What's new

BJP slams Digvijay Singh for remarks on Hindu refugees

I still can not understand mind set of this radical extremist hindu politicians of India... At 1st this bharti politicians blamed congress for supporting illegal migrants and under claiming that both muslim and hindu illegal migrants are refugee are foreigners... now this radical extremist hindu politicians started to whining that he is anti hindu and saying all these to appease the muslim... From all these it is quite apparent that this story made by bhartis about illegal immigrants are only meant for election time vite bank politics... If really there are 20 million illegal bangladeshi migrants are there why neither of these bharati parties ever provided any such proof to bangladeshi government??? N if they have so much love for the hindu migrants they should provide Indian citizenship to them those who migrated to india during 1971 war or just after that... n it is quite logical to give citizenship to the people those who are living in places for 30-40 years... n case closed...N bharatis can keep their anti migration issue with themselves... I have found 1 source which made this funny and imaginary 20 million illegal migration number... soon will post about that n will debunk that in front of the bhartis and will shut their big mouth forever regarding this issue...

Offcourse there is 2-3 Crore (20-30 Million) Bangaldehay people here but they include Hindus as well Muslims. I guess Muslim Bangaldehay are around 10 Million in our country and most of them living in the West Bengal it self.
 
.
The official Bangladeshi census has shown that the % of hindus in that country has been falling steadily over the decades.

28% in 1941; 22% in 1951, 18.5% in 1961; 13.5% in 1974; 12.13% in 1981; 11.62% in 1991 and 9.2% in 2001

This is consistent with all pro minority countries.

I do believe if any of them have come to India, they should be sent back. If the govt there won't take them back or won't create conditions for them to return, then consistent with the two nation theory, the bangladeshi hindus should be given their own country in bangladesh. since this is consistent with the two nation theory, none of the bangladeshis here will object to that, after all, they are pro minority.
 
.
Why don't the Indian members show how minorities are discriminated in BD? They just go around talking about how Hindus in BD suffer and "the plight of Hindus in BD". Show us PROOF --

here

Vanishing Minority Population

Hindus comprised nearly 30% of the total population in Bangladesh in 1947. After the exodus of minorities following the partition of India in 1947, the hindu population went down to about 22% by 1951. Due to unabated persecution, intimidation, and forcible conversion to Islam, the Hindu-Minority population kept on dwindling and now stands at a meager 10.5% of the total population in Bangladesh (1991 census)
.

In Bangladesh, hindu population was 28% in 1941; 22% in 1951, 18.5% in 1961; 13.5% in 1974;

12.2% in 1981 and 10.5% in 1991. Hindu population decreased by 8% from 1961 to 1991

The vanishing minority population is understood from researching the census documents published the government. Fifty years ago in 1941, 28.3 per cent of the total population was minorities. The population of Hindu was 11.88 millions, while 588 thousand was other religious and ethnic minorities (Buddhist, Christian and animist). Evaluation of government statistics of 50 years, from 1941 to 1991, indicates a large drop in the figure for minorities. A comparative picture shows that the number of the Muslim majority increased 219.5 per cent while the Hindu community increased by 4.5 per cent.

If normal increase rate prevailed, the number of the Hindu community in this country would have been 32.5 million, but the Hindu population in Bangladesh stood at 12.5 million in 1991 Census (State of Human Rights, 1994). Therefore the missing population is 20 million.

Ethnic cleansing of minorities in Bangladesh (then East Pakistan) started in 1947. Over half-a-century has passed with no end is in sight. Minorities in Bangladesh, including women and children were subjected to extreme brutality and torture following the last National Election in Bangladesh held in October 2001, forcing many families to migrate out of their "Homeland of generations" for physical safety.
Some "recent" incidents (2002)

( 1 ) 20th April 2002, at Moulavibazar district of Bangladesh, in Laxmipur village under Kulaur Police station several armed Muslim fundamentalists attacked the houses of Dulal Debnath and Jitendra Debnath, both members of the Hindu minority community. The houses were set ablaze. The group of miscreants led by Iuyas Mian of Balichiri village forcefully captured their lands. A case has been filed against them at the Kulaur police station.

( 2 ) 8th May, 2002, N. M. Jahangir Alam-A well known journalist of the newspaper Sambad which is published from Dhaka, was beaten up by Muslim fundamentalists. Because he was accused of publishing several news, reporting the poor conditions of the Hindu minority of Bangladesh. He filed a case at the near by Police Station but the police did not show the any interest in arresting the miscreants



Fig: Bangladeshi newspapers continuously featured on Minority Oppression after BD election

( 3 ) 5th May, 2002-in the morning, At the Dolu Bridge area situated in the Shattkaniya sub-district of South Chattagram, a group of Muslim fundamentalists kidnapped Rupam Mullick, a Hindu resident and damaged his arms and legs.

( 4 ) 23rd May, 2002, near Sadhurpara situated at the Chandgaon police station of Chattagram, the local Muslim fundamentalists forcefully captured the lands owned by a Hindu widow Charubala Nath (80).

( 5 ) 8th May, 2002,-in Narikelbaria village of Bakharpara sub-district situated at Jessore, a local Muslim extreamist, Saiful along with Kabir and other fundamentalists demanded, more than 1 lakhs takas (U.S. $2,000) as Jizya tax (tax imposed by non-Muslims on Muslims) from a business Subodh Saha. But Subodh refused to pay the tax. As a result the fanatics took a glass bottle fill with hot water and vehemently beat Subodh with it. He was badly injured. His two legs were damaged. Another person called Bablu Saha, who came to protect Subodh was also beaten up.

( 6 ) 10th May, 2002, at night, a Hindu journalist named Manik Mazumdar's office was destroyed by a group of right wing Muslim fundamentalists. Manik Mazumdar is the president of reporter's union of Madhukhali sub-district in Faridpur.

( 7 ) 25th April, 2002, 9 o'clock at morning in Thakurgaon district, Chandramohan Sarkar, headmaster of Shapla Adarsha Uchcha Vidyalaya was forcefully resigned from his post because of being a Hindu, by Muslim fundamentalists.

( 8 ) 7th May, 2002, at the Shathkhira sub-district, in the Sreerampur village a Hindu housewife was raped by a reactionary Muslim fanatic named Shafiqul Islam. A case has been filed but no adequate action has been taken by the police against the accused.

( 9 ) 9th May, 2002, at night, a Hindu religious place-''Aditya Asram'' situated in the Khashipur village under the Banshkhali police station of Chattagram was demolished by some Muslim activists. A group of 30 to 40 muslim fundamentalists along with sharp weapons attacked the ''Aditya Asram''. The priest of the temple-Pradipananda Purimoharaj was deeply injured by the fundamentalists. The property of the ''Ashram'' has been looted & taken away by the attackers.

( 10 ) 4th May 2002, at night, near the Biyanibazar of Sulhet district, a Hindu Brahmin girl of the Uttabhag village has been kidnapped by a group of Muslim fundamentalists and raped mercilessly. 5th May, the villagers rescued her but she was totally senseless.

( 11 ) 3rd May, 2002, at night, in Kumilya district of Bangladesh Brajendra Bhowmick, a Hindu villager of Haludia situated under Mujaffargunge Union was attacked by armed right wing Muslim fundamentalists. The houses of Subhash Chandra Bhowmick, Nakul Chandra Bhowmick and Bimalendu Bhowmick have been set a blaze. The local police station is still indifferent regarding the incident.

( 12 ) 8th May, 2002, at night, in the Nator district of Bangladesh, the villagers of Bashantapur at Shingra sub-district were attacked by armed Muslim extremists. The houses of Niren, Nitai, Atul, Prabhat, Dinesh, Ajit, Krishna, Jitendra, Basudev and Sukumar, all Hindus were looted. The families have decided to leave Bashantapur for India.

( 13 ) Recently, near the Patuakhali sub-district of Bangladesh, at Khachipara and Kalishuri village of Banpual-the Hindu minorities have been forcibly interned at their homes to keep them under observation. Shishutosh Dash, Bhabaranjan Das, Debendranath Sarkar and Hiron Kumar Sarkar were forced to sign and give away all their houses and properties to the Muslim fundamentalists. They only cried in silence and left their land to move away to any other place.

( 14 ) 20th April, in evening, at Uttapara sub-distict of Shirajgunga a Hindu clothes merchant, Nitai Sarkar has been attacked by some muslim exrremsits. Clothes from his shop were stolen that valued nearly, 1 lakh (U.S. $ 2,000) takas. Being mercilessly beaten he is now under treatment.

( 15 ) 15th April 2002, in the Chagal Naiya sub-distict of Pheni district, Khrishna Das (60) and Ujjal Das (27) Hindu vilagers of Sattar village has been severely tortured by local right wing Muslim fundamentaliss, because they refused to pay the jizya tax according to their demands.

( 16 ) 20th May 2002, at Bargauna district of Bangladesh, in Bukabania Zabar of Bamma sub-distrcits some Hindu owned lands surrounding a temple were captured by the Muslim partymen. They belonged to the fundamentalists group of the Bangladesh National Party. They have started to build their party office in that area.

Forceful Conversion of Two Minor Hindu Girls to Islam-Attack on Family Members:

Ethnic Cleansing In Bangladesh- Rahul Gupta

Minority repression and extra judicial killings has not stop in Bangladesh. Minority repression is a common feature in Bangladesh. Almost every day here happening minority torture.
Why Minority and Indigenous repression in Bangladesh still continuing? | BangladeshiHindu.com

In Bangladesh, crimes against humanity have become widespread, especially against minorities. Almost every day, minority people leave for our neighbor country, India. Minority women are constantly afraid for their security.

Peace, good governance, rule of law, and democracy are nonexistent in Bangladesh. Almost every day, perpetrators get impunity from the state. As a result, there is a constant increase in all kinds of bad activities in my dear Bangladesh. At the same time, sectarianism has increased very rapidly. And our religious minorities are suffering.Majority Muslims are occupying the minorities' lands, torturing them, and raping their women. It is a common practice. Everything has been happening in front of the eyes of the government. The present ruling party is always telling us that they are nonsectarian. Yet, they are failing to stop minority oppression, and the torture of minorities is still happening in Bangladesh.
Islamization and minority oppression in Bangladesh - ModernGhana.com

Ethnic Cleansing In Bangladesh - Bangladesh Atrocities | hindujagruti.org

Religious minority oppression is a common phenomenon in Bangladesh. Every day, minority oppression is growing at an alarming rate. Yet our government is not doing its duty to safeguard the minority groups. Why aren’t they doing something to stop minority torture? We don’t know. But we have been seeing that most of the perpetrators are linked with the ruling party. People think that the present government may be turning a blind eye at minority issues. We want to say clearly that the people do not want to see the issue ignored, but rather, that they want to see peace and happiness.

In Bangladesh, the brutal persecution of the Hindu, Christian religious minority and indigenous ethnic minorities is going ahead with full steam. Until now, the persecution that both communities faced never saw the light of justice. A culture of the denial of justice in Bangladesh is the root of all the persecution against the ethnic and religious minorities, which isn’t only affecting a part of the country, but is plaguing the entire criminal justice system in Bangladesh.

The minorities are still oppressing in Bangladesh | Euro Bangla

Now get off from your high horse, you are no angel.
 
.
Did not a senior member from BD said that Hindus Bangladeshis are not patriotic and will never fight against India. If this is the level of mistrust and hatred against the Hindus in BD, then I don't see any reason to fault the BJP's views.

They are being discriminated in BD, Good, let them settle in India as they don't change demographics, dont indulge in anti-social activities. And after all it is consistent with the two nation theory, the causus belli of modern India.
 
.

Tonight I am. Busy.... Tomorrow morning I will bust all of your bubble altogether regarding illegal migration and persecution of minority....I am just seeing the audacity of these bhartis everyday... They are from a country which is causing illegal migration problem all around the world and has consistency of discriminating and persecution of minorities, creating riot against the minority and it's politician rant and discriminate against the minority during the election time for vote. Bank politics has such a big mouth to speak persecution about minority in Bangladesh. just go n check your face in the mirror. We do not have or promote Hindu radical extremist terrorist group like rss, shiv sen a, bjp. This is your country that support such group and did not ban them yet. This bhartis kept on shouting with big mouth until they have been unveiled from top to bottom with it's true face.
 
.
You tell me to get off my high horse. You tell me that I am no angel. But let me tell you,

1) You have not shown any LAW that discriminates against Hindus. I asked you to show evidence of OFFICIAL discrimination against Hindus.

2) These are crimes, yes they occur. But these are ILLEGAL. And the Hindus can file cases against the perpetrators, and the perpetrators will be punished. There is no law that its legal for Muslims to commit crimes against Hindus, or vice versa.

3) I can similarly show you thousands of incidents of crimes against Muslims by Hindus, in India. But that would become a boring mudslinging thread. After all, in India, similarly, Muslims can go to the courts to get justice(for the small crimes, not for the large riots, btw). So I will not waste my time posting the other sources.

4) Crimes occur in every country. During Pujas here in BD often one group of Hindus attack other Hindu groups over organization of the Puja Commitees. Muslims also kill and rape other Muslims. Buddhists in the Hill Tracts set fire to Muslim's homes. Again, the law takes care of it. There are a few famous "Top Terrors" in BD who are Hindu. They fled to India when the CTG came to power. Are you seriously suggesting that for minorities to have equal rights there must be Zero crimes against Hindus in a country of 150 million? Are you insane?

5) Yes, the population of Hindus have gradually decreased. However, this in itself does not prove that Hindus are being oppressed. Almost every middle-class Hindu I have known has their children studying in India. They will settle in India. Other than that, lots of Hindus migrate to India. In '71 millions of Hindus emigrated to India. Don't forget that. Finally, Muslims, being relatively poor and ignorant, tended to have more children than the relatively better-off Hindus. This caused the proportion of Muslims to increase and Hindus to decrease. And also, lots of Hindus, especially lower caste Hindus, convert to Islam to escape the caste system. Another often-ignored thing is Muslim immigration into BD from India. One of my friends came to BD from India in the 80's by exchanging their homes with a Hindu family in BD. Then again, Myanmar expelled their Muslim population to BD in the 90's. So naturally the numbers of Muslims rose even further.

None of these are "torture" of Hindus. They can have more children, or stay here and not migrate. Nobody forces them to go to India. There is no law saying that Hindus cannot have children, or that Hindus must emigrate to India in large numbers, or that Indian Muslims cannot immigrate into BD.

I see that "fateh71" has thanked you for your post. I think that is indicative of the typical brainwashed mentality of Indian Muslims, who are always very eager to bash anything related to Islam or Muslims, without even examining the underlying logic. No doubt they do it to "fit in" with the majority Hindus in India, and to avoid being called a "traitor". Just an observation.
 
.
bangladesh is increasingly becoming safe heaven for fundamentalists and extremists. its high time u start taking action against them. leave us guys to tackle hindu terrorists in our own way.
 
.
this is in reply to Karthic Sri:

No, you are wrong. There is nothing to gain for a normal Hindu to be pro-India. They have more to gain from being pro-Bangladeshi, and nothing at all to gain from being pro-India. A sensible Hindu will be pro-BD. There are many patriotic BD Hindus who don't trust India. After all, what will they gain from being loyal to a foreign country? BNP has a Hindu in their highest level, I forget his name.
 
.
Bangladeshi Indians are being brain washed by the Indian Hindu's to transfer their money - assets to India (Looks like a good way to bring some money at India too). They leave Bangladesh only for the econmic reason, not for the oppression.

LOL, looks like bangladesh is inhabited by banglaeshi indians and bangladeshi pakistanis only, there are no bangladeshi bangladeshis. good, one more separatist theory has failed!

So according to your logic, bangladeshi hindus are coming to india for economic reason, that economic reason being handing over their own money to indians!!!

This logic is par for the course for the bangladesh related threads here. i won't fight it.
 
.
You tell me to get off my high horse. You tell me that I am no angel. But let me tell you,

1) You have not shown any LAW that discriminates against Hindus. I asked you to show evidence of OFFICIAL discrimination against Hindus.

2) These are crimes, yes they occur. But these are ILLEGAL. And the Hindus can file cases against the perpetrators, and the perpetrators will be punished. There is no law that its legal for Muslims to commit crimes against Hindus, or vice versa.

3) I can similarly show you thousands of incidents of crimes against Muslims by Hindus, in India. But that would become a boring mudslinging thread. After all, in India, similarly, Muslims can go to the courts to get justice(for the small crimes, not for the large riots, btw). So I will not waste my time posting the other sources.

4) Crimes occur in every country. During Pujas here in BD often one group of Hindus attack other Hindu groups over organization of the Puja Commitees. Muslims also kill and rape other Muslims. Buddhists in the Hill Tracts set fire to Muslim's homes. Again, the law takes care of it. There are a few famous "Top Terrors" in BD who are Hindu. They fled to India when the CTG came to power. Are you seriously suggesting that for minorities to have equal rights there must be Zero crimes against Hindus in a country of 150 million? Are you insane?

5) Yes, the population of Hindus have gradually decreased. However, this in itself does not prove that Hindus are being oppressed. Almost every middle-class Hindu I have known has their children studying in India. They will settle in India. Other than that, lots of Hindus migrate to India. In '71 millions of Hindus emigrated to India. Don't forget that. Finally, Muslims, being relatively poor and ignorant, tended to have more children than the relatively better-off Hindus. This caused the proportion of Muslims to increase and Hindus to decrease. And also, lots of Hindus, especially lower caste Hindus, convert to Islam to escape the caste system. Another often-ignored thing is Muslim immigration into BD from India. One of my friends came to BD from India in the 80's by exchanging their homes with a Hindu family in BD. Then again, Myanmar expelled their Muslim population to BD in the 90's. So naturally the numbers of Muslims rose even further.

None of these are "torture" of Hindus. They can have more children, or stay here and not migrate. Nobody forces them to go to India. There is no law saying that Hindus cannot have children, or that Hindus must emigrate to India in large numbers, or that Indian Muslims cannot immigrate into BD.

I see that "fateh71" has thanked you for your post. I think that is indicative of the typical brainwashed mentality of Indian Muslims, who are always very eager to bash anything related to Islam or Muslims, without even examining the underlying logic. No doubt they do it to "fit in" with the majority Hindus in India, and to avoid being called a "traitor". Just an observation.

the things u have pointed out are same for india also. muslims can go to court any time. yes we made certain mistakes with regard to hindu terror outfits but that is being corrected. so chill no problem.

can u give a figure of how many muslims have migrated from india to BD. the figure should be from neutral source. else u r theory will fall flat.

if hindus are sending their children to india and r settling in india then its because u have not been able to take care of them. they settled down in hope of better future and BD dint give them that future. period.

now was that all u got for u r so called bubble busting. u take care of u r own country and dont lecture us on wat do do in ours.
 
.
LOL, looks like bangladesh is inhabited by banglaeshi indians and bangladeshi pakistanis only, there are no bangladeshi bangladeshis. good, one more separatist theory has failed!

So according to your logic, bangladeshi hindus are coming to india for economic reason, that economic reason being handing over their own money to indians!!!

This logic is par for the course for the bangladesh related threads here. i won't fight it.

:rofl: :rofl: Are they professionally trained to think?
 
.
the things u have pointed out are same for india also. muslims can go to court any time. yes we made certain mistakes with regard to hindu terror outfits but that is being corrected. so chill no problem.

can u give a figure of how many muslims have migrated from india to BD. the figure should be from neutral source. else u r theory will fall flat.

if hindus are sending their children to india and r settling in india then its because u have not been able to take care of them. they settled down in hope of better future and BD dint give them that future. period.

now was that all u got for u r so called bubble busting. u take care of u r own country and dont lecture us on wat do do in ours.

One standard for oneself, and another for your neighbor. What is that called, yeah, hypocricy!

It was enlightening to see Janaji thanking his first post :)

He made some sweeping comments like you never hear BNP saying anti hindu things :) there are bangladeshi posters here who openly doubt the loyalty of bangladeshi hindus, calling them bangladeshi indians and also otherwise mentioning their doubts on many threads. And he's worried abt what a politician says.

Dude, all said and done, its the end result that matters, you can focus on the abberations, i will focus on the rule.
 
.
You tell me to get off my high horse. You tell me that I am no angel. But let me tell you,

You said there is no atrocities against minorities in BD, I was replying to your below quote

The facts are:

1) Despite BD being a Muslim country, there has NEVER been any riots against Hindus/Christians/Buddhists. But in secular India there has been riots against Muslims, Sikhs, Christians, and also Dalits.

1) You have not shown any LAW that discriminates against Hindus. I asked you to show evidence of OFFICIAL discrimination against Hindus.
The law of Bismillah is an official discrimination against minorities. In India , we dont have any such laws.

2) These are crimes, yes they occur. But these are ILLEGAL. And the Hindus can file cases against the perpetrators, and the perpetrators will be punished. There is no law that its legal for Muslims to commit crimes against Hindus, or vice versa.
Same goes for India

3) I can similarly show you thousands of incidents of crimes against Muslims by Hindus, in India. But that would become a boring mudslinging thread.

Agreed

After all, in India, similarly, Muslims can go to the courts to get justice(for the small crimes, not for the large riots, btw). .

Agreed except the bolded part. Any minority can file any case ( big , small whatever ) agaist anybody. Show me proof for your claim or stop lying.

4) Crimes occur in every country.

Agreed

Are you seriously suggesting that for minorities to have equal rights there must be Zero crimes against Hindus in a country of 150 million? Are you insane?

I never said anything like that.

5) Yes, the population of Hindus have gradually decreased. However, this in itself does not prove that Hindus are being oppressed. Almost every middle-class Hindu I have known has their children studying in India. They will settle in India. Other than that, lots of Hindus migrate to India. In '71 millions of Hindus emigrated to India. Don't forget that. Finally, Muslims, being relatively poor and ignorant, tended to have more children than the relatively better-off Hindus. This caused the proportion of Muslims to increase and Hindus to decrease. And also, lots of Hindus, especially lower caste Hindus, convert to Islam to escape the caste system. Another often-ignored thing is Muslim immigration into BD from India. One of my friends came to BD from India in the 80's by exchanging their homes with a Hindu family in BD. Then again, Myanmar expelled their Muslim population to BD in the 90's. So naturally the numbers of Muslims rose even further.
Show me proof for your claims.

I think that is indicative of the typical brainwashed mentality of Indian Muslims, who are always very eager to bash anything related to Islam or Muslims, without even examining the underlying logic. No doubt they do it to "fit in" with the majority Hindus in India, and to avoid being called a "traitor". Just an observation.

Typical ignorant rant.
 
.
this is in reply to Karthic Sri:

No, you are wrong. There is nothing to gain for a normal Hindu to be pro-India. They have more to gain from being pro-Bangladeshi, and nothing at all to gain from being pro-India. A sensible Hindu will be pro-BD. There are many patriotic BD Hindus who don't trust India. After all, what will they gain from being loyal to a foreign country? BNP has a Hindu in their highest level, I forget his name.

Karthic just reiterated the theory which is shared by many senior Bangladeshi members here, which is - Hindus in BD aren't pro-BD rather pro-India, and in case of any war between India and BD they will side with India.

Also according to a BD member, Hindus in BD will be victimized in case of strained relationship between India and BD.
 
.
The theory by senior BD members is just a theory. I have put forward an alternative theory, that Hindus have more to gain from being pro-BD than pro-India. So, assuming they are rational, and there's no reason to think otherwise, they would be pro-BD.

About Bismillah discriminating against Hindus, I have already offered you the examples of the UK, Scotland, most Scandinavian countries, which have a cross on their flags. India has the wheel on their flag. Go to the UK and tell them that their flag discriminates against Hindus, go ahead. Then come here to lecture us Bangladeshis. Just because countries have a symbol to represent their majority culture, it doesn't mean discrimination against minorities. Oh, and by the way, its not a "law" of Bismillah, its just a decorative sentence on the top, for good luck.

Look at our flag. It has a sun on it, the symbol of a Hindu God, Surya. It doesn't have any crescent or star. I think it is more justified to claim that BD discriminates against Muslims, because despite them being 80% of the population, it chose to use a symbol for the minority 10% religion. Imagine if the Indian flag had a crescent and star instead of a wheel. Imagine the howls of rage from the BJP howling about "Muslim appeasement". None of that happens in Bangladesh.

About the atrocities, I have told you once, the individual crimes are different from the organized riots which have happened during the Partition and in India at various times. And the same happens to Muslims, too, in India. There has never been any analog to the Babri Masjid riots, no analog to the 84 riots against Sikhs, no analog of the Gujrat massacres. So I stand by it, there have never been any atrocities against minorities in BD in its history (post-71).

Hindus migrating to India and having their children studying in Indian schools does not by itself mean discrimination. I don't know if you lived under rock for most of your life, but I'd like to inform you that, in fact, there is no difference between a Indian Hindu Bengali and a Bangladeshi Hindu Bengali. Neither for Muslims either. Naturally Hindus will tend to migrate to a Hindu-majority country and Muslims to a Muslim-majority country, all other things being equal, due to cultural similarities.

You take the comments by the "senior BD members" about Hindus to be the truth. Exactly the same anti-Muslim sentiments can be found by Indian members (ref. Temujin). And this is a Pakistani forum. I'm sure much worse anti-Islam sentiments will be found in Bharat-Rakshak. Would you say that Muslims are oppressed in India, based on the Indian member's sentiments? Are the senior BD members Judge, Jury and Executioner in BD, that you take their word so seriously, as if if they say Hindus are unreliable, immediately the state shall start taking actions against Hindus?

You are determined to believe, in the absence of facts, that Hindus are oppressed in Bangladesh. Even though a Hindu MP talks publicly about removing Bismillah from the Constitution in a 90% Muslim country, without any howls of anger about "Hindu appeasement", even though the BNP has a Hindu member in its highest council, even though there have never been any anti-Hindu riots in BD, even though you cannot find any communal anti-Hindu comments made by any BD political party, even though the flag of BD has a Hindu symbol and no Islamic symbol. This discussion is like banging one's head against the wall.

At the same time you would vehemently oppose any allegation that Muslims/Dalits/Christians are oppressed in India, though the exact same arguments can be made against India that you make against BD. In addition there have been riots.

:hitwall:
:hitwall:
:hitwall:
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom