Assam Congress MP Becomes Muslim

[Supply&Demand]

Assam is becoming another Pakistan, with Bangladeshis infiltrating in droves, hindus will find it very difficult to live..

It will not be long before, 15 yr old hindu girls will be kidnapped and will be forced to convert

 

[Rusty]

The quran doesn't mention any punishment, but some of the hadiths do. Anyway, in any place where shariah law has been established, the punishment for apostac has been death. Have you met any ex muslims in saudi arabia?

In contrast there are no such laws in any other non islamic society. You can say that that law is not really islamic, but islamic socities have always had punishments for apostacy, and many still do. By law.

No you are wrong.
1. The Quran is a higher authority then hadith, and Quran says there is no compulsion in religion.
2. The "death penalty" you speak of is for treason. At the time of battle some "Muslims" would say they have left islam so they would not have to fight. Then after the battle they would become Muslims again. Basically they were committing treason (any sane person would agree that is treason), so the prophet gave an order to execute anyone who does that.
3. Monarchies are against Sharia as well, but Saudis don't seem to notice. Saudi is not an example of Sharia.
4. Again, not true sine there is no punishment of apostasy.

 

[Rusty]

double post

 

[DRaisinHerald]

That is the Hypocrisy of Islam, If A Non-Muslims Girl Marries a Muslim, She has to Convert to Islam.
And If a Muslim Girl Marries a Non-Muslim, Then also The Non-Muslim has to Convert to Islam

You fell in love with a Muslim girl? Too bad; because Muslim girls can't marry non-Muslim men, and most of of the time they don't want to either.

 

[Rusty]

It only shows what kind of woman she is if she left her 2 yr old child for the sake of some pathetic piece of $hit



should i show u news report from Pakistan..about treatment meted out to a woman who converted from Christianity to Islam and again reverted back?

And I can show you news reports of Indians burying alive young girls for the crime of being girls. what's your point?

 

[SamantK]

She converted, big deal.. move on.. Rusty you can keep your wisdom to yourself and Indians can get over the fact that she converted to Islam for whatever reason..

 

[DRaisinHerald]

The "death penalty" you speak of is for treason. At the time of battle some "Muslims" would say they have left islam so they would not have to fight. Then after the battle they would become Muslims again. Basically they were committing treason (any sane person would agree that is treason), so the prophet gave an order to execute anyone who does that

Thanks for the clarification, these nobs don't have everything else to do but bash Islam. So much for Indian secularism, one guy converts to Islam and the rest start crying.

 

[Rusty]

BTW, what ever happened to "Hindus are tolerant of everyone, and there are many streams to God"

Just by the sheer hatred by the Hindu members here, it seems like that's all nonsense.
Just more hypocrisy from the Indians, but what else is new

 

[janon]

No you are wrong.
1. The Quran is a higher authority then hadith, and Quran says there is no compulsion in religion.
2. The "death penalty" you speak of is for treason. At the time of battle some "Muslims" would say they have left islam so they would not have to fight. Then after the battle they would become Muslims again. Basically they were committing treason (any sane person would agree that is treason), so the prophet gave an order to execute anyone who does that.
3. Monarchies are against Sharia as well, but Saudis don't seem to notice. Saudi is not an example of Sharia.
4. Again, not true sine there is no punishment of apostasy.

Thats why I said earlier that this is an evasive manuever. Throughout the middle ages, and today, islamic socities have had punishments for apostacy. Up until the 20th century, it used to be death for males, and imprisonment in a dark room for females until they repent. Now you can keep saying that it is not part of islam because it is not mentioned in the quran, but in practice it has always been enforced, and muslim scholars have always supported it. And it is a fact that apostacy carries penalties in most muslim countries even today, by law. That has been the consensus of most muslim scholars and jurists, throughout the ages, and these are the people who set laws for the people. You can pick any muslim society you want, whether saudi or iran or afghanistan today, and historically. Read the wiki page for how it has been through the ages:
Apostasy in Islam - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

 

[SamantK]

And I can show you news reports of Indians burying alive young girls for the crime of being girls. what's your point?

off-topic bu!!****

 

[Supply&Demand]

I remember reading a report about Kashmri Pandits and the their mass exodus from the valley in 1989-90

It seems for many days, muslims were shouting in mics from nearby mosques and from top of vehicles threatening Kashmirir Pandits to leave the valley and leave their wives and daughters behind..

This is the classic way muslim extremists target non-muslims- by targetting their women...

 

[SamantK]

BTW, what ever happened to "Hindus are tolerant of everyone, and there are many streams to God"

Just by the sheer hatred by the Hindu members here, it seems like that's all nonsense.
Just more hypocrisy from the Indians, but what else is new

We are not discussing Hindu tolerance here are we, why do you want to continually go off-topic. Create a new thread if you want to do that.

 

[Supply&Demand]

And I can show you news reports of Indians burying alive young girls for the crime of being girls. what's your point?

first go and check ur posts where u said there is no apostasy in Islam

 

[Rusty]

Thats why I said earlier that this is an evasive manuever. Throughout the middle ages, and today, islamic socities have had punishments for apostacy. Up until the 20th century, it used to be death for males, and imprisonment in a dark room for females until they repent. Now you can keep saying that it is not part of islam because it is not mentioned in the quran, but in practice it has always been enforced, and muslim scholars have always supported it. And it is a fact that apostacy carries penalties in most muslim countries even today, by law. That has been the consensus of most muslim scholars and jurists, throughout the ages, and these are the people who set laws for the people. You can pick any muslim society you want, whether saudi or iran or afghanistan today, and historically. Read the wiki page for how it has been through the ages:
Apostasy in Islam - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Ok so you accept that Islam does not allow for death to apostates, that's some progress at least.
So you can no longer make the claim that Islam tells people to do that.
Now what people do or don't do is not Islam's fault, it is the peoples fault. So bringing up this apostasy on this thread is as sensible as bringing up the GDP of Burundi. In that they have nothing to do with Islam and the topic.

As for your assertion that it has always been done, that again is nonsense.
Like forced conversion, killing apostates is against Islam and historically speaking it has been done by some misguided people mostly for political reasons.
but having said that, it has always been the exception and not the rule.

Don't let your hatred cloud your judgment. I can also easy make non sense claims about Hinduism just by taking a few examples (widow burning and what not) but I am sensible enough to know that those are rare cases and the people doing it are not following the religion properly.

 

[Roybot]

Yeah wtf? Who gives a shyte.