What's new

Ban Pakistan People's Party if you want to save Karachi turning into ruin

This just further reinforces my view of drastic actions, to save a patient in ICU.
Nothing will happen until Karachi remains under PPP provincial government.

No one can match ppp when it comes to stealing, and then no one comes close to them when people of interior sindh bring them to power despite all of this.
 
. .
Karachi is in ICU and needs drastic measures. As a foreigner, who has actually owned property in Karachi, spent summers there, and has seen its steady decline post '88. This is my conclusion:

1) Just like Martial Law was imposed in Lahore from February 1953 – May 1953. The same needs to be done.
2) All political parties who have looted the city, should be tried, locked up and banned.
3) It should be made into a Federal territory, and NOT a separate province.
4) Law & Order, i.e. Police and Courts need to be overhauled ASAP.
5) Until the civil apparatus becomes reliable, Military Courts should be established
6) Sindh Provincial Assembly should be dissolved, and every MPA should be investigated.
7) Waste to Electricity plants set up - With a daily production of 11k~12k tonnes of garbage, it is very feasible.
8) Invite investors to overhaul the public trnspt system on BOO basis. This would include electric buses, overhead trams and trains.

@The Eagle @Arsalan @TOPGUN @Dazzler @PakSword @Mangus Ortus Novem @Shane @waz @Zaki Your input please.



My friend, more than 50 people died. Including children.

This is something I dont understand, when monsoon rains were expected, why didn't the Govt shut down schools? Why did they have to wait for the last minute? Even then some where open, there was no proper coordination.
Extremely good options in this thread and your post to get the ball rolling.

There needs to be a methodical extermination of both PPP and MQM.

Making Karachi a federally administered area again is a top notch idea as Karachi was truly and appropriately developing metropolitan city until it was the capital of Pakistan. This would sideline PPP from interference in getting Karachi back on its feet without dissolving Sind assembly.

PPP and MQM should be overtly and legally banned for criminal negligence alone.

The federal takeover should be time limited to 1 year to keep the sentiments of other parts of sind in check and PPP along with Nationalists would not be able to incite people of sind that the federation has stolen Karachi and divided Sind. (The takeover can get biannual extensions until Karachi is fixed)

One by one, all municipal and services departments should be realigned, restructured and merged where necessary to end tug of war/ shifting responsibilities/ overlapping authorities/ wastage of funds /ghost employees etc.

@PakSword has highlighted a major cause of electrocution during rains. People responsible should be simply investigated, charged and hanged.

I would suggest the same to be done in other districts of Pakistan one by one, once this practice proves its effectiveness on the ground.
 
.
Normal people do not think a city which have tons of garbage on the street to be OK. Only uncivilized people think that way. I don't even want to know how your living condition is if you think EVERYTHING in Karachi is ok but you cannot accuse anyone for being anyone's thug for complaining about a city's condition, especially a sc*m like Altaf. @waz @The Eagle mods, tagging you guys here just because I feel its a bit offensive for this person to call the OP what he did
It was sarcasm. When somebody complains here about Karachi, people call him Altafs thug. And of course Karachi is almost destroyed, I am also from Karachi.
@MM_Haider and my jazbati brother @waz
 
.
The federal takeover should be time limited to 1 year to keep the sentiments of other parts of sind in check and PPP along with Nationalists would not be able to incite people of sind that the federation has stolen Karachi and divided Sind. (The takeover can get biannual extensions until Karachi is fixed)

This is the biggest hiccup but having it set as federal territory for a promised time limit might work.
 
.
Extremely good options in this thread and your post to get the ball rolling.

There needs to be a methodical extermination of both PPP and MQM.

Making Karachi a federally administered area again is a top notch idea as Karachi was truly and appropriately developing metropolitan city until it was the capital of Pakistan. This would sideline PPP from interference in getting Karachi back on its feet without dissolving Sind assembly.

PPP and MQM should be overtly and legally banned for criminal negligence alone.

The federal takeover should be time limited to 1 year to keep the sentiments of other parts of sind in check and PPP along with Nationalists would not be able to incite people of sind that the federation has stolen Karachi and divided Sind. (The takeover can get biannual extensions until Karachi is fixed)

One by one, all municipal and services departments should be realigned, restructured and merged where necessary to end tug of war/ shifting responsibilities/ overlapping authorities/ wastage of funds /ghost employees etc.

@PakSword has highlighted a major cause of electrocution during rains. People responsible should be simply investigated, charged and hanged.

I would suggest the same to be done in other districts of Pakistan one by one, once this practice proves its effectiveness on the ground.
and what nakes you think federal would work to fix karachi and not lot like ppp mqm and cantt guys?

in this gorak dhanda of looting karachi ppp mqm jammat e islami fauji are one partners in crime and now karachi bas become unfixable and beyond repair and the best part is no one will pay for thia criminal negligence!!

flies and mosquitoes rule the skies and there is a chance of major outbreak where not just karachi but Pakistanis will die and you know what no one gives a shit because sab harami mil key loot rahay hain!! politicians abd fauji sab!!
 
.
Extremely good options in this thread and your post to get the ball rolling.

There needs to be a methodical extermination of both PPP and MQM.

Making Karachi a federally administered area again is a top notch idea as Karachi was truly and appropriately developing metropolitan city until it was the capital of Pakistan. This would sideline PPP from interference in getting Karachi back on its feet without dissolving Sind assembly.

PPP and MQM should be overtly and legally banned for criminal negligence alone.

The federal takeover should be time limited to 1 year to keep the sentiments of other parts of sind in check and PPP along with Nationalists would not be able to incite people of sind that the federation has stolen Karachi and divided Sind. (The takeover can get biannual extensions until Karachi is fixed)

One by one, all municipal and services departments should be realigned, restructured and merged where necessary to end tug of war/ shifting responsibilities/ overlapping authorities/ wastage of funds /ghost employees etc.

@PakSword has highlighted a major cause of electrocution during rains. People responsible should be simply investigated, charged and hanged.

I would suggest the same to be done in other districts of Pakistan one by one, once this practice proves its effectiveness on the ground.
Karachi was a Federal city to begin with.
 
.
Nothing will happen until Karachi remains under PPP provincial government.

No one can match ppp when it comes to stealing, and then no one comes close to them when people of interior sindh bring them to power despite all of this.

best part is IK the mou ka fire leader sirf batain chod raha hai and karachi ia suffering everyday!! i feel sick that i voted for that bastard that coward!!
 
.
A few days back I visited Karachi (after 2007) and literally cried to see the situation there. Karachi has been made dilapidated in last decade by PPP. Although the situation in Karachi was not that good in 2007 but now it is all ruins.
  1. Bin Qasim park which was lush green back then has been turned into barren land and being encroached by land mafia
  2. Boat Basin which was supposed to be a good place for eating out is now filthy and garbage is all around with scores of flies. You just cannot eat there (even inside shops) because of smell and flies
  3. Lots of SUVs are seen on road but not following any rules. They overtake, jump signal, violate one way and hut an run.
  4. Street crimes have been sky rocketed and all my relatives and friends are now keeping their expensive phones at home and I was told to just give whatever street criminals want. Don't argue.
  5. Garbage - yes garbage is like everywhere. As soon as you leave airport and come on Shahrah e Faisal, you can see heaps of garbage all along from airport till Numaish Chowrangi and from Numaish till Defence.
  6. You see rangers at every nook and corner - napping, grabbing, arguing, drinking tea and hitting the mango masses.
  7. Traffic police is seems no where except some areas of Sadar etc
  8. Residential towers (along Shahrah e Faisal) seem like they have faced some kind of World War. (Imagine photos of Germany after World War II). In other countries such residential building are demolished which pose threat to the community. But people are living there without any fear and state, building control authority is sleeping.
  9. in 2007 there were so many cabs on roads to travel around. Now you see abundance of Rickshaws. Public transport was not there back then, same is the situation now.
  10. Beggars have been increased.
  11. Sindhi Vaderas are seen in abundance in their double cabin, land Cruisers with gunmen abusing and insulting the public who are late in giving way to them for like couple of seconds. If you go to airport, CAA has put a notice that gunmen/ priovate security is not allowed from such and such point.
  12. Sewerage system has been chocked completely and stagnant water you can see even from plane. This starts from Sukkur till Karachi. (traveled at day time).
  13. There is an anger in Urdu Speaking community although they abuse Altaf Hussain in public now but they are against everyone else.
  14. Police was corrupt back then now it is same perception rather that perception has increased many folds.
  15. Back in 2007, Clifton beach was relatively clean. It is more crowded and dirty now.
My question is in last decade every city in the world has been improved from past state. Don't go abroad just look at Lahore and Peshawar. Peshawar was war torn but its state has been improved. Lahore's whole outlook is changed and this is city is more cleaner than most of the South Asian metropolitans, why is ONLY Karachi which is ruined instead of getting improved from infrastructure, law and order and cleanliness perspective? It looks like their no ruler or government there. No rule of law is there and it is free for all. Everyone is wishing to go abroad and if not abroad their goal is to shit to Bahria town.

Can you make a wild guess who is responsible for Karachi's this kind of situation? Yes you guessed it right. It is ONLY THAT PARTY WHICH HAS BEEN RULING KARACHI FOR LAST DECADE AND A HALF NOW STRAIGHT - Pakistan People's Party.

This party should not be banned because Bilawal is giving irresponsible statements on Kashmir to save his corrupt Abbu, it because the more this party will rule Karachi, karachi will be more destryed with every passing day!!!

#BanPPPSaveKarachi.. :(



Lekin Bhutto to abhi zinda hai yaar...
Usney to har ghar se nikalna hai...
kis kis ghar ko ban karoge?

My question is only a simple one.
Are the people of Karachi dead, coward, lazy, or braindead?

Why don't they come on the streets and grab their rights?

What other city in the world will allow thugs to destroy their city and the awam keeps sleeping?
The awam who can come out in millions under threat from Altaf mafia, can't come out for their own rights?

If they are sleeping, then they are happy with the condition they live in, and actually deserve it...
 
.
Karachi was a Federal city to begin with.
There shouldn't be any provinces in Pakistan these provinces are like states within a state or countries within a country
There should be one district level local government and a federal government
 
.
What masses can do? Why don't they protest against PPP... MQM is right that karachi should be made separate province. It is not possible for PPP to run Karachi. they destruyed country when they were in power and now they are in Karachi

You know what is even worse? It is the fact that most of the PPP leadership, including Zardari and family, live in Karachi and yet they do not want to clean the city or manage traffic, roads, infrastructure etc.
 
. .
Democracy is the best Revenge.

About as bad as military dictatorship. Both systems have failed us miserably.

Mil dictator installed MQM there; Mush further nurtured them --- then the same Army spent a lot of blood and treasure destroying them after the entire city was held hostage by this criminal mafia for decades!

And PPP --- just as bad.

It's bad all around.
 
.
and what makes you think federal would work to fix karachi and not lot like ppp mqm and cantt guys?
Despair is natural, so is hope. There is always a methodical way of dealing with Caos.

One has to be optimistic and realistic at the same time to get the job done.

I'm hopeful because federal authorities would have to first repair the municipal and services departments and then just keep oversight. The performance can also be monitored by the Supreme Court.
 
.
Every job going person is suffering from mental distress here in Karachi due to traffic, pollution, noise, crime, lack of healthcare..
I am sure some African countries will have better facilities than in Karachi.

Its been decades, Karachi is ignored and treated as an orphan child. Shhhh dont wake up the sahib e iqtadaar :))

-
Just recently 42 people died due to electrocution and rain related deaths.

I guess the authorities wil wake up jab loog gharon se nikaal ke inhay maraingay
Tou log nikal kiyun nai rahay? It na sabar kub say agiyea is koum mein?

Is this patience only for the corrupt?
 
.

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom