Brahmasthra a Nuclear Weapon From History Channel

[utraash]

History channel is a joke.

especially when they run speculation on Aliens.......

 

[Skull and Bones]

And you think Indians contributed zilch??

No, when did i said that? I mentioned the collective contribution of different mathematicians of the era before Aryabhatta. What Aryabhatta achieved is definitely significant, but there were many similar stories in different part of the world. Equating calculating the value of Pie, to that of developing nuclear bombs and aircrafts is simply ridiculous.

Logic 101: Aryabhatta lived around 500 AD, so the ancient Indian scientists went on to develop an aircraft 5000 years ago without knowing the value of pie?

 

[INDIC]

especially when they run speculation on Aliens.......

most of their documentaries have alien connections.

 

[SarthakGanguly]

Aryabhatta lived around 500 AD, so the ancient Indian scientists went on to develop an aircraft 5000 years ago without knowing the value of pie?

What if Aryabhatta rediscovered the value of pi?

 

[Skull and Bones]

What if Aryabhatta rediscovered the value of pi?

What if people stop making stuffs up and adopt logic and rationality instead?

 

[Somras]

Extra terrestrial being possible, but if there was any advanced civilization, there should have been some relics to conform with their scientific achievements. No one make nuclear bombs and Vimanas in their pathsalas and gurukuls.

yes but you today have to reach those scientific levels to understand them - it is said Delhi is Indraprastha

now can you dig up delhi upto 100-200 meters to dig for ruins underground structures ? - No

the whole of Saraswati river flow as being suggested by sats can you dig up the cities - No

the whole of Gangetic plains is historical and ancient

can you dig up ayodhya to uncover what lies beneath

can you dig up mathura to uncover what lies beneath

No, when did i said that? I mentioned the collective contribution of different mathematicians of the era before Aryabhatta. What Aryabhatta achieved is definitely significant, but there were many similar stories in different part of the world. Equating calculating the value of Pie, to that of developing nuclear bombs and aircrafts is simply ridiculous.

Logic 101: Aryabhatta lived around 500 AD, so the ancient Indian scientists went on to develop an aircraft 5000 years ago without knowing the value of pie?

what if it is found that aryabhatta lived much before this 500AD date ?

if aryabhatta lived in 500Ad how come there are advanced mathematics in vedas - in mahabharat etc

 

[SarthakGanguly]

yes but you today have to reach those scientific levels to understand them - it is said Delhi is Indraprastha

now can you dig up delhi upto 100-200 meters to dig for ruins underground structures ? - No

the whole of Saraswati river flow as being suggested by sats can you dig up the cities - No

the whole of Gangetic plains is historical and ancient

can you dig up ayodhya to uncover what lies beneath

can you dig up mathura to uncover what lies beneath

Calm down. Some of these are proven. Folks like @Skull and Bones is necessary, else this nation will turn into a rouhani foujis believing Zaid Hamid's brainfarts. Sceptics are needed. As time progresses, more Dwarkas will be discovered and more Vimana Puranas will be dismissed as hoax. There will be both types - some will be validated, some debunked. That's how life has always been.

But yes, India's contribution had been great, and that is not disputed. The richness of India's civilization is still being unearthed - literally. Let's give the archaelogists time to their job, till then the 'mythologies' can be considered as clues. Time will tell.

 

[Skull and Bones]

yes but you today have to reach those scientific levels to understand them - it is said Delhi is Indraprastha

now can you dig up delhi upto 100-200 meters to dig for ruins underground structures ? - No

the whole of Saraswati river flow as being suggested by sats can you dig up the cities - No

the whole of Gangetic plains is historical and ancient

can you dig up ayodhya to uncover what lies beneath

can you dig up mathura to uncover what lies beneath

First of all, one has to come up with plausible reasoning for the deposition of 100-200 meters of sediments over ancient cities.

 

[Norwegian]

If it really was junk then give me one good reason why did the Britishers ordered it to be written down and later took it to Britain to "work" on it??(till then vedas were passed on by memorising it )

J. Robert Oppenheimer (originally Jewish), the famed inventor of first modern nuclear bomb quoted from Hindu sacred Gita two days before Trinity Test (first successful nuclear blasts). This led to wild speculations that there was some sort of "connection" between that and nuclear weapons.
J. Robert Oppenheimer - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

 

[Skull and Bones]

what if it is found that aryabhatta lived much before this 500AD date ?

if aryabhatta lived in 500Ad how come there are advanced mathematics in vedas - in mahabharat etc

The '500 AD' era was not made by me, that was the time period the archaeologists have came up with after carefully examining his work and timeline and i have all the reasons to believe in their methodologies than some random internet poster's 'what if ?', even then, the Gupta era lasted from 300-500 AD, so it doesn't make much of a difference either.

 

[Somras]

The '500 AD' era was not made by me, that was the time period the archaeologists have came up with after carefully examining his work and timeline and i have all the reasons to believe in their methodologies than some random internet poster's 'what if ?', even then, the Gupta era lasted from 300-500 AD, so it doesn't make much of a difference either.

well i cant posts links now

will post it when i can post links

The '500 AD' era was not made by me, that was the time period the archaeologists have came up with after carefully examining his work and timeline and i have all the reasons to believe in their methodologies than some random internet poster's 'what if ?', even then, the Gupta era lasted from 300-500 AD, so it doesn't make much of a difference either.

there ihas been a lot of CHORI of actual inventions and discoveries by western scientists to thier credit

wireleess comm
telephone etc

so while the textbooks, science journals EMinance credit them all know the actual thing

so keep your mind open to possibilites and alternate reserch

 

[Skull and Bones]

well i cant posts links now

will post it when i can post links

Make sure you post peer reviewed scientific links, not some 'hindu sanskriti jagaran' blogpost.

 

[Norwegian]

there ihas been a lot of CHORI of actual inventions and discoveries by western scientists to thier credit

ٰIts not exactly theft but finalization of an earlier uncompleted invention

 

[SarthakGanguly]

CHORI of actual inventions

All are not Chori. Even early helicopters were inspired from insects.

ٰIts not exactly theft but finalization of an earlier uncompleted invention

Bingo.

 

[Skull and Bones]

there ihas been a lot of CHORI of actual inventions and discoveries by western scientists to thier credit

wireleess comm
telephone etc

so while the textbooks, science journals EMinance credit them all know the actual thing

so keep your mind open to possibilites and alternate reserch

Telephone was western invention, but there is scientific consensus about the discovery of wireless between Marconi, Jagadish Chandra Bose and Tesla.

My mind is always open to possibilities and research, as being a budding researcher in Nanotechnology myself. But then, an argument has to have some plausibility and rationality, and a little more than 'What if?'.