Bilal9
ELITE MEMBER
- Joined
- Feb 4, 2014
- Messages
- 26,569
- Reaction score
- 9
- Country
- Location
Firstly, lets look at the time frame of the F-7BG and F-7BGI purchases. The BGs were delivered in 2006 and the BGI in 2013 approximately. At that time, the JF-17 was just enterting block 2 phase production. I would characterize the block 1 as an incomplete product. Additionally, your right, the price difference is tremendous and at that point in time I can see the wisdom of getting the F-7s, not to mention familiarity with the platform, ease of integration along the lines of training and maintainence. So I'm not making the arguement that BAF should have bought the JF-17 instead of the F-7 IN THAT TIME FRAME.
However, in comparing the 2 platforms in 2018 and also generally speaking, I would absolutely want the JF-17 block 2 and above over the F-7BGI.
Firstly, the proof is in the pudding, where the PAF will eventually have the platform as their main type to replace their F-7P and eventually non ROSE Mirage. That alone gives me confidence in the type. You can say that they dont really have an option otherwise politically, but do remember the JF-17 underwent a reconfiguration at some point during its development to better handle emerging Indian threats such as the Flanker. Its said the JF-17 received alot of input from the Russians and may acutally be based on their original MIG-33.
You mentioned top speed. So what? It takes alot of fuel and these types rarely if ever operationally approach their top speeds. Another member mentioned that the only difference is the JF-17's ability to fire more weapons from the Chinese inventory. Yea, I would say that important. Bangladesh better have a counter for the SD-10s that will soon be in Myanmar Air Force inventory. Active radar homing BVR is a game changer. Not to mention the PL-10 and other goodies that the Chinese are working on and fielded already.
Not to mention the block 3 which they are working on with AESA, new engine, HMS and probably newer weapon system capabilities.
So yea I would take a JF-17 over an F-7 any day of the week.
Bhai even if JF-17 is a great platform technically, the chances of getting it from Pakistan (and far more importantly, the AL govt. approving that purchase) is close to nil.
Theoretically - great platform and maybe quite cost effective as well. But does it compare with first world or Russian options technically, or has any chance of getting inducted? I have my doubts.