What up with the Quarreling here? Every writer is free enough to express his opinions ... If anyone disagree hes free to ignore it.
Passing Analysis as Fact is more common that one would like to admit. Books come and go day after day...to write a book is deceptively easy IQ is hardly needed, eloquence,Vocabulary and some diligence is all whats needed.
Arundati Roy is an apt example.
To actually seize the psyche of the audience is what makes a book sell , be it Fact or an Analysis . Analysis Like this one, can be never Passed on for Facts as it is always as limited as the amount of accumulated proof, Punctuality is always key , as time goes by Newer realities emerge .. Alas analysis have a dual capacity to become a refreshing retrospective or a Moronic chatter, as the Time flies past.