What's new

'Bangla' is also ours

Status
Not open for further replies.
Too little , too late.

Whatever the reasons, the fact remains that the name 'Bangla' or 'Bengal or Bangaala', really belongs to us. This is the traditional name of our motherland and will eternally remain so. Though our country's name officially is 'Bangladesh', historically, geographically, culturally and linguistically, we are 'Bangla' or Bengal.

What was stopping BD from using this name for the last 45 years ?



Moreover, the specific use of Bangla or 'Bengal' as the name of Paschim Banga will give rise to unnecessary problems, including legal, both in the national and international arena. Henceforth, Paschim Banga may brand some of their specific products and processes as products of Bengal and ask for registration as exclusive patents, trademarks or copyrights from the relevant agencies of WIPO or WTO or any other authority. Because of Paschim Banga's claim of the name Bangla or Bengal, any such move on our part is not likely to succeed.

Here lies the problem the author has, however this has already happened with regards to Mangoes, sarees etc. So whats new ?

We find it offensive when some Indians claim to be Bengalis!

Thats most unfortunate. Wonder why you find it offensive . Those living in Punjab on both sides dont have a problem when called Punjabis so whats different ?
 
.
1) Rather than Bengal or Bangla, "Bangalah" is the correct word. The non-political names of different parts of 'Bangalah' in the historical times are Bongo, Shomotot, Rarh, Barendra, Bakla, Bhati and some others. But, no name could be fixed to an area because of the lack of demarcation. Many of these localized names may have been given by the local Puthi-Shahityo poets or folk singers, and the locals gradually accepted the names.

2) Many of the Kingdoms in the historical times were named after their Capitals. Such as Delhi Sultanate, Gazhni Sultanate etc. The region between Indian NE and Uttar Pradesh was the Kingdom of Laksmanaboti (Lakkhanabati). Biswarup Sen vacated this Capital when Laksman Sen was defeated at the hands of Ikhtieruddin Khilji. The immigrant Turkic/Afghan Muslims started to mis-pronounce it Lukhnouti, instead. Hence, it became the country's name.

3) At a certain point of history, the overzealous newly arrived Muslims changed the name of the Capital to "GHORE." Why Ghore? It was because Ghore is the name of their original country in Afghanistan, and this is why its Sultan was called also Muhammed Ghori. Now, the name Ghore in Bengal could not be properly pronounced by the local Hindus. They started to mis-pronunce it as Gour. Since then it was Gour.

4) It continued until the Delhi Mughals fully captured this land in 1605. They named it "Sube Bangalah." This is the first time that the entire region between Indian NE and U.P started to be called Bangalah. After 1947, it was East Pakistan, but its people loved to call it Purbo Bangla. It was changed again by our warriors in 1971.

5) So, only this part of Bangla has the right to name it according to the old name. Pashim Bongo name should remain as it is, or it can unite with Bihar to be called Bihar. That Kolkatta-centric people have little right to claim their tiny Province to be named Bangla. How can it be when they chose to break away from the mainland Bengal in 1947?
 
Last edited:
.
Looks like the westies having identity problem. Why don't y'all join Bangladesh?
 
.
Too little , too late.
What was stopping BD from using this name for the last 45 years ?

Bangladesh is the nation of Bengalis, The region is Banga and the culture is Bengali.


Enjoy The Tagore Song " Aji Bangladesher Hridoy Hotey "


And this one by Sukanta " Himalay theke Sundarban, hotat Bangladesh"

 
.
It's as absurd as someone from Dublin telling someone from Derry - "Don't call yourself Irish because politically you are part of Britain".
 
.
I like that suggestion. "Banga" too.

What about "Bongo", though? Since Bangladesh already has "Bangla" in its name?
bongo is good so is bangla... i dont see how people will get confused between bangladesh and bangla... there are tonnes of cities all over the world named by colonialists with similar names... nobody gets confused.
bangladeshis are making mountain over a mole hill... as if we are stealing their identity....

i am ok with continuing the name west bengal.. as its the cheapest... and there is no need to change... but the state representative think its better... i would have voted for bengali mcbongface... :)
 
.
Then what do you call people from East Bengal ? Ethnically and linguistically majority of Bangladeshi's and those in East Bengal are the same, Irrespective of the religious differences

Sorry i meant West Bengal
 
.
Sorry i meant West Bengal

Few days ago I tried to find the list of Bengali singers from both India and Bangladesh, I thought of 40:60 split but amazingly its almost 10:90 split based on my internet name search. They are becoming irrelevant as days pass by.
 
.
Few days ago I tried to find the list of Bengali singers from both India and Bangladesh, I thought of 40:60 split but amazingly its almost 10:90 split based on my internet name search. They are becoming irrelevant as days pass by.

As in the language spoken ? That's surprising

@Rain Man is Bengali being used less in West Bengal these days
 
.
Lot of confusion on names now.

Time to annex BDesh, merge with W.B and name it Bangla Pradesh or if they like to call it Bangla Prodesh.

We can bargain and offer Mustafizur Rehman a place in Indian cricket team.
 
.

12:00 AM, September 19, 2016 / LAST MODIFIED: 12:08 AM, September 19, 2016
'Bangla' is also ours
west_bengal_as_bangla_1.jpg


Enam Ahmed Choudhury

Recently, the West Bengal Legislative Assembly passed a resolution renaming the Indian state of West Bengal as 'Bangla' in Bengali, 'Bengal' in English and 'Bangaala' in Hindi/Urdu. As one of the reasons for this momentous change, the Chief Minister of 'Paschim Banga' (the state's current name) mentioned that with the alphabet 'B' in the beginning of the name 'Bengal', the state will get alphabetical priority in Delhi.

Whatever the reasons, the fact remains that the name 'Bangla' or 'Bengal or Bangaala', really belongs to us. This is the traditional name of our motherland and will eternally remain so. Though our country's name officially is 'Bangladesh', historically, geographically, culturally and linguistically, we are 'Bangla' or Bengal. Mainly, we own the glory and achievements of Bengal or Bangla. From time immemorial, the present day Bangladesh was part of 'Bangla', a name derived from 'Banga'. During the Mughal rule, it was part of Subeh-Bangla. During the British rule, Calcutta was initially made the capital of India (till 1911) and also the provincial capital, and the province of British Bengal (called Bengal Presidency) included the territories that now comprise both Bangladesh and Paschim Bangla (West Bengal)

The area and the population of Bangladesh are much higher than that of West Bengal. Through history's bloodiest but most glorious Liberation War, we won 'Banglar Swadhinata' - the independence of Bangla. This Bangla is Bangladesh, our sovereign independent country. The slogan of our Liberation War was Joy Bangla. Our national anthem begins with an emphatic proclamation of our love for Shonar Bangla - the Bengal of gold. This is not just the national anthem, but the central source of our inspiration. Our national academy is called Bangla Academy. The Bengal Foundation set up by Abul Khair, and many other institutions named likewise are dedicated to the propagation of the arts and music of Bengal. We are 'Bangalee' as we live in Bengal. Our state language is Bangla. In remembrance and in recognition of our great state language movement, February 21 has been accepted universally as the World Mother Language Day. Introduced by Mughal Emperor Akbar, we observe the first day of Baishakh as our national New Year's Day. Our music is Banglar gaan, our seasons are seasons of Bengal, our animals are the Bengal goat and the Bengal tiger, our culture is Bangla, our products are Bangla products, our rivers are rivers of Bengal, our cuisine is Bangla. One of our great national leaders A. K. Fazlul Huq is called 'Sher-e-Bangla' - the tiger of Bengal. The Parliament area in Dhaka is known as 'Sher-e-Bangla' Nagar. In our vision, the picture that eternally flashes as our motherland is the face of Bangla - Banglar mukh. We appreciate Bangalees living in different parts of the world, including India, sharing our glory and pride. Indeed, there are many commonalities. But this does not mean that anyone can hijack the name Bengal or Bangla from us for exclusive use. That is our name, our existence, our identity.

Moreover, the specific use of Bangla or 'Bengal' as the name of Paschim Banga will give rise to unnecessary problems, including legal, both in the national and international arena. Henceforth, Paschim Banga may brand some of their specific products and processes as products of Bengal and ask for registration as exclusive patents, trademarks or copyrights from the relevant agencies of WIPO or WTO or any other authority. Because of Paschim Banga's claim of the name Bangla or Bengal, any such move on our part is not likely to succeed. At the very least, this could create great confusion, detrimental to our interests.

The issue, which is a very serious one, should be taken up both officially and unofficially, for a mutually acceptable solution. The central government of India, I believe, is yet to give its final approval. Since this involves the interests of Bangladesh, we would expect the government of India to give neighbourly considerations and consult our government in this regard. Public opinion, conveying our anxiety, may also be voiced. Issues of this nature have been settled amicably or otherwise solved in the case of Korea, and previously Vietnam and Germany, and even in Punjab shared by India and Pakistan. Thousands of ventures, initiatives, societies and enterprises of Bangladeshi entrepreneurs all over the world are named or known as 'Bangla' endeavours. On a safari trip in a remote South African Game Reserve, traveller Shimu Nasser (as reported with a photograph on the September 9 issue of Prothom Alo) found a big grocery store called 'Bangla Superstore' located near the entry point, owned by two young men from Feni. In an unfrequented small beach town in Scotland, I recently ran across a restaurant owned by a gentleman from Sylhet named 'Taste of Bengal'. There are countless such instances. Most of our restaurants abroad (and these are aplenty) serve, what they call, Bangla cuisine, (albeit, partly Mughal) and Bangla sweets. The recent victories of young girl footballers from Bangladesh were hailed as triumphs of Bengal tigresses. All these, of course, should and would continue. But renaming West Bengal exclusively as Bangla or Bengal will definitely create great confusion and should be avoided by all means.

The best solution, of course, is continuation of the present practice of officially calling the country (independent) and the territory (in India) as Bangladesh and Paschim Banga, respectively. Alternatively, without trying to lay exclusive claim on the name Bangla or Bengal, Paschim Bangla may like to be called Indian Bengal or Bharatiyo Bangla or simply 'Banga'. During the debate in the West Bengal Assembly, many members of the Congress, CPI and even BJP expressed their preference for the name 'Banga'. Even Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee on record stated that she did not dislike the name 'Banga', but it was not so much in use anymore. However, if 'Banga' is accepted as an official name, it would obviously be used. Another alternative for consideration could be the name Bangla Pradesh (BP), like UP (Uttar Pradesh), Maddhya Pradesh (MP), Himachal Pradesh (HM) and Northwest Frontier Province (NWFP).

In any case, there should be an amicable settlement of the issue. The decision should not be taken arbitrarily and unilaterally. In the meantime, we should vigorously keep on using 'Bangla' or 'Bengal' as the commonly used name of our motherland. Otherwise, in the process of history, we will eventually move far away from our traditional name and identity, and thereby lose our source of glory and pride

Indians are copycats.

Haven't you seen how they shamelessly copy Pakistani songs and sell as their own?

Or lay claim to Mohenjo Daro and Harrapa?

And most recently they have started to call their soldiers "Shaheed" and got "Shahadat" - words previously no where to be found in "Parmanu Kabootur" Hindi.

I think it is more to do with inferiority complex.
 
.
STILL DREAMING OF AKHAND BHARAT. SLEEP TIGHT AND ENJOY YOUR DREAMS. EVER HEARD OF BANGLADESHI BAMBOO? DONT EVER FORGET WE ARE MUSLIMS,DONT WAKE UP UP A SLEEPING A ROYAL TIGER TO END IN THE TIGERS STOMACH,
\
 
.
Do Bangladeshi's find other calling them Bengali offensive ? Or is that term solely in recognition for those in India ?
Bangla represents Bangladeshis mainly. But west Bengal is also Bengali ethnic people. We divided Bangla under british rule cause Culcutta was a puppet state and East India company was dragging wealth from Dhaka via Culcutta to Britain. If any nation to represent Bangla, that must be Us the Bangladeshis.

It's kind of the same when you say Persian lions-"Indian Lion".
 
.
Bangla represents Bangladeshis mainly. But west Bengal is also Bengali ethnic people. We divided Bangla under british rule cause Culcutta was a puppet state and East India company was dragging wealth from Dhaka via Culcutta to Britain. If any nation to represent Bangla, that must be Us the Bangladeshis.

It's kind of the same when you say Persian lions-"Indian Lion".

Yep i'm aware of the history of the region mate.. Was just wondering if Bangladeshi's find it offensive to be called Bengali's and why, Is it because you want to be defined by nationality ?
 
.
Lot of confusion on names now.

Time to annex BDesh, merge with W.B and name it Bangla Pradesh or if they like to call it Bangla Prodesh.

We can bargain and offer Mustafizur Rehman a place in Indian cricket team.

Aren't you guys facing enough problems in Kashmir already?

Or you are interested in creating more conflicts and ultimately end up dividing India into small parts hostile to each other?
 
.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom