Attack on Malala was staged, claims PTI MNA

[niaz]

It has really surprised me that everybody from moderators to think tanks came out to support a girl whose father has clearly been linked with foreign agencies(read CIA).This girl supposedly got shot in the head and surprisingly enough lived to tell the tale,let me tell you something my friend got shot in the head and he died 12 hrs after that.
Bottom line is it was just a hogwash and she and her family conveniently settled in the uk to spend rest of their lives in tranquility.

I am shocked at your post Sir. Do you honestly think that she was not shot and critically injured? You think that it is a lie that she was treated by the Army Hospital and that the ISPR release as well as Taliban declaration to target her again and Imran Khan saying that he sat with Malala’s father were all fake and that the whole thing was a nothing but a drama. (See links below)

https://www.dawn.com/news/755419

https://tribune.com.pk/story/449070...-malala-yousufzai-injured-in-firing-incident/

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/wor...ful-solution-to-Pakistans-brutal-reality.html

I can understand that many people don’t like Malala out of shear jealousy but it appears that you would have been happier if that brave girl had actually died ?

Honourable Sir, I can only say that I have no words to argue with someone who insists that it is night even when the sun is shining brightly. Let us agree to completely disagree.

 

[Musafir117]

It has really surprised me that everybody from moderators to think tanks came out to support a girl whose father has clearly been linked with foreign agencies(read CIA).This girl supposedly got shot in the head and surprisingly enough lived to tell the tale,let me tell you something my friend got shot in the head and he died 12 hrs after that.
Bottom line is it was just a hogwash and she and her family conveniently settled in the uk to spend rest of their lives in tranquility.

Our whole establishment linked with CIA so what? There are various cases people survived to get bullet in head or you living in caves?

 

[tarrar]

What is happening with Malala from day one is a clear proof that something is fishy & how could she had survived so many gun shots which was claimed on corrupt media. Also we all can see she is close to anti Islamic bastards like Salman Rashde & others, also her book was completely written by anti Pakistani & anti Islamic bastard, only for Malalas name to be printed on the book. We all by now know she is a complete fake & is living & working for foreign agenda & how she is getting polished by foreign powers is a clear proof on what a fake b!tch she really is.

 

[graphican]

Malala is nothing more than a balloon, who's air came from America.

 

[mingle]

I can disagree with her but there r a lot of issue s which r hidden from her articles as gulmaki to her book .More is her father behind her persona she is just cheer leader nothing else .

 

[YeBeWarned]

Bhai mai Qiyaamat ka wait ker raha hun , Buhat si Conspiracy theories ka sach janna hai mujhe .. mujhe tu lagta hai Allah mian ko 1000 Saal tu sirf Conspiracy theories hi solve kerne mai lag jayen gay .. for the topic, i don't want to comment , Lets all wait till the judgment day when all Truth tellers and Liars will stand before that Great Creator , and lets make no mistake my dearly supporters and deniers of Conspiracy theories , The the Truth will Triumph and False will perish as Allah said, Falsehood is by nature to be perish..

 

[El Sidd]

Not this again please. She is but just one child with one story just like everyone of us. The moral of the story is important and not the person.

Whatever happened happened. Learn from the issue at hand and make sure education does not become a luxury just for the rich.

 

[niaz]

A good column by Hamid Mir in Urdu. However, well educated Conspiracy Theorists still continue to believe that attack on Malala was fake.

https://jang.com.pk/print/303577-hamid-mir-column-2017-04-24-god-father

حا مد میر
MAY 29, 2017 | 12:00 AM

 

[Mian Babban]

Musarrat Ahmad Zeb was removed from PTI two years ago. Bad journalism by Tribune. https://www.dawn.com/news/1305309 .
https://tribune.com.pk/story/1415434/pti-distances-mna-controversial-remarks-malala/

She belongs to the family of former rulers of Swat. She being a fierce Pakistanist, has beef with ANP and Malala's family are ANP-ites. She follows me on twitter , and just today she had exchange of sharp words with a senior ANP karkun

 

[sur]

...

...Do you honestly think that she was not shot and critically injured? You think that it is a lie that she was treated by the Army Hospital ...

I have my guesses too.

She was indeed shot and injured. So were 2 other girls...
But those 2 other girls did not become famous. In fact we never heard about them except in very early news.

After whatever happened, current reality is that Malala has portrayed a great image of Pakistan and she is true sincere Pakistani. She speaks very well in her public addresses.

Malala had nothing to do with the planning of those events. I mean she herself wasn't aware that she was being made famous and for what reasons.

She was picked by whoever (those who wanted to make Pak look bad internationally). She was made little famous by this white guy who was actually one of the perpetrators... (just a guess!)

Plan was to make her a little known name & then kill her to portray to the world that this is what happens to girls in Pak who want to study etc etc..

But it didn't go quite as planned... so they resorted to plan-B. Now she's famous.
But Malala herself had nothing to do with plot nor is she aware that she was being plotted against.

Adam B.Ellick's contact with Malala was also a way to keep track of her movements and execute the shooting.

 

[Mian Babban]

She was indeed shot and injured. So were 2 other girls...
But those 2 other girls did not become famous. In fact we never heard about them except in very early news.

Perhaps you dont know but Malala was already a well known person (at least in anti-Taliban Pashtun circles) before the shooting, the other two girls were not. You are forgetting that Taliban had specifically came after Malala, not after other girls on the occasion who were nobodies. They deemed her as a threat as she was appearing in Seminars and conferences , talking about girls education and about conditions of schools in Swat under Taliban occupation.

Taliban had given warnings to her family several times before the incident which her foolish father ignored. She had already startled Taliban with this interview in 2009

Now majority of Pakistanis and almost entire West mistakenly think that she was juts ordinary/common girl who was one day shot by Taliban for no reason and background and that she became a 'celebrity' after getting shot in the head by Taliban. Thats why there were voices in Pakistan who were demanding that the other two slightly injured girls should also be given same recognition and facility of going to UK by government of Pakistan as given to Malala.

.........

Many Pashtuns and other Pakistanis are hostile to her on the same grounds that she brought badnami to her qaum and country. They are the people of same mindset who will frown upon rape victim but not rapists. For her age (10 year old in 2009) , her extraordinarily boldness was actually her innocence and the fearlessness (or lack of caution) was due to her father (ANPite fool) who thought Taliban being Pashtuns wont hurt a girl. ANP leadership and notables keep contacts with Americans (including American Embassy officials some of whom are CIA) and Indians , but they did not need convincing from them to oppose Taliban. The same CIA agents of American Embassy of Pakistan, also meet a whole lot of people including diplomats , politicians and army general......why singling out family of Malala?