BSF shoots tangled teenager

[Md Akmal]

wats this,this is illegal to cross the wires.they are meant for some purpose

@ So you people are making fun with this killing ?

@ And now the Indian High Commission will say, " look at night we have a shoot at sight order, since the girl was crossing the barbed wire so BSF has killed her, it is normal in the border areas".

@ Sk Hasina our beloved PM is sleeping and busy with the trial of Nizami, Saka Chow, Golam Azam. Woo, I see today she is going to Rangpur with Ershad in the same helicopter.

@ I am sure, she would never dared to complain this to Indian embassy. Because, he is blind and moreso she cannot hear any thing due to the grenade splinter of 21 August.

 

[Avatar]

@ So you people are making fun with this killing ?

@ And now the Indian High Commission will say, " look at night we have a shoot at sight order, since the girl was crossing the barbed wire so BSF has killed her, it is normal in the border areas".

@ Sk Hasina our beloved PM is sleeping and busy with the trial of Nizami, Saka Chow, Golam Azam. Woo, I see today she is going to Rangpur with Ershad in the same helicopter.

@ I am sure, she would never dared to complain this to Indian embassy. Because, he is blind and moreso she cannot hear any thing due to the grenade splinter of 21 August.

What do you suggest we do ? Distribute sweets and love letters to illegal Bangladeshi immigrants on the border ?

 

[Last Hope]

@those bharti members, who support this incident...
Tomorrow, a news came 'Bangladeshi forces shot dead a Bharti teenage girl, trapped helplessly' how would your reaction be???

 

[silentinksoldier]

@those bharti members, who support this incident...
Tomorrow, a news came 'Bangladeshi forces shot dead a Bharti teenage girl, trapped helplessly' how would your reaction be???

ok..firstly...its india...

2ndly...

if the report told us that she had ALSO crossed the border illegally....then no doubt we would have been saddened for the poor girl...but we would have also recognised that in way this is the reality of the world....since she crossed the border she was liable to get shot...

personally..i TOO am sad for the poor girl.....but i can't blame the border forces.....they've got to do their job as well....

i believe that while such killings are given much attention...the causes are not...

its not as if bsf encroaches into bangladeshi territory..and starts killing at random....
underlying all such encounters....lies the fact that the international border was crossed illegally.....if the bangladesh govt. and forces took more measures to stop such incursions..i am sure the situation would improve......get a visa and visit india....the bsf wont touch you....

but frankly speaking..killing people who violate the borders..is something the bsf is PAID to do...

and while it is sad that such incidents occur...i dont see any way for them to stop...

as
1] there's a HUGE volume of smuggling going on at that border
2] if you lived in india you would know we have millions of bangladeshi refugees.....at the lowest rung of our society....siphoning off our resources..
3] bangladeshi terror outfits have made attacks on india...

we cant exactly be lax about all this.....because the bangladeshis cross the border like it doesnt exist...i dont see how they can be so casual about it.......maybe the bsf has gotten frustrated..and uses such means as a deterent

 

[Last Hope]

I get your point.
Lets make it in this way, you see a helpless girl, who is too young to be be a threat and who is unarmed, trapped, screaming and crying her lungs off, and you shoot her?

You could have arrested her, then take a huge amount for her?

If it was a boy, then case would have been different. What she has done is wrong, but what the bsf has done, is worse.

End. Thread closed, we are going no where.

 

[Avatar]

@those bharti members, who support this incident...
Tomorrow, a news came 'Bangladeshi forces shot dead a Bharti teenage girl, trapped helplessly' how would your reaction be???

I am saddened by the incident regardless of the girls nationality. If the girl was Indian then we would first inquire into what CAUSED her to cross the border ILLEGALLY and then take PREVENTIVE ACTION for any SIMILAR INCIDENTS in future. If people STILL WANT TO GO AND GET SHOT, then I feel no pity for them.

 

[Rafi]

By this logic, indian illegal immigrants should be shot in Europe and America, while crossing the border. Or illegal indian's in Australia - are beaten up, I hope our indian friends don't complain.

 

[Md Akmal]

What do you suggest we do ? Distribute sweets and love letters to illegal Bangladeshi immigrants on the border ?

@ With this attitude and mentality you want to make friendship with us. What a shameful people you are !

@ You know in politics there are some "Mastans" and "Gundas" who always dominates in the area or locality similarly you people can be compared with that and a time will come when some rival group will eliminate you people.

@ We people are peace loving, be remain in your court and be happy.

@ What you gain by killing these innocent people in the border areas ? If you have that much power than kill on the Pakistani and Chinese border . But remember, we will not remain through out like this !!!

 

[NALANDA]

I am saddened by the incident regardless of the girls nationality. If the girl was Indian then we would first inquire into what CAUSED her to cross the border ILLEGALLY and then take PREVENTIVE ACTION for any SIMILAR INCIDENTS in future. If people STILL WANT TO GO AND GET SHOT, then I feel no pity for them.

Avatar

More human approach is needed.....a life got extinguished......

BSF guy who shot it, he may be thinking it to be an Indian as teh crossing was happening from Indian side...was he trying to kill an Indian citizen........she could well be an Indian citizen..think of this....

if an illegal immigrant was crossing over ..what is the need to shoot..let her cross over......it would have been a different case if it was crossing over to indian side...

....I am actually too sick of these killings.....when will God bestow enough resource to our nations that nobody ever needs to cross illegally and nobody killls anybody....

I pray for the departed soul, her family, her father.....let all pray for them.

well I have nothing else to say.........

 

[PRACTICAL PATRIOT]

@ With this attitude and mentality you want to make friendship with us. What a shameful people you are !

@ You know in politics there are some "Mastans" and "Gundas" who always dominates in the area or locality similarly you people can be compared with that and a time will come when some rival group will eliminate you people.

@ We people are peace loving, be remain in your court and be happy.

@ What you gain by killing these innocent people in the border areas ? If you have that much power than kill on the Pakistani and Chinese border . But remember, we will not remain through out like this !!!

@ if you want us to let you do illegal things harmful for our nation in return of your so called friendship then no thanks we are better off without it. we always like clean friendships.

@we are peace loving too but not weak to be taken advantage of.

@ china doesnt send illegal immigrants from border they have better jobs in there own land, and pakistan sending any such illegal immigrants will also be treated same way.

@ we will be more happy than you when you develop, atleast then this people wont have to migrate illegally.

 

[saleen_s7]

Killing under any situation cannot be tolerated. There are violations and there are remedies for violations.
Yes, crossing the border is illegal and it's very easy for you to say that they are doing their job by sitting on your ***.
You have to realize that no one here chose to be poor. If the this poverty hit people wants to move to India thinking they might have a slightly better life, how are they wrong? The only mistake they made were being born and they hell paying a lot for it.
When it comes to setting up businesses and make money from us, you guys get here first. You should realize its a two way street.

 

[integra]

well heres how I see it

BSF (uncivilized, not so trained lunatics) ---well you see anyone near the border be it anyone just kill them who cares?

BDR--(civilized, sober and trained)---- well you see anyone near the border be it anyone (rohingyas,myanmar, indian) you capture them and follow proper international protocols then either push them back at border meetings or throw them inside the jail.


Well in the border areas you can always enter india by paying bribes to bsf. But no one bothers becasuse over there everyone has family members on both sides. So its quite common.

The poor girl and the bloody uncivilized BSF.

Well I know how you'll all shout 'bout BDR mutiny but atleast it was a domestic matter.

 

[Md Akmal]

killing innocent person is aweful but,

do you think BSF guys have 3 rd eye to find out one who is crossing a International Border illegaly is a terrorist or a normal person. that too when INDIA is going through many terrorist attacks???
do you think BSF guys should go near such suspicous people doing illegal things and first check if they are armed or not and shoot only after they get attacked???
if this people are so innocent why they try crossing border illegally when there are legal ways to do so.??

@ Look my dear beloved Indian friend this Felani and his family went to India for better job through mediater but once they realised that it is time to go home so with the help of local Indian people by giving"hafta" they were crossing the barbed wires but unfortunately this Felani could not and she had it.

@ Who goes in the border areas with arms ? Rather illegal arms comes through India. As it is reported in the last year(2010) alone 74 people were killed by BSF.

 

[PRACTICAL PATRIOT]

@ Look my dear beloved Indian friend this Felani and his family went to India for better job through mediater but once they realised that it is time to go home so with the help of local Indian people by giving"hafta" they were crossing the barbed wires but unfortunately this Felani could not and she had it.

@ Who goes in the border areas with arms ? Rather illegal arms comes through India. As it is reported in the last year(2010) alone 74 people were killed by BSF.

terrorists trying to enter INDIA, seperatists all this come through illegal means.

and do you expect us to open borders to BD?
what is meaning of having seperate nation then? we have 80% poor people as claimed by many members here so shouldnt we first let our people get jobs???
look i understand killing someone is not something good but blaming BSF for it cant be jusified either. they didnt go to there home killing them.

 

[Avatar]

@ Look my dear beloved Indian friend this Felani and his family went to India for better job through mediater but once they realised that it is time to go home so with the help of local Indian people by giving"hafta" they were crossing the barbed wires but unfortunately this Felani could not and she had it.

@ Who goes in the border areas with arms ? Rather illegal arms comes through India. As it is reported in the last year(2010) alone 74 people were killed by BSF.

Look dear, me or no other Indian supports the killing of innocent Bangladeshis. Any loss of life is the most unfortunate incident. We find no joy in hurting your people. If your citizens want to travel between our nations, there are legal ways to do so. The reason why BSF is so strict is because of illegal trafficking, drugs, fake money, etc comming through that border.

I agree that it was completely wrong of BSF to shoot down the girl, if it was possible to capture her. At the same time you must be aware that you cannot blackmail us into accepting illegal immigrants for your friendship. Lets give BSF the benefit of doubt.

In my opinion Bangladesh should cooperate with India to bring an end to these smugglers who take money from people to make them cross.

You say 74 people were killed by BSF in 2010. Now tell me how many people must have illegally crossed the borders in 2010 ? That number alone would be in thousands, if not more. So dont you think that BSF could have hurt a lot more people if they really wanted to ?

Remember that India is one of the most peace loving nations on the planet. Even the fake Indian currency notes smuggled through the borders have Gandhi on them.