What's new

Bangladesh may get benefit from Indian cattle slaughter ban

bluesky

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Jun 14, 2016
Messages
16,515
Reaction score
-4
Country
Bangladesh
Location
Japan
30 May 2017, 19:25:37
Bangladesh may get benefit from Indian cattle slaughter ban


KOLKATA: Exporters see Bangladesh is benefiting from the ban on cattle slaughter in India.

The leather produced in India contains certain type of grains which leather from countries like South America and Africa do not have.

"Bangladesh's leather is more akin to that of leather manufactured in India," said Nafis of Zia Hide Skin Agency, who has a factory in Chennai.

Md Ibrar, director of Adiba Leather, is worried about the supply of raw hide, according to a report by economictimes.indiatimes.com.

"We supply bags to international brands such as Gerry Weber. We are also expecting calls from them," he said. "I am not sure what will happen next."

India's curbs on cattle slaughter are making international fashion houses worried.

Brands such as Zara, Marks & Spencer, Prada, Hugo Boss and Armani, or their agents, have started contacting suppliers in India, enquiring whether they would be able to meet their commitments on supplying footwear, handbags, jackets, belts and other products.

The suppliers, many of them running small scale units, fear the government move will cause a big hole in India's $13 billion-a-year leather industry, as a chunk of the business may shift to Bangladesh or they may have to spend more to import raw material. "An important agent from Spain, who sources finished leather for shoes for Zara, had called me last Friday enquiring whether I have enough stock for long-term commitment and how can I ensure supply in the backdrop of the recent government order," said Mohammad Zia Nafis, MD, Zia Hide Skin Agency.

"I have also received calls from Marks & Spencer for whom we supply finished leather for shoes," he said.

On Friday, the government banned sale of cattle for slaughter, a move it said was aimed at preventing cruelty towards animals, curbing illegal trade and smuggling of animals.

While it has stirred up a political storm, the decision caused uncertainties in the meat and leather export sectors, where India is one of the largest players.

In fiscal 2016, India had earned nearly $6 billion from leather exports, show government figures.

Ramesh Juneja, the eastern regional chairman of the Council of Leather Exports, said exporters in the region have been flooded with calls from Italian intermediaries in Solofra and Florence, who work for brands such as Prada and Gucci.

"They all want to know whether the supply will remain normal after the Centre's recent notification," Juneja said.

Prada, Armani and Hugo Boss directly source leather bags for men and women from Kolkata exporters, Juneja said. "I supply to Mango and we may too get a call shortly."

Juneja said if the supply side dries up, the industry may have to import leather.

Kolkata is a major leather industry hub, accounting for as much as 58 per cent of leather goods exported from the country. There are some 1,500 exporters in the Bengal capital alone. August to December is the critical time for the industry, as 45 per cent of the exports take place during these months.

The leather industry from Bengal has decided to approach chief minister Mamata Banerjee and state finance minister Amit Mitra to help them tide over the crisis.

"We will also take legal help if required," said Juneja.
 
. . . .
Timing is good. Shortly shifting of our leather factories to savar will be completed. Its time our leather sector makes a giant leap forward.

It wont. Supply of leather is assured in India...even with this move, given the restriction on cattle smuggling at the border with BD. BD simply does not have a local cattle population of any sizeable amount...and import costs of such also affect BD to begin with too.

3i2jnQf.jpg


This is effectively a demonetisation move on the industry (force the streams to be through legal channels only i.e certificate issued abbatoirs or natural death hides)....and transient issues/worries will blow over quite quickly just like demonetisation will if such goes through on the ground in the first place.
 
.
Bengalis Muslims & Hindus both eat beef. WB has always had a high meat consumption.

Good this trade may shift over to us, if so, we will do a better job.

I believe, you have made a wrong statement. Hindus in BD and WB do not eat beef traditionally, there may be some exceptions, though!! WB has 28% Muslim population. This is why beef consumption there is high.
 
.
It wont. Supply of leather is assured in India...even with this move, given the restriction on cattle smuggling at the border with BD. BD simply does not have a local cattle population of any sizeable amount...and import costs of such also affect BD to begin with too.

3i2jnQf.jpg


This is effectively a demonetisation move on the industry (force the streams to be through legal channels only i.e certificate issued abbatoirs or natural death hides)....and transient issues/worries will blow over quite quickly just like demonetisation will if such goes through on the ground in the first place.

You are correct, India is the biggest exporter of cow meat and south Indian Hindus specially the Tamilian and dalit will keep on eating beef. So there should not be any shortage of cow hide in India.
 
.
You are correct, India is the biggest exporter of cow meat and south Indian Hindus specially the Tamilian and dalit will keep on eating beef. So there should not be any shortage of cow hide in India.

Well the bovine meat exported from India is buffalo meat...cow and even bull meat is banned for export. Buffalo hides are not premium quality I believe for leather.

As for cattle hide, you are correct, there will be a transition period (to more formal routes) but the overall demand is steady in many areas and communities so there may be a small overall % increase in cost from formalising the logistics but I don't think it will undercut overall export competitive advantage. The states where leather industry is big employment will probably work out some compromise with the centre anyway, it is the reason why a number of their local high courts have stayed the decision for few months.

A few details on the announcement:

http://rightlog.in/2017/05/beef-ban-truth/

Nowhere in the notification does it say that slaughter houses are banned from buying cattle directly from farmers for the purpose of slaughter but clearly the illegal practice of slaughter houses buying from animal markets and also the practice of locating slaughter houses adjacent to or very near animal markets is being sought to be prevented or at least restricted and this is as it should be.
 
Last edited:
.
I believe, the Indian farmers will steadily decrease the raising of cows because of govt ban on their selling, slaughtering and eating. This will reduce the quantity of cow hides in India. Water buffalo hides are of lower quality than the cow hides.

I do not see, however, any big prospect of BD getting better export business due to this. In reality, salted BD cow hides are smuggled every year across the border to India after the two Eids, where they are well-tanned for export. BD can get benefits only if it can stop this smuggling and raise its quality of tanning and splitting.
 
Last edited:
.
Last year , Cattle hide prices were low in Pakistan .. may rebound this YEAR :D
 
.
Well the bovine meat exported from India is buffalo meat...cow and even bull meat is banned for export. Buffalo hides are not premium quality I believe for leather.

As for cattle hide, you are correct, there will be a transition period (to more formal routes) but the overall demand is steady in many areas and communities so there may be a small overall % increase in cost from formalising the logistics but I don't think it will undercut overall export competitive advantage. The states where leather industry is big employment will probably work out some compromise with the centre anyway, it is the reason why a number of their local high courts have stayed the decision for few months.

A few details on the announcement:

http://rightlog.in/2017/05/beef-ban-truth/

Nowhere in the notification does it say that slaughter houses are banned from buying cattle directly from farmers for the purpose of slaughter but clearly the illegal practice of slaughter houses buying from animal markets and also the practice of locating slaughter houses adjacent to or very near animal markets is being sought to be prevented or at least restricted and this is as it should be.
People are not stupid to buy buffalo instead of cow meat. India just used the name bovine meat to cover things up. Nobody buys bovine but beef.
 
.
People are not stupid to buy buffalo instead of cow meat. India just used the name bovine meat to cover things up. Nobody buys bovine but beef.

Bovine meat is what I used (to describe either cattle and buffalo meat). The beef exported by India is buffalo meat.

Exporting by ship to middle east etc follows much certification (there is further legislation regarding that it must not be complete or half carcass). Where cow and bull meat is produced in India, it is consumed internally....not exported.
 
.
India cattle trade ban to halt beef exports, lead to job losses
>> Reuters

Published: 2017-05-29 17:52:42.0 BdST Updated: 2017-05-29 17:52:42.0 BdST


  • India+cattle+trade_1.jpg

    FILE PHOTO - Butchers from the Qureshi community gather outside meat shops ordered to close, following regulations imposed by newly elected Uttar Pradesh State Chief Minister, Yogi Adityanath, in Lucknow, India, April 4, 2017. Reuters
India's ban on the trade of cattle for slaughter threatens $4 billion in annual beef exports and millions of jobs if the government does not revoke the stoppage decreed last week, according to two industry officials.

In the latest setback to the Muslim-dominated meat industry, Prime Minister Narendra Modi's government decreed animal markets will only be able to trade cattle for agricultural purposes such as plowing and dairy production.

The ban is likely to further alienate Muslims, who make up 14 percent of India's 1.3 billion people, and raise communal and religious tensions. Hindu hardliners and cow vigilante groups have been increasingly asserting themselves since Modi's Hindu nationalist government came to power in 2014.

Most of India's beef comes from water buffalo rather than cows, which are considered holy by Hindus, but local cattle traders and slaughterhouses have repeatedly come under attacks from activist groups that oppose the meat trade.

"In the garb of the order that prohibits the trading of cattle at organised markets, the government has tried to impose a ban on the meat industry," Abdul Faheem Qureshi, head of the Muslim All India Jamiatul Quresh Action Committee, told Reuters.

"Meat supplies will very soon grind to a halt in India and abroad if either the government does not repeal this draconian order or a court does not step in," Qureshi said.

Government officials were not available for comment.

Indian meat traders, under the aegis of the Quresh Action Committee and other trade and industry associations, plan to petition India's Supreme Court in the next couple of days to get the government order rescinded.

"Exports will come to a halt because slaughterhouses will find it extremely difficult to buy cattle and we also apprehend widespread job losses in the sector, which supports millions of people," said Qureshi.

Abattoirs across India on March 31 called off a strike after four days when the most populous state of Uttar Pradesh, ruled by Modi's party, gave assurances that it would renew the licenses of slaughterhouses and protect them against the attacks from cow vigilante groups.

The slaughter industry stabilised after the strike but the latest order has unsettled trade again, said Priya Sud, partner at Al Noor Exports, which operates abbatoirs in Uttar Pradesh.

The impact on exports will be more evident after a couple of months when the supply chain dries up, Sud said.

India exported 1.33 million tonnes of buffalo meat in the 2016/17 fiscal year to March 31, worth about $3.9 billion. The exports were slightly up from the 1.31 million tonnes exported in the previous year.
 
.
Bovine meat is what I used (to describe either cattle and buffalo meat). The beef exported by India is buffalo meat.

Exporting by ship to middle east etc follows much certification (there is further legislation regarding that it must not be complete or half carcass). Where cow and bull meat is produced in India, it is consumed internally....not exported.
I told you except indian nobody eats buffalo.
 
.
I told you except indian nobody eats buffalo.

Well what we are exporting is buffalo meat. If you personally think people in middle east (biggest market for it) want to believe its cattle, thats fine.

India exported 1.33 million tonnes of buffalo meat in the 2016/17 fiscal year to March 31, worth about $3.9 billion.

From bluesky posted article just above yours.
 
.

Country Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom