Canada's Sikh community in government.

[CHD]

Just a reminder, Khalistan movement long gone and dead but Balochistan movement is still up and running.

yes it is going on in UK and india but not in balochistan

 

[dadeechi]

What many people do not realize is that how well Hindus and Sikhs get along.

Sikhs visit Hindu temples and Hindus visit Gurudwaras.

I myself visit Gurudwara here in US with my Sikh friends.

People posting about Khalistan in 2015 are really clutching at the straws

 

[raktaka]

This is incorrect/misleading. Sikhism was formed by Hindus to oppose the Muslim invading armies from the west.

LOL ... does that matter ?

This is a propaganda piece and this is what it said.

"Amnesty International took up his case, as did a local Edmonton interfaith coalition. Sohi says the Canadian Security Intelligence Service, commonly referred to as CSIS, did as much to help free him as anyone.

CSIS investigated Sohi’s Edmonton activities, reporting to officials in India he was no threat"


Why did the CSIS get involved in his case when he was Jailed in India ? ....... ask yourself this, is this normal practice ?

He is now DEFENCE Minister. Apparently something in his background spelled "defence" ..... what do you think that was ?

For eg. did you know that That the equavivalent of Defence Minister in USA is Defence Secretary are usually ex-CIA ? Robert Gates, Leon Panetta, John O Brennan etc..


Put two and two together and then what do you get ?

 

[Godman]

What many people do not realize is that how well Hindus and Sikhs get along.

Sikhs visit Hindu temples and Hindus visit Gurudwaras.

I myself visit Gurudwara here in US with my Sikh friends.

People posting about Khalistan in 2015 are really clutching at the straws

Thats in India not the Skihs outside India for some reason

 

[Sugarcane]

This is incorrect/misleading. Sikhism was formed by Hindus to oppose the Muslim invading armies from the west.

Why Hindus couldn't oppose Muslim armies by sticking to Hinduism? Why they needed new ideology to fight?

 

[Roybot]

Why Hindus couldn't oppose Muslim armies by sticking to Hinduism? Why they needed new ideology to fight?

Probably because they were not united, cause of castes and all.

 

[dadeechi]

Why Hindus couldn't oppose Muslim armies by sticking to Hinduism? Why they needed new ideology to fight?

Earlier today I saw a thread on Pakistan's COAS offering prayer in Saudi. Why is Pakistan's army projected as an Islamic army?

 

[CHD]

Probably because they were not united, cause of castes and all.

but i thought india was 2000 years old

Earlier today I saw a thread on Pakistan's COAS offering prayer in Saudi. Why is Pakistan's army projected as an Islamic army?

its not projected, we are

 

[dadeechi]

its not projected, we are

Why do Pakistan's army need religion to fight? Can't they fight without the religion?

 

[Sugarcane]

Earlier today I saw a thread on Pakistan's COAS offering prayer in Saudi. Why is Pakistan's army projected as an Islamic army?

Is it your answer?

 

[dadeechi]

Is it your answer?

Yes It was.

 

[Sugarcane]

Why do Pakistan's army need religion to fight? Can't they fight without the religion?

Nobody in Pak Army ever changed/created new religion to oppose invading armies, while as per your claim Hindus had to create new religion.

Probably because they were not united, cause of castes and all.

Doesn't make sense, 1) Muslims have also been divided into sects. 2) If Sikhism is unifying factor than why all Hindus didn't converted to Sikhism?

 

[dadeechi]

Nobody in Pak Army ever changed/created new religion to oppose invading armies, while as per your claim Hindus had to create new religion.

What any Military needs is a common denominator that could unite them as a unitary force.

Sikhism is nothing but a militant form of the religion adopted as a common denominator.

Today, Indian Military has adopted atheism as the common denominator. @Joe Shearer is an example.

Doesn't make sense, 1) Muslims have also been divided into sects. 2) If Sikhism is unifying factor than why all Hindus didn't converted to Sikhism?

You are correct. Muslim armies were not united either and they themselves fought each other just like Hindu kings.

 

[Sugarcane]

What any Military needs is a common denominator that could unite them as a unitary force.

Sikhism is nothing but a militant form of the religion adopted as a common denominator.

Today, Indian Military has adopted atheism as the common denominator. @Joe Shearer is an example.

It's interesting to know that Sikhism is militant form of the religion (i guess Hinduism) - that answer many questions but raise some other. Do India still need this militant form of religion? or current secular army is better?

 

[dadeechi]

It's interesting to know that Sikhism is militant form of the religion (i guess Hinduism) - that answer many questions but raise some other. Do India still need this militant form of religion? or current secular army is better?

It's too late. The genie is out of the bottle. Hinduism has never been a united or unitary religion. Due to the democratic nature of the religion to encourage freedom of thought, it has always been producing new thoughts and religions like Shaivism, Vaishnavism, Buddism, Jainism, Sikhism. Even the recent followers of Sai baba do not consider themselves as Hindus and only go to sai baba temples.

There was only one instance where the genie was put back into the bottle by Adi Sankhara when he brought back people following Shaivism, Vaishnavism, Buddism (majority) back into the fold of modern form of Hinduism.