Bangladesh:Gunfight at BDR headquarters

[eastwatch]

Considering the fact that Bangladesh borders West bengal..which is not far from Bihar and UP..So, i guess enough Army can be mobilized in 12-15 hours at max..

Ask your army strategists, it will take over 60 days. So, take your time and come to BD land. There will be an welcome ceremony for your coward army. Last time in 1971, you escaped with only 1300 deaths, because we gave our lives in many lakhs, instead. But, this time you should be ready to give 13 million lives. So, who stops you from coming? Just jump.

 

[monitor]

guys do anyone has access to bdmilitary forum here ? if any one has then it may help us to get important information regarding bdr mutiny .

 

[monitor]

Considering the fact that Bangladesh borders West bengal..which is not far from Bihar and UP..So, i guess enough Army can be mobilized in 12-15 hours at max..

with that i think you should carry enough body bag with your army too.

 

[monitor]

dear member can any one post the related page number where the intruding of other countries commandos into the bdr headquarter discussed ?
how many of you really think that in a country's capital someone from other country come and go without unnoticed after doing such crime ?

 

[eastwatch]

I do not think, anybody in BD thinks seriously any foreign direct involvement in the BDR mutiny. BDR Jawans had and has many grievances. Pay raise and better education facilities for their kids are two of these demands. Their representatives approached both the political Parties before the last general election. So, both the parties knew about their grievances. At least one of these parties might have taken advantage of the situation in order to destabilize the country.

A few AL leaders may have the aim to destroy both BDR and army by indirectly arranging a civil war. The reasons could be multifaceted. One may be that the AL leadership do not trust army, who killed Sk. Mujib and almost all his family members. A civil war would have destroyed the backbone of the military.

BNP could also be responsible for the killing. It could be a revenge on losing the election, and also that Tareque Zia and his family were humiliated by the army. So, both the parties had enough reasons to instigate a revolt in Pilkhana.

There is no difference in opinion that the Jawans were not aware that there would be a killing of the Officers. But, when the BDR Chief and his Officers were forced marched through the main door of the Darbar Hall at gun point, a group of BDR troops were waiting outside across the road and behind a pick-up truck who first opened fire.

This had a chain reaction. Jawans thought that the order was to kill. So, many took part in the killing and looting. I believe, the planners behind the scene were expecting the army to interfere, because it would have initiated a set of reactions across the entire country. 67,000 BDR troops were ready to fight against the army had there been an army attack on Pilkhana. The organizers were in contact with most of the BDR border outposts, and the Jawans there forced their Officers to vacate their posts. NCOs took over the commands. It was a total anarchy.

So, I think, the decision by the army not to attack Pilkahana saved the country from falling into the traps set by the Pilkhana organizers and their foreign patrons, if any. Pilkhana attack by the army would have surely started a civil war.

 

[monitor]

yes no body will believe that just only for better payment or allegation of corruption in 'dal bhat operation' could trigger such a mutiny .the player behind the scene must planed it earlier what would they do if any civil war like situation created in bangladesh . indian airforce were ready for coming bangladesh to help government which indicate who might be the mastermind behind all this .

 

[LaBong]

yes no body will believe that just only for better payment or allegation of corruption in 'dal bhat operation' could trigger such a mutiny .the player behind the scene must planed it earlier what would they do if any civil war like situation created in bangladesh . indian airforce were ready for coming bangladesh to help government which indicate who might be the mastermind behind all this .

Please enlighten us logic-devoid mind-numbing people as to who might be the mastermind behind all this? You know, we're not really good at conspiracies, so you will have to take the extra trouble of specifically point to the evil mastermind who's behind the mutiny!

 

[Bhairava]

Ask your army strategists, it will take over 60 days. So, take your time and come to BD land. There will be an welcome ceremony for your coward army. Last time in 1971, you escaped with only 1300 deaths, because we gave our lives in many lakhs, instead. But, this time you should be ready to give 13 million lives. So, who stops you from coming? Just jump.

Are you a strategist in the Indian Army ?? If not please save us your "strategies".

And secondly whats there worthwhile in your already sinking country to invade and occupy it.? Dont flatter yourself.

 

[darkhand08]

Especially for eastwatch

We Indians have such a coward army which accidently happens to be the 2nd largest army in the world....but given your vast expertise with Indian Strategists you are so true....60 days even with the fact that some of the biggest divisions of the Indian Army stand around 500 miles from Bangladesh Border..........you seem to be knowing Indian Strategists more than we do....inside contact huh..

 

[LaBong]

60 days is a stupid remark without taking into consideration that headquarter of eastern division of IA is in Fort William, Calcutta.

Anyway, getting into conflict with BD is not of India's interest.

 

[fallstuff]

Dreaming is good but day dreaming is very dangerous.

I don't think India will need to fight BD, but if there is a situation when some anti-India elements like BNP-Jamat extemists come to power and force India for a fight. Than it will take 24 hours to take over BD and we might be signing in another surrender paper in Dhaka. It is BD's luck that they are surrounded by India and no one will dare to attack them. One small portion of border you have with Myanmar but still so many problems!!

Bangladesh is no more east Pakistan we know, but BD is weaker than EP because Rajakars and Al Badrs are still very much active.

Also read the history first India-China war in 62 was not a full scale war no air fore or navy was involved. Don't try to take other's pride to hide your weakness. Ohhh sorry you don't have anything to pride.

Thanks God, most of the people in BD don't think like you, otherwise this shouldn't be good for them.

This is such a childish post. There are other players in the theater.

As far as being proud about, your post speaks volume about the state of your faculty.

 

[eastwatch]

yes no body will believe that just only for better payment or allegation of corruption in 'dal bhat operation' could trigger such a mutiny .the player behind the scene must planed it earlier what would they do if any civil war like situation created in bangladesh . indian airforce were ready for coming bangladesh to help government which indicate who might be the mastermind behind all this .

If you are right in saying that a revolt cannot be organized because of some petty grievances, therefore, many people believe in a conspiracy instigated by a foreign agency. So, who could be that agency for Pilkhan?

Any revolt may start with only tiny reasons, then it spreads like a fire in a jungle. It starts with a few killings, but then everyone starts firing at others because someone of his kins has been killed. It then spreads further.

Only Pilkhan organizers know which foreign agency was behind them. BDR Jawans were certainly not told about any conspiracy. They understood it was because of their grievances, so they spontaneously participated.

 

[Hulk]

If you are right in saying that a revolt cannot be organized because of some petty grievances, therefore, many people believe in a conspiracy instigated by a foreign agency. So, who could be that agency for Pilkhan?

Any revolt may start with only tiny reasons, then it spreads like a fire in a jungle. It starts with a few killings, but then everyone starts firing at others because someone of his kins has been killed. It then spreads further.

Only Pilkhan organizers know which foreign agency was behind them. BDR Jawans were certainly not told about any conspiracy. They understood it was because of their grievances, so they spontaneously participated.

Then reached home and told you the story.

 

[Skies]

I heard that one of jawan fired at DGF at first. Then everything begun. Don't you think that the first fire was planed, otherwise how would someone had got the gut to shoot at DGF at the crowded meeting since anyone simply knows that if someone shoots there then he also has to die just like a suicide attack? It can not be happen just for grievances. I think it was planed and the issue was Jawans' grievances. And I think lot of evidence are hidden/unexposed, may we will know many thing after several years.

 

[fallstuff]

Then reached home and told you the story.

Stop the trolling. If you got nothing of value to add , hold your peace.