What's new

Can private ride-hailing services solve the commute crisis in Pakistan?

Dubious

RETIRED MOD
Joined
Jul 22, 2012
Messages
37,717
Reaction score
80
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Can private ride-hailing services solve the commute crisis in Pakistan?
Aliza Anees
Updated November 06, 2019


5dc12ded271a0.jpg

The lack of a functioning and reliable public transport system has long since been a problem in the country. But can multiple ride-hailing services manage this issue for our metropolitan cities?

There are 45 people struggling for one seat in a public bus in Pakistan,” Zeeshan Baig, General Manager at Careem Pakistan said on Saturday during a panel discussion on transport and mobility at the 021Disrupt tech conference that took place in Karachi.

Imagine the multiple opportunities that exist in this sector in Pakistan,” he continued, adding that "Careem takes pride in the fact that it paved the way for others to join the transit ecosystem."

Other panelists shared how they saw through the struggles people faced in travelling across the city every day, particularly women and children, and identified the need for cheaper and safer commute options.

Muneeb Mayr, founder and CEO at Bykea, shared that his company is capitalising on the existing network of bikes on the roads, instead of adding more.

We try creating more jobs per hour so the guy making a dollar per hour can make two dollars per hour. We can ensure profit maximisation for both the rider and the company if we structure ourselves as a marketplace running on a network of motorbikes.”

But what about safety?

In mass transit, we have one driver responsible for dozens of passengers. So we provide a thorough training to our drivers so they put forward their best selves,” shared Usman Gul, CEO at Airlift, an app-based, premium van service in Pakistan.

I believe it is more about the checks and balances you plant in the system and finding technology-driven solutions. Our reward and incentive system, where we provide our drivers with real-time financial benefits for the right behaviour, plays an instrumental part too."

5dc040143707e.jpg

Panelists discussing mass transit.

"We have an ecosystem with major air and space challenges that we’re trying to solve and I think the heart of all these urban problems that we are experiencing lies in the lack of a mass transit system. The opportunity here is to build a mass transit system where you’re transporting people in a manner which is efficient for all stakeholders," he added.

Some on the panel talked about implementing vigorous screening processes before hiring drivers for their mobility services, while others shared the importance of establishing sound relationships with their staff and providing them the training to distinguish between right and wrong.

Co-founder of Roshni Rides, Gia Farooqi, explained, “Human interaction and development is important so our drivers can be the ambassadors of our brand.

Gia's enterprise Roshni Rides caters specifically to women and children, who she says are affected most by Pakistan's mobility issues.

The disruptors unanimously agreed that their relationship with the government is not always smooth.

They explained that ride-hailing regulations that the government often sends their way in the form of levied sales tax and predetermined service rates do not help either.

“We have created over 6,500 jobs in the country so the government does not have to do it anymore," said Zeeshan. "I feel this public-private partnership can be a win-win situation for all parties.”

The government is the biggest winner here. They don’t have to build a new, mass transit system because we have ours in place,” added Mostafa Kandil, founder and CEO of Egypt-based transport app Swvl, a premium mass transit system that has recently expanded its services to Pakistan.

https://www.dawn.com/news/1514877/c...services-solve-the-commute-crisis-in-pakistan
 
.
IF even after spending BILLIONS on metro, we have gaps...it is a shame!

It is sad and nothing short of poorly planned and executed! Just in the name of votes!

In Europe you have a very well PLANNED network of buses that enables people to find a bus within a walking distance to reach a train/ underground station...and most buses run those routes or you just need to change buses...

But for Pakistan you build metro on pillars so expensive and despite all that it doesnt even link ALL the important points?! The stations are far from where anyone would pick a bus!
 
.
No it can't. Cities like Karachi needs huge systems with dedicated routes which runs 24/7.
Can private ride-hailing services solve the commute crisis in Pakistan?
Aliza Anees
Updated November 06, 2019


5dc12ded271a0.jpg

The lack of a functioning and reliable public transport system has long since been a problem in the country. But can multiple ride-hailing services manage this issue for our metropolitan cities?

There are 45 people struggling for one seat in a public bus in Pakistan,” Zeeshan Baig, General Manager at Careem Pakistan said on Saturday during a panel discussion on transport and mobility at the 021Disrupt tech conference that took place in Karachi.

Imagine the multiple opportunities that exist in this sector in Pakistan,” he continued, adding that "Careem takes pride in the fact that it paved the way for others to join the transit ecosystem."

Other panelists shared how they saw through the struggles people faced in travelling across the city every day, particularly women and children, and identified the need for cheaper and safer commute options.

Muneeb Mayr, founder and CEO at Bykea, shared that his company is capitalising on the existing network of bikes on the roads, instead of adding more.

We try creating more jobs per hour so the guy making a dollar per hour can make two dollars per hour. We can ensure profit maximisation for both the rider and the company if we structure ourselves as a marketplace running on a network of motorbikes.”

But what about safety?

In mass transit, we have one driver responsible for dozens of passengers. So we provide a thorough training to our drivers so they put forward their best selves,” shared Usman Gul, CEO at Airlift, an app-based, premium van service in Pakistan.

I believe it is more about the checks and balances you plant in the system and finding technology-driven solutions. Our reward and incentive system, where we provide our drivers with real-time financial benefits for the right behaviour, plays an instrumental part too."

5dc040143707e.jpg

Panelists discussing mass transit.

"We have an ecosystem with major air and space challenges that we’re trying to solve and I think the heart of all these urban problems that we are experiencing lies in the lack of a mass transit system. The opportunity here is to build a mass transit system where you’re transporting people in a manner which is efficient for all stakeholders," he added.

Some on the panel talked about implementing vigorous screening processes before hiring drivers for their mobility services, while others shared the importance of establishing sound relationships with their staff and providing them the training to distinguish between right and wrong.

Co-founder of Roshni Rides, Gia Farooqi, explained, “Human interaction and development is important so our drivers can be the ambassadors of our brand.

Gia's enterprise Roshni Rides caters specifically to women and children, who she says are affected most by Pakistan's mobility issues.

The disruptors unanimously agreed that their relationship with the government is not always smooth.

They explained that ride-hailing regulations that the government often sends their way in the form of levied sales tax and predetermined service rates do not help either.

“We have created over 6,500 jobs in the country so the government does not have to do it anymore," said Zeeshan. "I feel this public-private partnership can be a win-win situation for all parties.”

The government is the biggest winner here. They don’t have to build a new, mass transit system because we have ours in place,” added Mostafa Kandil, founder and CEO of Egypt-based transport app Swvl, a premium mass transit system that has recently expanded its services to Pakistan.

https://www.dawn.com/news/1514877/c...services-solve-the-commute-crisis-in-pakistan
 
.
IF even after spending BILLIONS on metro, we have gaps...it is a shame!

It is sad and nothing short of poorly planned and executed! Just in the name of votes!

In Europe you have a very well PLANNED network of buses that enables people to find a bus within a walking distance to reach a train/ underground station...and most buses run those routes or you just need to change buses...

But for Pakistan you build metro on pillars so expensive and despite all that it doesnt even link ALL the important points?! The stations are far from where anyone would pick a bus!

Metro projects in Pakistan are nothing but a tactic to get votes from the middle class and kickbacks for the bureaucrats/politicians. How can you be spending Billions on metro projects when your other public sectors are in shambles.
 
.
No it can't. Cities like Karachi needs huge systems with dedicated routes which runs 24/7.
Then what is the solution?

Problems:
Pollution
Irregular public transportation
Traffic jams
Cost of fuel
Commuting long distance


What solution do you suggest?
 
.
No it can't. Cities like Karachi needs huge systems with dedicated routes which runs 24/7.

Karachi is a mess mate, before anything else Karachi needs a massive clean up operation to get rid off rubbish including toxic waste. Karachi has no master plan, whatever the Brits built was never improved on although Karachi had a slight improvement and planning done during Ayub Khan's regime but since then Karachi's population jumped up because Pakistan failed to modernise smaller cities and towns in Pakistan which meant half of Pakistan still wants to immigrate to Karachi to look for jobs.
 
.
Karachi has no master plan, whatever the Brits built was never improved
Yet the same party was in power for what 4 decades?

This is nothing short of shameful! Yet Bilawal has the audacity to try to create rifts in the population by blaming other politicians for something his own forefathers couldnt achieve!
 
.
Yet the same party was in power for what 4 decades?

This is nothing short of shameful! Yet Bilawal has the audacity to try to create rifts in the population by blaming other politicians for something his own forefathers couldnt achieve!

Why would Bhuttos want any improvement in Karachi? If they had their way they would turn Karachi into a big interior Sindh with no electricity, hospitals or schools, they are feudal who rely on uneducated slaves to stay in power. Then we had the fascists political parties such as MQM, ANP and Jamaate Islami fighting over animal hides, land grabbing, drugs and weapons smuggling.
 
.
Then what is the solution?

Problems:
Pollution
Irregular public transportation
Traffic jams
Cost of fuel
Commuting long distance


What solution do you suggest?
When i visited karachi 3 years ago I saw tracks on roads for trains which used to run throughout the city. The only viable solution in my opinion is to revive these tracks. Because a system like metro bus won't be able to support the population of Karachi. The metros in Islamabad are already over crowded.

Hacing a public transit system will drastically reduce the traffic on roads becuse people who are going to jobs,unis etc will use it instead of taking a bike or car.
 
.
The only viable solution in my opinion is to revive these tracks.
I agree with this...We should improve our train system...especially for commuters from nearby towns...But our trains are mismanaged and offer horrible services...

We also need to teach basic manners to people! Like seriously its lacking! Its like the backward class somehow settled in the cities and their descendants still couldnt be refined?!
 
.
IF even after spending BILLIONS on metro, we have gaps...it is a shame!

It is sad and nothing short of poorly planned and executed! Just in the name of votes!

In Europe you have a very well PLANNED network of buses that enables people to find a bus within a walking distance to reach a train/ underground station...and most buses run those routes or you just need to change buses...

But for Pakistan you build metro on pillars so expensive and despite all that it doesnt even link ALL the important points?! The stations are far from where anyone would pick a bus!
Cause the metro only runs in one direction lmao. For a mass transit system to be effective it needs to reach each and every corner of the city. One metro line isnt enough

No it can't. Cities like Karachi needs huge systems with dedicated routes which runs 24/7.
One word...."subways"

Then what is the solution?

Problems:
Pollution
Irregular public transportation
Traffic jams
Cost of fuel
Commuting long distance


What solution do you suggest?
Electric subway systems

Karachi is a mess mate, before anything else Karachi needs a massive clean up operation to get rid off rubbish including toxic waste. Karachi has no master plan, whatever the Brits built was never improved on although Karachi had a slight improvement and planning done during Ayub Khan's regime but since then Karachi's population jumped up because Pakistan failed to modernise smaller cities and towns in Pakistan which meant half of Pakistan still wants to immigrate to Karachi to look for jobs.
Karachi has a master plan, soul was also built by looking at karachi. There just needs to be alot of bulldozing done.

I agree with this...We should improve our train system...especially for commuters from nearby towns...But our trains are mismanaged and offer horrible services...

We also need to teach basic manners to people! Like seriously its lacking! Its like the backward class somehow settled in the cities and their descendants still couldnt be refined?!
Just copy paste Tokyo mass transit.
 
.
Cause the metro only runs in one direction lmao. For a mass transit system to be effective it needs to reach each and every corner of the city. One metro line isnt enough


One word...."subways"


Electric subway systems


Karachi has a master plan, soul was also built by looking at karachi. There just needs to be alot of bulldozing done.


Just copy paste Tokyo mass transit.
You said 100% what I was going to say!!

No more gimics.

Time to develop a 50 year plan of building Subways.
 
.
Peshawar BRT is the solution :))

The whole Pakistan needs to be covered with Peshawar BRT.

If it can change the fate of Peshawar, imagine what it will do for the rest of Pakistan

But on a serious note, these ride hailing services are terrible. Can't find the captain on time and some of them are rude, nosy.

The solution is widening and cleaning and repairing roads and making cars cheaper by not destroying the economy.
Why Peshawar BRT.... why not Showbazi Orange Line Metro that goes from nowhere to nowhere while being an eyesore for the entire city and cost an arm and a leg. Or worse why not Multan Metro that has such low ridership that the bus windows had to be tinted black so that people do not know the buses are running empty.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
.
It should be the job of govt to provide mass transit instead of relying on private players like swvl e.t.c

Read this thread w.r.t problems with mass transit and peak hour traffic.



For a sustainable system we need a system that can be cycled to other routes after catering to peak traffic on main routes otherwise it won't be sustainable.

Either that or design it in such a way that it is used to maximum by utilizing connecting feeder buses e.t.c

ISB metro is not overloaded as they are still not using all the buses in order to reduce operating costs.

I have been using a combo of swvl and metro for last month and a half in ISB apart from present dharna days. In absence of feeder buses SWVL presents an alternative to link with metro (in times when I don't get direct swvl ride to my home station).

Swvl as a service will be sustainable if they increase prices down the line. This way they will increase routes. Govt would have to keep subsidizing metro and raise taxes from car token tax e.t.c in order to balance both out. Lets face it using car to go to office is not sustainable and not an optimal use considering average occupancy of 25-50 percent. It is better to tax them higher to curtail car usage in light of exponential population growth.
 
.
IF even after spending BILLIONS on metro, we have gaps...it is a shame!

It is sad and nothing short of poorly planned and executed! Just in the name of votes!

In Europe you have a very well PLANNED network of buses that enables people to find a bus within a walking distance to reach a train/ underground station...and most buses run those routes or you just need to change buses...

But for Pakistan you build metro on pillars so expensive and despite all that it doesnt even link ALL the important points?! The stations are far from where anyone would pick a bus!
if you ask a Lahori , our metro is best placed.... right through the center checks l important points...Universities, schools, colleges, hospitals, courts , etc the problem is population
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom