How does SATP collect their statistics? Do they have a media article they source for each terrorist attack? And yes I know not all terrorist attacks have a media article. Nevertheless, I need to know they happened. One can't just say that just because SATP says an attack happened, the attack must have happened.
At least 4 killed, 14 injured in Karachi suicide blast
- Thread starter karan.1970
- Start date
karan.1970
BANNED
- Joined
- Jan 3, 2010
- Messages
- 14,781
- Reaction score
- -20
- Country
- Location
Sir, the base line is same.. If the numbers include sectarian violence plus bomb blasts in 2011, the 2010 numbers and 2009 numbers also include both. So the comparison remains apples to apples. However, if your contention is that in Pakistan one evil (traditional terrorism aka suicide blasts) is going down and another evil (sectarian violence aka targeted killings, shoot outs etc) are on the rise, then ok, you may be right there.. But really, is that any different from terrorism ?? Because there also, the concept is same, using physical terror to enforce an ideology. The only difference between the 2 is that both are enforcing a different ideology.. And in the end, as I said before, its the methodology and not ideology that defines terrorism.
Hindustani
BANNED
- Joined
- Nov 15, 2010
- Messages
- 1,748
- Reaction score
- -3
- Country
- Location
Seems like the violence in Karachi has increased. Sad.
karan.1970
BANNED
- Joined
- Jan 3, 2010
- Messages
- 14,781
- Reaction score
- -20
- Country
- Location
SATP provides a timeline and datasheets for incidents that it has used for calculations.. You may go thru them and correlate their dates to media articles of that date to verify.. Mostly I have found them fairly accurate.. The only difference could be classifying an attack in terrorism or not.. Mostly I have seen them erring on the side of caution.
Dude, its all about classification. You are only looking at a TTP suicide bomber exploding himself in a crowded market or an attack on Mehran Naval base as a terror strike.. where as some people consider people of a particular sect, taken off a bus and shot in cold blood as terrorism as well(which your site classifies as sectarian violence and not terrorism).. Read my response to sir fatman.. I have tried to explain my POV there
Quoting from SATP.ORG
Pakistans continuing engagement with the production and export of Islamist extremism and terrorism continued to produce a bloody blowback at home, with a total of at least 6,142 persons, including of 2,797 militants, 2,580 civilians and 765 Security Forces (SFs) personnel killed in 2011. However, even this worrying total constituted an improvement of 17.75 per cent over the preceding year. 7,435 persons, including 5,170 militants, 1,796 civilians and 469 SF personnel, had been killed in 2010.
While civilian and SF fatalities increased by whopping 43.65 and 63.11 percent, respectively, the steep decline (45.89 percent) in fatalities among the militants, primarily due to Islamabads approach of going soft on terror, was the sole reason for the decrease in overall fatalities through 2011.
Meanwhile, Federal Interior Minister Rehman Malik on August 2, 2011, informed the National Assembly that the SFs had arrested 3,143 alleged terrorists in the country and recovered 4,240 weapons from them over the preceding three years. However, the Chief Justice of Pakistan Justice Iftikhar Mohammad Chaudhry, on December 24, 2011, expressed dissatisfaction over the slow disposal of cases in Anti-Terrorism Courts (ATC), over delays in submission of charge sheets and frequent adjournments being sought and granted to prosecuting and defence counsel in trial courts.
The country recorded at least 476 major incidents (involving three or more killings) of terrorism in 2011, in which 4,447 persons were killed. The fiercest of these attacks took place on May 13, 2011, when 90 people, including 73 Paramilitary Forces (PMF) personnel and 17 civilians, were killed by twin suicide bombers who attacked troops as they were about to leave a Frontier Corps (FC) Training Centre in the Shabqadar tehsil in the Charsadda District of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KP). After the attack, Tehrik-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) spokesman Ehsanullah Ehsan declared, "This was the first revenge for Osama's martyrdom. Wait for bigger attacks in Pakistan and Afghanistan." The number of major attacks in 2010 stood at 662, inflicting a total of 6,088 fatalities.
There was, however, a dramatic decline in fatalities inflicted by suicide attacks, though the diminution in the total number of such attacks was not as sharp. 41 suicide attacks, inflicting 628 fatalities, were reported in 2011, as against 49 such attacks inflicting 1,167 fatalities in 2010. Revelations by Umar Fidayee (14), the teenage suicide bomber who was arrested as an accomplice in the suicide attack on the shrine of Sufi saint Ahmed Sultan, popularly known as Sakhi Sarwar, in the Dera Ghazi Khan District of Punjab on April 3, 2011, indicated that up to 400 suicide bombers were being trained in NWA, suggesting that little respite from such attacks was to be expected in the days to come.
The number of terrorist engineered explosions across Pakistan increased from 473 in 2010 to 639 in 2011, resulting in 1,547 and 1,092 fatalities, respectively. Sectarian violence also continued to haunt the troubled country, with at least 30 such incidents reported in 2011 as against 57 in 2010, resulting in 203 and 509 fatalities, respectively.
Target killings a continuous stream of assassinations inspired by sectarian, political or purely criminal motives, and executed by a range of armed non-state actors engulfed the nation. A February 14, 2012, Home Department Report observed, Target killings still continue in most parts of the country and major reasons behind these are sectarian, demographic changes, easy access to illicit weapons, mistrust among ethnic groups, family enimities and business rivalries. Significantly, official documents noted that, over the preceding four years, since the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP)-led coalition came into power in 2008, the Government had issued about 50,000 prohibited-bore arms licenses. The licenses had been issued to applicants from all the Provinces, allowing them to carry sub-machineguns and AK-47s for their personal security.
You failed to answer my post, that the data collected by satp.org is unverifiable, and highly inaccurate.
Many of the news reports they base their statistics off are unverifiable.
The source that I provided talks in detail about not just the nature of the attacks; but also of the details of the casualties, the distribution of the casualties, attack tactics used by the terrorists; as well as other details. Something which is not described by satp.org. It has vague data, & a lot of it is unverifiable as well.
I agree that the Mehran base incident & others were acts of terror. I agree that sectarian terrorism & other forms are classified as terrorism; but the satp.org's data also calls political & ethnic killings (all acts of domestic violence) as terrorism, which is not the case. If that were the case, as SMC pointed out, the US would be facing one of the highest threats of terrorism in its country, with only 15k people being killed from shootings every year. Which is why it is important to make this classification. The source I have posted includes all types of terrorism (WOT terrorism, sectarian terrorism, separatist insurgent terrorism etc); whereas satp.org also classifies acts of political & ethnic (domestic) violence as terrorism. Which is why the statistics posted by satp.org are highly skewed & inaccurate.
Harry Potter
BANNED
- Joined
- Dec 14, 2011
- Messages
- 600
- Reaction score
- 0
But still Bilal uses SATP as a source when posting about Maoists.
karan.1970
BANNED
- Joined
- Jan 3, 2010
- Messages
- 14,781
- Reaction score
- -20
- Country
- Location
Go thru this.. I think its fairly detailed.. Just putting in the link since the data is too large to post here
Pakistan Timeline 2012
No, I always use the original news reports (i do NOT quote from satp.org) when talking about violence from Maoists. Observe:
No, I always use the original news reports (i do NOT quote from satp.org) when talking about violence from Maoists. Observe:
No, I always use the original news reports (i do NOT quote from satp.org) when talking about violence from Maoists. Observe:
Harry Potter
BANNED
- Joined
- Dec 14, 2011
- Messages
- 600
- Reaction score
- 0
^Every report of casualties in pakistan also has a news source.
You even post abductions as acts of insurgency.
You even post abductions as acts of insurgency.
They have not quoted any of the original links, most of the incidents are unverified. Most of their data is vague.
karan.1970
BANNED
- Joined
- Jan 3, 2010
- Messages
- 14,781
- Reaction score
- -20
- Country
- Location
Ok.. Take it as you like..
Harry Potter
BANNED
- Joined
- Dec 14, 2011
- Messages
- 600
- Reaction score
- 0
Self Delete.
Harry Potter
BANNED
- Joined
- Dec 14, 2011
- Messages
- 600
- Reaction score
- 0
you are right a simple google search of each of this will get you a link to a pakistani source like Dawn,Nation etc.
karan.1970
BANNED
- Joined
- Jan 3, 2010
- Messages
- 14,781
- Reaction score
- -20
- Country
- Location
Anyway, I had made an observation based on the reports at SATP which is a fairly decent source of terrorism data. If someone does not have confidence on that data and its accuracy, well, I have no inclination to argue that with him. However be happy do discuss my interpretation of that data with anyone who is interested..
notsuperstitious
ELITE MEMBER
- Joined
- Jan 11, 2009
- Messages
- 10,473
- Reaction score
- -15
Secterian violence is terrorism is too, if it systematically targets civilians.
Any case lets hope there's an end to every kind of violence.
Any case lets hope there's an end to every kind of violence.
Similar threads
