Bilawal spoke against militants, he has the blood of the Bhuttos of Larkana!

[Zarvan]

Bilawal spoke against the militants, he has the blood of the Bhuttos of Larkana!
By Malik Zameer Hassan Published: December 29, 2013

Bilawal’s commitment in his speech to stand with the working class and against privatisation is ample evidence that the PPP is back on track with its principles. PHOTO: PPP MEDIA CELL

Time does not heal all wounds and this has been the case with the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP). It can neither forget its scars nor can time heal them because this party – the party of martyrs – has come face-to-face with various tragedies over the past few decades.

PPP’s leaders were hanged, they were sent to the gallows, were exiled and were executed judicially. However, in spite of all the persecutions by the state authorities, PPP remained committed to its basic principle of democracy.

Since its very inception, this party has been struggling to inculcate a democratic society and a democratic government in Pakistan and in doing so, it has had to sacrifice many of its leaders and party workers.

Only the PPP has stood against dictatorship and paid the highest price in the form of the martyrdom of its beloved leader, Shaheed Mohtarma Benazir Bhutto. While the people of Pakistan and the political parties enjoy the fruits of democracy, it is Bilawal Bhutto Zardari, Bakhtawar Bhutto Zardari and Aseefa Bhutto Zardari who still mourns the loss of their mother. It is these children who lost their future, lost their paradise and again stand today on the land of martyrs, addressing the sixth martyrdom anniversary of their mother.

However, instead of being overwhelmed by their loss, they are once again roaring to stand against the enemies of Pakistan, against the enemies of democracy and against the enemies of peace.

Bilawal Bhutto Zardari’s speech at the anniversary was a much-awaited one for the workers of PPP, especially for those workers who have been in the party, not just because of the charismatic personalities of Shaheed Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto and Shaheed Benazir Bhutto but also because of the ideological stance of this party and its stance on land reforms, privatisation, labour laws and so forth.

Most of the senior party workers have been anticipating this address since he wrote a column against the government’s privatisation of national corporations in Pakistan. Another reason why Bilawal’s address was a much-awaited one was because of the prevailing rumours regarding changes in the hierarchy of PPP at provincial levels. There have also been rumours about Bilawal’s election from Larkana while the majority of workers want him to be in the National Assembly and play the role that once Shaheed Benazir Bhutto had played when Nawaz Sharif, the then Prime Minister, wanted her to come forward and wipe out the eighth amendment from the constitution.

You may disagree with me and you probably will if you have been anti-PPP in the past, but it is a fact that PPP’s Bilawal Bhutto Zardari is the only political leader who has a clear vision and stance and has been vocal against extremism from the very first day. The way he pointed his finger towards the Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) in his recent address was phenomenal. And PPP supporter or not, you will have to agree that no other party has had the courage to show this spirit against militants.

Some may argue that he has bullet-proof security and hence, was able to take that risk. However, my argument to all such thinkers is that such security is available and used by the likes of the prime minister of Pakistan as well as other political party leaders. Then, why do they not show such courage against the militants who behead our soldiers, exploit religion and have been challenging the writ of the state through their suicide bombing?

The fact is that this courage comes from blood and this blood is not so common. This blood which gives one the courage to stand against the enemies of the state, can only be found in the Bhuttos of Larkana.

Bilawal’s speech made it clear that the PPP will not step back from its policies – those policies which were introduced by its founder Shaheed Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto. His socialist policies for the downtrodden class of Pakistan, which have become victim along the line to privatisation, religious myths and taboos, loan schemes and even ethnicity.

Since Pakistan’s inception, bureaucrats and generals have been ruling and exploiting the country in collaboration with Pakistan’s superior judiciary, which paved the way for almost all military coups in the country.

Bilawal spoke out against the bureaucracy, military and judiciary in his speech and accused them for exploiting the country’s working class because they do not want their authority to be challenged. Hence, they use their state resources against the PPP which has been struggling to raise the status of a common Pakistani because it believes in equality and prosperity of the working class. Bilawal’s commitment in his speech to stand with the working class and against privatisation is ample evidence that the PPP is back on track with its principles. And this has been the demand of all its workers.

Moreover, Bilawal’s promise to re-instate its old workers is a clear indication that Shaheed Benazir Bhutto’s son values all the workers who were loyal to her. He has truly shown a statesman’s spirit by giving respect to these workers and the PPP is the only party of Pakistan where workers never demand anything – all they want is respect and if they get that, they will not spare anything for the party. They will sacrifice all they have for the party and its principles.

Although Bilawal’s speech was a much-welcomed one by the party workers because he spoke from the heart and admitted to the mistakes that the party made in the last five years, they must remember that Bilawal Zardari Bhutto is not Shaheed Benazir Bhutto. She was an institution in herself but she did not become one in a mere day or a month. It took her years and she struggled a lot, faced persecutions, exiles and was even sent to prison more than once. She sacrificed a lot to become the legend that she is.

Bilawal Bhutto Zardari is young and charismatic. He has strong leadership skills but it is not fair if we, the workers, start expecting the same from him at this early stage. We must give him time and I am sure that he will prove to be the gallant son of a gallant leader.

Bilawal Bhutto Zardari: The new hope for Pakistan’s future
By Akif Abbas Published: December 29, 2013

Bilawal has a clear cut stance against the Taliban. We need that kind of firm decision-making power from our leaders. PHOTO: REUTERS

During his recent speech, Bilawal Bhutto Zardari stunned everyone. His style and tone of addressing the masses atGarhi Khuda Buxturned the tide and changed the way many political experts used to think about him – such a performance from him was unexpected and refreshing for everyone.

He was consistent with his words and fluent in Urdu, which has been his weak point in the past. He was emotionally riled up and involved the audience. His speech was even witty, especially when he discussed the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz’s (PML-N) stance on extremism and their passive approach to the issue.

Along with other political issues, he even addressed the issue of the Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) and he listed the conditions that he planned to raise if a deal were to be made with them. He is probably the first leader to design a comprehensive set of conditions for the government to present before the TTP. I personally think that the government should consult the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) while dealing with the Taliban since Bilawal has a number of clear-cut ideas to deal with them, as seen in his speech.


Asif Ali Zardari also managed to charm the people. He discussed national issues and shared his views about the current government. He also expressed his opinion about Pervez Musharraf’s treason case and supported PML-N’s stance.

Both father and son were clear and in agreement that the current government must complete its tenure successfully in the spirit of democracy. This idea clearly separated the PPP from the likes of Dr Tahirul Qadri and other political elements which are against the very idea of democracy.

The neutral, progressive stance which the PPP has taken so far, in my opinion, is a mature one. And the credit for this goes to our former president and PPP co-chairman Asif Ali Zardari. His opponents might have a lot to say against him but he is a strong man. After all, he spent years as a political prisoner and completed his tenure despite its turbulent history.

He fought with terrorists and maintained his party’s stance against them. He even collaborated with the Army in difficult situations and explored different foreign relations avenues. He also stood against the US and the NATO supply blockade. The big achievements of his government include handing over the Gwadar port project to China and signing the Iran-Pakistan gas pipeline deal, which are both going to be of great benefit to our economy.

These types of things have rarely been seen in any democratic tenure in Pakistan’s history. I have highlighted these achievements because I feel that the media does not give them their due attention.

Yes, the PPP has made many poor decisions, which includes bad governance, but that does not mean that we turn a blind eye to all the good that they have done.

I see Bilawal becoming an able and strong prime minister in the future, while Aseefa will probably hold an important position at a ministry – whereas Asif Ali Zardari will once again sit in the presidency. So, for me, the future of the PPP is bright, especially keeping in mind the new blood which is pumping through this historic institution’s views.

I am sure that many people will not agree with me and will criticise this piece but these things mentioned are the ground realities of our political arena and being a neutral observer, these are my predictions for the PPP in the upcoming years.

Times are changing and so is Pakistani politics. We need to understand, appreciate and accept the new, young and agile candidates who have entered this field to bring in prosperity and progress for the country.

he spoke against militants because he is the grand son of a terrorist who killed his own political opponents the Rafiq father of Saad Rafiq the JI leader the father of Qasoori and many more and same was done by his mother who was nothing but a corrupt brutal destroyed Pakistan economy

 

[pak-marine]

THE interest a large section of society showed in Bilawal Bhutto Zardari’s speech of last Friday is understandable. The qualities of leadership he can display will be an important factor in the remaking of the Pakistan Peoples Party.

One does not have to be a supporter of the PPP to realise that its resurrection is necessary for keeping alive the option of establishing egalitarian democracy. It is for the same reason one welcomes the signs of activism in left-of-centre groups, such as the campaign for land reforms of the Awami Workers’ Party and the decision of the Awami Party of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan’s National Party to work together.

These efforts are welcome because the political landscape is now almost wholly occupied by rightist formations — from right and extreme right to militant right.

In this situation there will be little room for welfarism, basic liberties will be at a discount, the space for civil society organisations is bound to shrink, and the moves to end the imbalance in civil-military relations may run aground. The rise of indigenous neo-con theorists is ominous because they have less capacity to do good than their Western godfathers while their potential for causing harm is perhaps unlimited.

Pakistan badly needs strong left-of-centre voices to prevent the state from becoming completely insensitive to the needs and aspirations of the impoverished masses. The developments in PPP are important because of the party’s past successes and since it still has a power base in one federating unit.

There was much in Bilawal’s latest speech that deserved notice. His stand on terrorism, for instance, won applause for his courage and clarity of perception. He should know that there is no possibility of a non-Muslim’s becoming prime minister for many decades, yet he lifted the hearts of non-Muslim citizens as nothing else has done since the Aug 11, 1947 speech of the Quaid-i-Azam. Still, much more has to go into Bilawal’s education and training before he can claim the mantle of his mother and grandfather.

The stress on the grooming of Bilawal seems to be part of the belief that the PPP must throw up a dominating leader who has a direct rapport with the masses. That alone will not be enough. The party has a huge leadership vacuum at the centre. Most of the dignitaries that flanked the party chief during the recent past have pushed themselves into the political wilderness and are more of liabilities than assets. In fact, the decline in the quality of the party’s central leadership has been going on for nearly two decades.

Mr Bhutto was fortunate in having around him quite a few leaders of standing in politics whom he often had to listen to. As he lost them one after another the quality of central leadership declined and Benazir Bhutto had to make do with a company in which spurious coins freely jostled with genuine currency. Bilawal will not be able to do much unless the gap at the top is filled by persons of high calibre and unimpeachable integrity.

The same holds good for the party’s leadership at the provincial level. One of the major mistakes of the PPP during the past six years or so has been its lack of interest in training good provincial leaders. It needs efficient organisers at the district and city levels too.

The PPP will do itself wrong if it does not properly analyse its latest debacle. Mr Zardari is miles off the mark when he says that the party sacrificed 100 seats in order to save its workers’ lives. The plain fact is that in the last election, the PPP had neither workers of the kind it had 10-20 years ago nor local level leaders. Worse, in the 2013 general election it suffered a hefty erosion of its vote bank, something that had never happened before.

The party has never bothered to understand why the educated middle class, the lower middle class, the artisans and petty businessmen, and the workers, on whose support the party rode to popularity in 1970, deserted it in the years that followed. This exercise has long been overdue.

The politically conscious and hordes of the poor had flocked to the PPP in 1969-70 because of what it stood for. What does it stand for now?

The slogans of 1970 have little pull today. The party in its bid to woo the affluent sections of society gave up the cause of peasants and workers long ago, a costly blunder. Punjab can no longer be seduced with the promise of a 1000-year war with India. Roti, kapra aur makan — the slogan of unmatched strength ever — does not move the have-nots because no set of rulers showed the will to fulfil its promise.

The PPP also needs to give up the habit of blaming external elements for its misfortunes. That thesis is only partly correct; for much of its undoing the party has to blame itself.

The people need a new political thesis that offers something to all the diverse elements constituting Pakistan’s pluralist society. The remaking of PPP demands a great deal of work at the grass-roots level so that the party can win back the alienated cadres and convert the youth to its point of view. Electoral politics is important but more important perhaps is the need to build the party from the village and town level up. There is more wisdom and a greater capacity for sacrifices there than at the top.

 

[Developereo]

How can a party that doesn't practice egalitarianism and meritocracy within its own ranks claim to do so for the country at large?

The sheep will continue to chant "Jiay Bhutto" (even though Billy boy is a Zardari), but thinking people should not be fooled by this dynastic politics.

 

[Rafael]

He had the courage to call spade a spade & terrorist a terrorist .. unlike the rest of the garbage , cowardly , Hippocratic leaders we have in Pakistani politics

After ruling the country for 5 years, he only 'calls' them a terrorist.

Indeed he is a Bhutto. All he can do is talk!

 

[pak-marine]

After ruling the country for 5 years, he only 'calls' them a terrorist.

Indeed he is a Bhutto. All he can do is talk!

start some where .. under the circumstances when no one utters a word after all the terrorism.

 

[Mav3rick]

start some where .. under the circumstances when no one utters a word after all the terrorism.

What happened to you mate? I thought you were pro MQM?

 

[pak-marine]

What happened to you mate? I thought you were pro MQM?

yes i am pro MQM when it comes to politics but i think we also have to appreciate every one who stood up against these tyrants , give credit where its due

 

[Crypto]

 

[pak-marine]

he spoke against militants because he is the grand son of a terrorist who killed his own political opponents the Rafiq father of Saad Rafiq the JI leader the father of Qasoori and many more and same was done by his mother who was nothing but a corrupt brutal destroyed Pakistan economy

his mother (silly policy in my view) was among the vary creator of these Talibani snakes .. His grand father were the first ones in global leaders who helped start insurgency against earlier Afghan govts (again a stupid move in my opinion) ..Bhuttos were silly and stupid they trusted the extremist snakes , he isnt and i hope stays this way

 

[Developereo]

.Bhuttos were silly and stupid they trusted the extremist snakes , he isnt and i hope stays this way

Do you truly honestly believe that?

Do you think he utters a single word in public which hasn't been carefully crafted by a bevy of consultants?

If he was such a reformer, he could have gone outside and told the PPP goons and the police to step back and to tear down the illegal wall at his house in Karachi.

If educated people like you fall for this charlatan, there is little hope for Pakistan.

 

[pak-marine]

Do you truly honestly believe that?

Do you think he utters a single word in public which hasn't been carefully crafted by a bevy of consultants?

If he was such a reformer, he could have gone outside and told the PPP goons and the police to step back and to tear down the illegal wall at his house in Karachi.

If educated people like you fall for this charlatan, there is little hope for Pakistan.

he is a politician leads masses off course he will have a speech writer ... the wall is primarily due to serious security concerns and being a karachiete having witnessed the mayhem in the past i can understand its importance .. we witnessed 27th december and the aftermath what happened on those 5 days very little is reported .. the fuss is more about 12th may any further any incident could trigger serious anti punjabi sentiment across sindh. So i wont be jazbati kid and be rational about this wall and let it stay untill scum bag jihadis and extremists are rooted out and may be may be try removing those hundreds and thousands of illegals aliens from karachi first who occupy our lands and those areas are no go areas for decades now.

 

[Developereo]

he is a politician leads masses off course he will have a speech writer ... the wall is primarily due to serious security concerns and being a karachiete having witnessed the mayhem in the past i can understand its importance .. we witnessed 27th december and the aftermath what happened on those 5 days very little is reported .. the fuss is more about 12th may any further any incident could trigger serious anti punjabi sentiment across sindh. So i wont be jazbati kid and be rational about this wall and let it stay untill scum bag jihadis and extremists are rooted out and may be may be try removing those hundreds and thousands of illegals aliens from karachi first who occupy our lands and those areas are no go areas for decades now.

So you're saying the Sindh court got it wrong and the PPP is right?

What a brilliant example of citizenship this "future leader" of the people is setting: Ignore the law if you don't like it.

That alone tells me this guy is bullshitting.

He is a feudal vampire through and through.

 

[Cheetah786]

 

[pak-marine]

So you're saying the Sindh court got it wrong and the PPP is right?

What a brilliant example of citizenship this "future leader" of the people is setting: Ignore the law if you don't like it.

That alone tells me this guy is bullshitting.

He is a feudal vampire through and through.

He is threatened by savage blood thirsty extremists monsters , his mother was killed. The wall was never there in the past until their was little or zero threat to him or the ex - president.Now threat and act are both on record.

No he isnt nor the sindh govt is not above the judiciary although the same courts have released those killers understandably they were also threatened by killers but easier for them to just pack and leave whereas impossible for these people since they run a party and are representatives of people.

 

[Peaceful Civilian]

please do a DNA test here ...

I think bilawal is shemale. look his videos, actions, way of speaking ,and gestures.
Ontopic. This is good stance against Taliban. Unlike PMLN, PPP is openly speaking against Taliban even they still facing serious threats.