhtar.

Talking about technocrats, he said any technocrat who did not have their roots in the masses was no better than a contractor and they just would not be bothered about national or public welfare.

“Now”, he said, “The World Bank and the IMF have taken over total control of the Pakistani economy and have established their stranglehold on it.” Talking about Dr Hafeez Sheikh’s reported obstinacy, he said, “It’s because he knows that he is just answerable to Washington.”

Dr Bengali attributed the failing economy to the decisions of increasing non-productive expenditures. He said many new ministries were made without any good reason like the ministry of national reconciliation.

By increasing expenditures, we were increasing the dollar gap, he said, adding that when our imports outstripped our exports, the dollar gap would widen.

He said that till recently for every $100 of exports, we had $125 of imports. Now, he said, for every $100 of exports there were $230 of imports. He added that in most of our cities, department stores were just stacked with imported consumer items so much so that a locally manufactured product was really hard to come by.

The speaker predicted that by the coming December, a dollar would be worth Rs200 and next year around this time, it would be worth Rs250. He firmly asserted that we had to cut back on non-development expenditures right away, otherwise, things would get totally out of hand.

According to Dr Bengali, foreign companies in Pakistan converted their profits into dollars and then remitted them back home, which drained the country’s dollar reserves. He said the country right now was in the grip of ‘Mir Jaffers’. He remarked that there could be no revolution as the era of revolutions was over. However, he said industrialisation could break the back of feudalism.

Zehra Khan of the Home-Based Women Workers Federation said it was after a great struggle that they had made the provincial government pay the mandated Rs16,200 to a labourer but even that was a pittance under the present circumstances given the back-breaking inflation.

She said that the public would have to be mobilised to launch a struggle for their genuine rights. Political parties, she said, were least bothered about the plight of the toiling have-nots.

Piler Executive Director Karamat Ali quoted a recent World Bank study which stipulated that a large majority of Pakistanis were living on $2 per day, which was well below the poverty line. Tracing Pakistan’s involvement with the IMF from 1988 onwards, he said real incomes had dropped by 50 per cent since then. He said, “The Nawaz Sharif government went on a privatisation spree as a result of which we stand de-industrialised today.”

Dr Riaz Shaikh, dean of the Szabist social sciences department, towards the beginning of the consultation, pointed to the air of fear that had been bred in the country whereby people were scared of speaking their minds out on issues affecting them for fear of punitive reprisals. He pointed out the repressive measures that the media was being subjected to in order to stifle freedom of thought and expression, and debate on vital issues.

The speeches of the main speakers were followed by an animated and highly charged question-answer session.
https://www.thenews.com.pk/print/46...ll-cause-massive-unemployment-warns-economist
 
.
Capitulating to IMF will cause massive unemployment, warns economist

Listen





469197_9481259_Dr-Kaiser-Bengali_akhbar.jpg



The International Monetary Fund (IMF) has one-point agenda in Pakistan, namely the privatisation of all the assets of the country which will cause large-scale unemployment.

Economist and former adviser to the Sindh and Balochistan chief ministers Dr Kaiser Bengali stated this while speaking on Thursday evening at a consultation meeting, titled ‘The current economic scenario and its effects on the common man’, at the Arts Council of Pakistan.



Related Stories


The event was held under the aegis of the Pakistan Institute of Labour Education and Research (Piler) and the Shaheed Zulfikar Ali Bhutto Institute of Science and Technology (Szabist).

Dr Bengali said he feared that after selling off all the national assets to foreign conglomerates, the government would also sell off the natural resources. He maintained that the PTCL, which was privatised in the Musharraf era, owed $800million to the Pakistani government which was still not forthcoming.

According to the economist, the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) had been in the grip of the IMF-World Bank duo for the last 16 years during which period it was overseen by Dr Mohammad Yaqub, Dr Ishrat Husain and Dr Shamshad Akhtar.

Talking about technocrats, he said any technocrat who did not have their roots in the masses was no better than a contractor and they just would not be bothered about national or public welfare.

“Now”, he said, “The World Bank and the IMF have taken over total control of the Pakistani economy and have established their stranglehold on it.” Talking about Dr Hafeez Sheikh’s reported obstinacy, he said, “It’s because he knows that he is just answerable to Washington.”

Dr Bengali attributed the failing economy to the decisions of increasing non-productive expenditures. He said many new ministries were made without any good reason like the ministry of national reconciliation.

By increasing expenditures, we were increasing the dollar gap, he said, adding that when our imports outstripped our exports, the dollar gap would widen.

He said that till recently for every $100 of exports, we had $125 of imports. Now, he said, for every $100 of exports there were $230 of imports. He added that in most of our cities, department stores were just stacked with imported consumer items so much so that a locally manufactured product was really hard to come by.

The speaker predicted that by the coming December, a dollar would be worth Rs200 and next year around this time, it would be worth Rs250. He firmly asserted that we had to cut back on non-development expenditures right away, otherwise, things would get totally out of hand.

According to Dr Bengali, foreign companies in Pakistan converted their profits into dollars and then remitted them back home, which drained the country’s dollar reserves. He said the country right now was in the grip of ‘Mir Jaffers’. He remarked that there could be no revolution as the era of revolutions was over. However, he said industrialisation could break the back of feudalism.

Zehra Khan of the Home-Based Women Workers Federation said it was after a great struggle that they had made the provincial government pay the mandated Rs16,200 to a labourer but even that was a pittance under the present circumstances given the back-breaking inflation.

She said that the public would have to be mobilised to launch a struggle for their genuine rights. Political parties, she said, were least bothered about the plight of the toiling have-nots.

Piler Executive Director Karamat Ali quoted a recent World Bank study which stipulated that a large majority of Pakistanis were living on $2 per day, which was well below the poverty line. Tracing Pakistan’s involvement with the IMF from 1988 onwards, he said real incomes had dropped by 50 per cent since then. He said, “The Nawaz Sharif government went on a privatisation spree as a result of which we stand de-industrialised today.”

Dr Riaz Shaikh, dean of the Szabist social sciences department, towards the beginning of the consultation, pointed to the air of fear that had been bred in the country whereby people were scared of speaking their minds out on issues affecting them for fear of punitive reprisals. He pointed out the repressive measures that the media was being subjected to in order to stifle freedom of thought and expression, and debate on vital issues.

The speeches of the main speakers were followed by an animated and highly charged question-answer session.
https://www.thenews.com.pk/print/46...ll-cause-massive-unemployment-warns-economist
Doesnt matter books have to balanced period ..

Cant run fiscal deficit of 8% for ever..
 
. . .
Capitulating to IMF will cause massive unemployment, warns economist

Listen





469197_9481259_Dr-Kaiser-Bengali_akhbar.jpg



The International Monetary Fund (IMF) has one-point agenda in Pakistan, namely the privatisation of all the assets of the country which will cause large-scale unemployment.

Economist and former adviser to the Sindh and Balochistan chief ministers Dr Kaiser Bengali stated this while speaking on Thursday evening at a consultation meeting, titled ‘The current economic scenario and its effects on the common man’, at the Arts Council of Pakistan.



Related Stories


The event was held under the aegis of the Pakistan Institute of Labour Education and Research (Piler) and the Shaheed Zulfikar Ali Bhutto Institute of Science and Technology (Szabist).

Dr Bengali said he feared that after selling off all the national assets to foreign conglomerates, the government would also sell off the natural resources. He maintained that the PTCL, which was privatised in the Musharraf era, owed $800million to the Pakistani government which was still not forthcoming.

According to the economist, the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) had been in the grip of the IMF-World Bank duo for the last 16 years during which period it was overseen by Dr Mohammad Yaqub, Dr Ishrat Husain and Dr Shamshad Akhtar.

Talking about technocrats, he said any technocrat who did not have their roots in the masses was no better than a contractor and they just would not be bothered about national or public welfare.

“Now”, he said, “The World Bank and the IMF have taken over total control of the Pakistani economy and have established their stranglehold on it.” Talking about Dr Hafeez Sheikh’s reported obstinacy, he said, “It’s because he knows that he is just answerable to Washington.”

Dr Bengali attributed the failing economy to the decisions of increasing non-productive expenditures. He said many new ministries were made without any good reason like the ministry of national reconciliation.

By increasing expenditures, we were increasing the dollar gap, he said, adding that when our imports outstripped our exports, the dollar gap would widen.

He said that till recently for every $100 of exports, we had $125 of imports. Now, he said, for every $100 of exports there were $230 of imports. He added that in most of our cities, department stores were just stacked with imported consumer items so much so that a locally manufactured product was really hard to come by.

The speaker predicted that by the coming December, a dollar would be worth Rs200 and next year around this time, it would be worth Rs250. He firmly asserted that we had to cut back on non-development expenditures right away, otherwise, things would get totally out of hand.

According to Dr Bengali, foreign companies in Pakistan converted their profits into dollars and then remitted them back home, which drained the country’s dollar reserves. He said the country right now was in the grip of ‘Mir Jaffers’. He remarked that there could be no revolution as the era of revolutions was over. However, he said industrialisation could break the back of feudalism.

Zehra Khan of the Home-Based Women Workers Federation said it was after a great struggle that they had made the provincial government pay the mandated Rs16,200 to a labourer but even that was a pittance under the present circumstances given the back-breaking inflation.

She said that the public would have to be mobilised to launch a struggle for their genuine rights. Political parties, she said, were least bothered about the plight of the toiling have-nots.

Piler Executive Director Karamat Ali quoted a recent World Bank study which stipulated that a large majority of Pakistanis were living on $2 per day, which was well below the poverty line. Tracing Pakistan’s involvement with the IMF from 1988 onwards, he said real incomes had dropped by 50 per cent since then. He said, “The Nawaz Sharif government went on a privatisation spree as a result of which we stand de-industrialised today.”

Dr Riaz Shaikh, dean of the Szabist social sciences department, towards the beginning of the consultation, pointed to the air of fear that had been bred in the country whereby people were scared of speaking their minds out on issues affecting them for fear of punitive reprisals. He pointed out the repressive measures that the media was being subjected to in order to stifle freedom of thought and expression, and debate on vital issues.

The speeches of the main speakers were followed by an animated and highly charged question-answer session.
https://www.thenews.com.pk/print/46...ll-cause-massive-unemployment-warns-economist

Faisal Wowda is someone the government Trusts with Water resource Management when india is building dams in Kashmir.

He is an Expert in creating jobs.
 
.
Pakistan needs to think about long term gains , we suffered heavily in 1992 and carried out reforms , earlier loans by IMF were used for short term gains by Pak without major reforms
 
.
The biggest traitors of Pakistan are people who understand the economic situation and have a voice but use it to paint a rosy picture.

The later you take treatment, the worse the medicine is going to get.
 
. .
Criticism is all very well but do we have a choice?

Even an idiot knows that if your income is Rs100/ pm and you continuously spend Rs110/- pm, the end result would be bankruptcy. Pakistan has been doing the same thing for a very long time. When are we ever going to balance our books? All attempt thus far have been halfhearted and reversed each time there is a regime change. Musharraf / Shaukat Aziz had made a genuine attempt to document the economy but it was stifled and as soon as PPP came in power; things went back to square one.

In my humble opinion, there have been enough discussions on the TV as well as in this forum and endless debates never resolved anything. Good or bad, the new economic team is here and we should wait and see how it performs. Instead, every effort is being tried to ensure that it fails.

At the end of the day the real losers would be Pakistan and its low-income population; i.e. the ordinary public.
 
.
We will soon see if this so called books gets balanced after imf loans.
IMF is loan shark that gives you loans when noone else will do(i.e when you are broke) and Pakistan is broke
But in return IMF asks you to balance your books .the reason why IMF has told the govt that why is your petrol, gas and electricity cheaper than bangladesh? When you make them via oil

Govt cant print money though previous govt and majority of people think it can..and that is the essence of Pakistan problem..the delusion that Pakistan can print dollars/gold as rupee printing has no value only gold & dollars has
 
.
Every tom d!ck and harry is economic expert these days. I know simple math and logic, which is that you can't continue to spend more than your income by taking loans forever. And you need forex reserves to float in market to control the market and Pakistan is struggling to have enough forex to fulfill the obligation and the geniuses are asking to burn whatever little forex we have to keep rupee high. Why not ask Chief Justice to take notice, and order money changers to buy and sell dollars at 100.
 
.
We need to grow spine and start using our natural resources (oil gas copper gold etc) otherwise we will end up where we are today after this IMF programme.
 
. .
Pakistan needs to think about long term gains , we suffered heavily in 1992 and carried out reforms , earlier loans by IMF were used for short term gains by Pak without major reforms
how how can she slap?

The day actual reforms are carried out our feudal polity will vanish, they will neither have the resources nor the people they fool to get votes, but it is a distant dream.
 
.
why not ban all imports of goods that can be manufactured here? why not ban import of components/raw material that are available here? why not force the industrialists to raise the quality of their products so that it can be exported? we are an agricultural country and yet we are importing fruits,vegetables, cheese, cream, chocolates etc from abroad. force the chemical and pharma companies to use local raw material, force the raw material producers to maintain quality. force the automotive industry to source as much parts as possible locally, toyota was established in 90's it has been nearly 30 years and they are still importing stuff, whereas when it was established, it was promised by them that they would localize the production.
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom