What's new

BJP embarrassed again as RSS claims Hindus should 'weigh and assess their power'

. . . . . .
Would it then be fair to say that it is Hindu charity money that subsidizes Indian Muslims for their haj pilgrimage?

@The_Showstopper
What subsidy are you speaking of? The government's airline survives on these so-called subsidies. Muslims don't get any money out of it. This has been discussed hell number of times, Don't start with it all over again.... The only reason why Indian muslims have continued using this is because they don't have many other options... So you better ask your share of money from Air India. Anyways a few articles you might consider reading...

Haj Subsidy, Anyone? | Indian Muslims
Exploitation of Indian Muslim Minority in the Name of Haj Subsidy, Islam and Politics, Aamir Raza Husain, New Age Islam
Muslim leaders back cutting Haj subsidy
SC order against Haj subsidy welcomed - The Times of India

Who is Hindu?Ask any Indian,Pakistani,Bangladeshi muslim Haj pilgrim to Arab.they call them as Hindus not Pakistani,Bhartiya,Bangaldeshi.

Hindu is the name of citizens from Indian subcontinent.
No they don't....:no:
 
.
What subsidy are you speaking of? The government's airline survives on these so-called subsidies. Muslims don't get any money out of it. This has been discussed hell number of times, Don't start with it all over again.... The only reason why Indian muslims have continued using this is because they don't have many other options... So you better ask your share of money from Air India. Anyways a few articles you might consider reading...

Haj Subsidy, Anyone? | Indian Muslims
Exploitation of Indian Muslim Minority in the Name of Haj Subsidy, Islam and Politics, Aamir Raza Husain, New Age Islam
Muslim leaders back cutting Haj subsidy
SC order against Haj subsidy welcomed - The Times of India

Our point is simple, whoever is getting the money.

Why is Hindu money being used to subsidize Muslim pilgrimage?

Why should we ask for our money back. Why don't you get a modicum of self respect and refuse it in the first place?
 
.
Our point is simple, whoever is getting the money.

Why is Hindu money being used to subsidize Muslim pilgrimage?

Why should we ask for our money back. Why don't you get a modicum of self respect and refuse it in the first place?
Who asked for money? We didn't? I asked you to go through the articles I posted. Did you even care to go through them. Your and our money is going to ailing Government airlines. And you aren't only one paying taxes even we do...
 
.
Who asked for money? We didn't? I asked you to go through the articles I posted. Did you even care to go through them. Your and our money is going to ailing Government airlines. And you aren't only one paying taxes even we do...

I am not talking about India's piddly taxes. Even there, seeing the Hindu working population compared to the tax paying Muslim one, take a wild guess who is footing a lion's share of the bill?

I am talking about temple funds, administered by the state, which run into the millions. A large part of your community's subsidy comes from that as well. Why?

You did not ask for it, but you got it. Why do you continue to take it? Why do your leaders, Imam's etc. not pass a fatwa or something that taking a Hindu's money for Haj is haram?
 
.
I am not talking about India's piddly taxes. Even there, seeing the Hindu working population compared to the tax paying Muslim one, take a wild guess who is footing a lion's share of the bill?
The Lion's share is used by the Hindu population. Since Hindu population is around 80%, obviously they are the one who would mostly use facilities the government is providing. So no you are not providing for me... Its not that we are getting more privileges than you, so what are you speaking of...


I am talking about temple funds, administered by the state, which run into the millions. A large part of your community's subsidy comes from that as well. Why?
Can you present some proof for that?

You did not ask for it, but you got it. Why do you continue to take it?
What are we getting:angry:? I have repeatedly been saying that its your ailing airline which is eating the subsidy, not us.... And I did post my sources supporting it. Read them if you care...:coffee:

Don't bother me if you can't read them....
 
.
on-Muslims would never be made trustees or guardians of mosques.
Non-Christians would never be made trustees or guardians of churches.
Non-Sikhs would never be made trustees or guardians of gurudwaras.

So why should non-Hindus be allowed to be trustees or guardians of Hindu temples ?

The government of India, at the centre and in the states, actively places non-Hindus as overseers of Hindu temples. Indeed, Hindu temples are the only institutions to be “acquired” by the government to “make sure its finances are not misused”.
Why ?
Aren’t Muslims, Sikhs or Christians just as vunerable to their religious institutions being misappropriated ? Indeed, over the years, it has been amply proven that they are more in need of assistance than any temple ! The Golden Temple at Amritsar, along with several others, was misused by terrorists and separatists to hoard weapons, terrorists and anti-national literature. A major government / army action had to be instigated to remove this in the 1980s. Yet, Gurudwaras remain free of government control.

Recently, mosques and madrassas have been routinely used as hiding places by spies and anti-India terrorists. They have been used in Kashmir as safe houses and as arms dumps. Government is well aware of the activities of several Imams who spew communal hatred on weekly basis to muslims gathered for the Friday prayers. No one in the government sees it fit to regulate their affairs by putting a government body to oversee their activities.

Christian missionaries regularly convert people by offering inducements of job, money, housing and education. Often, illiterate parents are promised great futures for their children if they convert and send their children to the mission school. Amongst these missionaries, sexual / physical abuse is well known and internationally documented. Yet, Christian institutions remain free of any control to make sure they do not misuse the trust of their congregation or mislead people by convert by false promises.

Hind temples have never been misused to hoard anti-India people or literature.
Hindu temples have never sheltered terrorists or arms and ammunition.
YET, Hindus have to submit their temple to stringent government control.

Finances of the richest Hindu temples are taken over by the government and are redistributed by them as they see fit. Non-Hindus are placed at the helm of these overbearing government committees and all the wishes of the devotes are ignored to please the political appointees. Harking back to the days when muslims and christians ruled us with an iron grip, proscribing our religious life to force us to convert, the politicians of today, are hurting the Hindus.

Hindus should demand that their temples be free of outside interference.
Hindus should demand that only Hindus, and only members of their own sect, be allowed to sit on the committees that oversee the funds and activities of the temple.
Hindus should demand that they be in charge of how the funds contributed by them, are disbursed.

Hindu temples especially the well known, well funded, are often in bad state of repair.
Why ?

Hindu temples, especially in popular pilgrimage centres, are overflowing with beggers.
Why ?

Hindu temples, especially in sacred places are not peaceful preserves they once were.
Why ?

Hindu temples, once their finances are taken over by the government, are unable to use that money to repair or restore any part of the building without the government overlords’s say so. Pealing paintwork, damaged art works and stones covered over with lichen are all too familiar sights even in the richest of Hindu temples. Crumbling architecture is often allowed to fall before any action is taken. When action is taken, it is often not in keeping with the architectural style of the original and is often concrete walls covered over with tasteless marble tiles.

Security at Hindu temples is lax at best and non-existent at worst. No one seems to care or consider the impact of the recent terrorist plans on our culture and country. Even after Akshardham in Gujarat was attacked, no one seems to take the threat seriously !! Diwali 2005, Dehli was attacked. On 7th of March 2006, Varanasi was attacked ! The security apparatus in India needs to awaken to this new danger to our cultural independence.

Money flowing into the temple coffers is emptied with equal speed. Often temple priests are forced to rely on pilgrims to supplement their meagre wages, set to 1970s standards. This leads to priests being labled as greedy and grasping. They are only trying to earn a living, denied to them by their own temple boards.

In the old days, temples used to distribute food to the needy, poor, pilgrims and sadhus alike. Now, that their source of funds are seized by the government, they can’t do the charity work as before. The poor are forced to beg from the pilgrims rather than rely on the temple board to feed them. No social works are carried out by the government to alleviate the poverty in pilgrimage sites. They simply appropriate the temple funds to supplement charities motivated by their politically leanings.

The government, local, state and central, does nothing to help the pilgrimage sites from encroachment. Illegal land grabs, stall holders on every inch of land left vacant and buildings unsympathetic to the environment of the place abound. No rules are put in place to make sure the place is kept noise and pollution free. Shops blare out music of all sorts at high volume day and night. Open gutters, stray animals and lack of dustbins leaves entire pilgrimage site an unsightly mess. The money garnered from pilgrims, should be used to improve the environs of the temple town. Roads should be made easy to navigate and shops regulated to make sure they do not sell substandard items to the pilgrims. Noise and environmental pollution should be checked to make sure the sanctity of the town is maintained. Sadly, currently, none of this happens and Hindus suffer day and night in places that are most sacred to them.

Money garnered from hard working Hindus is siffened off to pay the minority projects supported by our so called secular politicians. One such example is the Hajj subsidy paid to muslims. Hindus do not get any help for their pilgrimages, yet muslims do ! Hajj subsidy is against the Sharia and is hence not offered by any Islamic nations, including Saudi Arabia. Yet, muslims in India keep availing this unfair, un-islamic aid. Christians are offered assistance by the Andra Pradesh Givernment to go to Palestine. Churches, missions and schools are given government land at throw away prices, where as temple lands are confiscated and re-allocated by the government to their political projects.

Hindu leaders, such as the Shankaracharya of Kanchi are unfairly accused to neutralise their power and appeal to the minority vote banks. By foisting unreasonable cases on them, the government hopes to drain them of financial resources and keep them in fighting the courts rather than carrying out the good works amongst the community. Swami Ramdev has proved, that the political parties are out to get Hindus in any way they can. Now that all allegations against his pharmacy have been proven false, I wonder if the political leaders who falsely accused him, will apologise ! Hindu religious leader was killed on Janmastami and yet, the government does nothing to help find the killers. Hindu leaders need to stand as one to make sure they are not taken advantage of by the government.
 
. .

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom