Bilawal says PPP to make new province in south Punjab

[somebozo]

Charity begins at home..start with Karachi first..Since Karachi has very distinct identity from Rest of the Sindh and in any case PPP has never done justice to Karachi starting from ethinic riots of bhutto to Zardaris china cutting...

In Sindh they are waderas and in punjab and KP they show themselves as left wing party of poor peasants, Bhutto old roti kapra makan tricks will no longer work.

Ironically it was the punjabi agrarian class which voted in majority for bhutto out of their narrow mentality towards modern industrialization and eventually they suffered the most under bhutto nationalization..

Sindh has been reduced to a money making machine (via corruption) for the PPP and those with connections to the PPP elite and there will be absolutely no change in the PPP so long as Zardari and family are in control.

Has any seen bilawal house and the security enforcement around it?
It has made life hell for ordinary citizens passing by that area every day in hectic traffic jams..
One is made to ponder, what sort of sick ruling class we have imposed upon ourself?

Baluchistan has all reason for being backward ... but Sindh backwardness is beyond my understanding . Para likha jahil

not only jahil but also big time choor...

 

[Yaseen1]

they know they cannot win in punjab because all educated and major population will elect pti after pmln break down so they wantt some share to loot .more provinces will weaken federation and difficult to manage as 18 amendment has already hurt provinces harmony.we need to strengthen local govt system to devolve power to bottom level

 

[Dastaan]

1414

 

[AZADPAKISTAN2009]

There should be atleast a dozen provinces in Pakistan, not based on ethnicity or language.

Pakistani provinces are too big where only one major city gets the development and others lack. Cities get overpopulated. More provinces are gonna develop more parts of Pakistan, will reduce population density, more people will likely to immgirate to different provinces depending on their particular needs, more people will intermix and inter marry.

This map is not what I would personally propose but I am just sharing it here for the only purpose of others understanding the basic picture of having more provinces.

Pakistan Zindabad.
View attachment 442756

Fantastic map

Just instead of Area being identified by Major city should name the areas based on something relevant

My twist

 

[Syed1.]

I think the idea of more provinces seems plausible on paper but it is far removed from the ground reality. In Pakistan corruption takes place at every step of the government. Imagine instead of 4 chief ministers you will have 15 chief ministers each doing their own share of corruption (which would collectively be alot larger than what 4 CMs would be stealing). Then factor in the bureaucracy of the 15 provinces filling their pockets as opposed to bureaucracy for just 4 provinces. There would be nothing left for the aam admi.

 

[AZADPAKISTAN2009]

The approach to create provinces divided across major city hubs is a fantastic vision with idea being , integration of all ethnic population into one Pakistani Unit Identity

Most of Japanese provinces are similarly named , such as province of flower etc in their own language etc

Example tiny Japan is broken down into "43 zones"
They use the term prefecture for Province it seems , and they have broken down their regions efficiently into zones which can all get

a) Funding
b) Administration
c) Division of development activities
d) Growth of areas equally across country so no over population in one zone

They did it because it is a system that works

 

[Valar.]

Just instead of Area being identified by Major city should name the areas based on something relevant

Yea, this is just a map I copied from internet. Personally, I would have given them some stylish historical names
And, personally I would want 5 coastal provinces instead of 3 in the map.

I think the idea of more provinces seems plausible on paper but it is far removed from the ground reality. In Pakistan corruption takes place at every step of the government. Imagine instead of 4 chief ministers you will have 15 chief ministers each doing their own share of corruption (which would collectively be alot larger than what 4 CMs would be stealing). Then factor in the bureaucracy of the 15 provinces filling their pockets as opposed to bureaucracy for just 4 provinces. There would be nothing left for the aam admi.

Hmm..you got a good point there.

 

[AZADPAKISTAN2009]

When country is divided into various Zones, more provinces, it will encourage the Political Parties also to develop more emphasis on having political presence across the country. And having more of a dynamic structure representing larger population of Pakistan

a) Better division of financial funding

b) More accountability as you can audit and figure out corruption easily in funding problem

c) Also better ability to collect taxes , as each zone can collect it's own taxes and easier to
target smaller zones for tax collection. Country can figure out which zone have better
taxation figures etc

d) When all regions have funding all regions get school / hospitals / markets / homes and
economy


Example in Map Above we have 16 Zones
An administrative Prime Minister or Administrator assigned by PM can review
performance of all 16 zones and give out a more meaningful figure yearly

a) Which area is giving most taxes?
b) Which area has higher population?
c) Which area is suffering from lack of funding
d) Which area has solved the electricity problem , water problem , traffic problem
e) If taxes are low in a "zone" at National Level , strategy can be figured out how to
improve tax collection? Encourage people to give tax

 

[WaLeEdK2]

He should focus on trying to provide people in Sindh with clean water. But I guess that's not an issue to them. And still people will vote for them. If you vote for these types and complain about lack of facilities then to hell with you. You deserve it all the misery and demoralisation they can offer. You'll be punished in this world and Allah will punish you ever so severely.

 

[AZADPAKISTAN2009]

I think Taxation collection can improve 100% if we have more zones in Pakistan

Also from Economic perspective today we have talk of
a) 4-5 Economic zones

But in future with 16 Provincial Zones, we might be talking of 16-18 Economic or Industrial Zones.

16 > 4

Similarly Metro Bus/ Train requirements for 16 Zones vs just 4 , which today means just 1-4 cities

 

[python-000]

poor kid, trying to save his father and its corruption from judiciary and trying to make fool the Pakistani people as Chef Justice said (u can make fool some one for some time but you can not make fool every one every time)

 

[pak-marine]

marson marson punjab na deson

 

[ziaulislam]

I think Taxation collection can improve 100% if we have more zones in Pakistan

Also from Economic perspective today we have talk of
a) 4-5 Economic zones

But in future with 16 Provincial Zones, we might be talking of 16-18 Economic or Industrial Zones.

16 > 4

Similarly Metro Bus/ Train requirements for 16 Zones vs just 4 , which today means just 1-4 cities

not matter how many zones you make not going to happen why
because of this

https://www.facebook.com/

you have lowest literacy rate in world and you think about economical growth, this is what i call bullshit
remember its a whole generation so no chance for another 30 years

unless of course you get more oil than saudis though that will end up in panama due to the way we vote

 

[AZADPAKISTAN2009]

Well 16 Zones / Provinces makes better sense

Imagine you have $100, every Zone will get $6.25 share each zone is getting fair share of budget. They can make a school or other service with fund.

Compared to that the present scenario is $100 , is distributed to 4 provinces and then there is uneven distribution of wealth and budget is concentrated across 3-4 cities, 60-70% of regions remain with out the provision of budget funds don't reach certain places

People really have difficult time to justify where the funds went

Certain folks just point fingers to different direction if asked about the money

Present scenario is large budget is aquired however the distribution mechanism is not proper that quite a few areas do not see the funding , if your man is in politics then he/she will make a road or few malls in your city

If 4-5 Billion dollar Metro will be constructed , obviously few regions will not get their share of budget for year

 

[jupiter2007]

Fantastic map

Just instead of Area being identified by Major city should name the areas based on something relevant

My twist
View attachment 442826

That's my map from 2003, which was rejected by many people but now it makes sense. Only thing I will change in the map is to make Khuzdar as the capital instead of Larkana.

I think Taxation collection can improve 100% if we have more zones in Pakistan

Also from Economic perspective today we have talk of
a) 4-5 Economic zones

But in future with 16 Provincial Zones, we might be talking of 16-18 Economic or Industrial Zones.

16 > 4

Similarly Metro Bus/ Train requirements for 16 Zones vs just 4 , which today means just 1-4 cities

I must say it's a very good ideas. But before anything can happened, we must defeat corruption and extremist cultures.