As Assam's Massive Citizenship Drive Nears Finish Line, Uncertainty Looms

[Bilal9]

some states were at 0% even before swach bharat abhiyan started.

Fe-Fi-Fo-Fam! I smell a Sanghi Man!

Random quotes about the greatness of Bharat (Mera Bharat Mahaan), mentioning Swach Abhijaan and the like at every turn, yes we have a Sanghi on our hands....

Keep this Bongladeshi sh1t with you man.whole world knows who you people are.

And the world knows your country a lot better, Shyam. For all the WRONG reasons.

It's like calling some support line, and an Indian answers, calling himself 'Sam'. Rrrighttttt...............

The world knows Indians and their creative lota habits too.

Those get posted by the whole world on Instagram, every damn day....

Ok, so farm labourer wage in Assam is 14-15 dollars a day?
Can we have a credible link for this claim?

Tumi ki pagol hoiso bhai?

Link dibo koithekka?

These guys are like first class frauds as always.

A backward place like the NE? And daily wage at 15 dollars?

 

[swnjo]

Fe-Fi-Fo-Fam! I smell a Sanghi Man!

Random quotes about the greatness of Bharat (Mera Bharat Mahaan), mentioning Swach Abhijaan and the like at every turn, yes we have a Sanghi on our hands....

I dont know what a sanghi has ever done to you , but it seems you are incapable of reading the links provided.BJP did nt even rule these state, when stats were compiled.

 

[Black_cats]

Quoted from here from 2006. where is the propaganda again?
http://www.in.undp.org/content/dam/india/docs/gendering_human_development_indices_summary_report.pdf

I quoted from 2016 which one is more recent and reliable?

It also shows the data of 2006 was not reliable.

 

[UKBengali]

These guys are like first class frauds as always.

A backward place like the NE? And daily wage at 15 dollars?

Have you seen how he is now trying to divert ,saying that BD'shis are migrating to his dump for other reasons than better employment prospects? Maybe it is for the glorious Indian culture of open defecation that attracts BD'shis from their homeland?

Since he will never come up with a link please see below:

https://paycheck.in/main/salary/minimumwages/assam

BD does not have a minimum wage in agriculture since one is not required as labour supply is tight. This has meant that pay has rocketed to over 7 dollars a day in Cox's Bazaar in the far south. The garments industry required a minimum wage in BD due to surplus of female labour which drove wages down to below subsistence levels.

Our comparison has to be like for like. So an unskilled farm labourer in BD gets 600 Taka a day which works out to be 7.3 dollars. In the supposed Assamese paradise for poor landless BD'shis they get 250 Indian Rupee as of last year - it is unlikely to have gone up in just one year. This 250 Rupees is just 3.9 dollars, which is just over half that can be earnt in BD.

So we are supposed to believe that landless and uneducated BD'shis will go from their own country where they can earn around twice as much, into a bigoted foreign land where their earning power will be around half?!
These Indian trolls must think that everyone was born yesterday!

If this moron ever comes up with BBS fake statistics nonsense again, then we only need remind the forum that BD unskilled agricultural wages are twice that of Assam, and then all fair and neutral posters will see his lies for what they are - lies from a butt-hurt loser.

 

[Nilgiri]

https://defence.pk/pdf/threads/repository-for-bd-statistics-bbs-quality-credibility.525379/
loI , If these were true , everything BD members are claiming in this thread are not accurate? HDI literacy rate etc?SMH

They have credibility issue....no one can really know how deep it is tbh....but its there.

So far the few instances of actual 3rd party verification (like say economist did with the liveability of Dhaka) suggests its pretty deep dissonance between paper and reality.

Problem is the tourism/foreign interaction levels in BD are severely low...so there is not much fact checking genuinely going on. A journalist might visit to say cover the rohingya thing, but what choice does such person have than to use the BBS published data for reference? UN and all others cant really openly reject BD claims either, given UN is essentially a feel good over actual development organisation to begin with. You have to dig somewhat deep inside the UN and such organisations (that measure development, economy etc) to find their deep down credibility analysis of Bangladesh versus other developing countries....that is the point of that thread.

I will revisit the issue again at some later point.

Ok, so farm labourer wage in Assam is 14-15 dollars a day?
Can we have a credible link for this claim?

First you have to accept the average worker in India earns twice that of his counterpart in Bangladesh.

We can then go into specific state by state analysis after you acknowledge that. Otherwise no point.

 

[bluesky]

As usual, the GoI is creating another myth of BD immigrant in their heavily developed Assam. Assam has seen Muslim migration in historical times after the 1st Muslim adventure there by Ikhtiaruddin Khilji in 1203 CE. India is late by almost 800 years to find them out. No one from BD goes to Assam to work there, all are native Assamese Muslims and non-Muslims.

 

[EastBengalPro]

Assam’s citizenship list: A ticking ‘time bomb’ for Indo-Bangla ties

At the moment, a crisis is clearly looming with no sign of a solution on the horizon
The publication of the National Register of Citizens (NRC) by the Indian state of Assam on December 31 will pose a big challenge to the country’s relationship with Bangladesh, political observers have warned.

Once completed, the NRC will provide a definitive list of the legal citizens of Assam, and therefore of India, with all those left out likely to be identified as so-called “illegal intruders” from Bangladesh.

It is unclear what Dhaka will do if Delhi demands Bangladesh take back the several hundred thousand Bangali Muslims who reside in the state.

At the moment, a crisis is clearly looming with no sign of a solution on the horizon.

Various groups and communities have long been running political campaigns against the “Bangladeshi intruders”.

The influential All Assam Students Union (AASU) has been claiming that local Assamese are gradually becoming cornered because of Muslim Bangladeshi immigrants. They say the “intruders” are outnumbering the locals in many areas.



India’s ruling Bharatiya Janata Party, which came to power in Assam for the first time, has openly declared its position against “illegal Bangladeshis”. However, this term is only applicable to Muslims. The door is always open for Bangladeshi Hindus.

According to the Hindustan Times, the names left out of the list will be included in the final draft if they are able to prove links to family members who were listed in either the 1951 NRC or subsequent electoral rolls up to March 25, 1971.

Currently, the Indian Supreme Court is monitoring the entire process and will continue to do so until the final draft is released.

However, there have been controversies over the process to identify “illegal Bangladeshis”. Over the years, the issue of intrusion by Bangladeshi citizens has become a contentious political issue in the northeastern Indian state.



There are fears that Bangla-speaking Muslims will be branded intruders and have their rights to live in the state rescinded. They may be forced to live in detention camps along the border where several thousand suspected “foreigners” (Bangladeshis) have already been kept.

Joyeeta Bhattacharjee, a senior fellow at Delhi think-tank Observer Research Foundation, said hundreds of thousands of people would not be able to prove their citizenship in Assam.

She warned that if the number of detainees swells to hundreds of thousands at these camps, the problem could even turn into a diplomatic crisis if Bangladesh does not move to repatriate its nationals.

“As far as I know, Bangladesh is not ready to take back any of them,” she said.

She pointed out that there had been no formal discussion between Delhi and Dhaka about preparing the NRC, let alone repatriating “illegal Bangladeshis”.



“This is why this issue is comparable to a ‘time bomb’ in the two countries’ bilateral relationship,” Joyeeta said.

This fear is not unfounded. The first NRC draft included 19 million people out of the total 32.9 million applicants. Others, particularly the Bangali Muslim residents, are facing an uncertain future.

Hafiz Rashid Choudhury, a Guwahati-based lawyer and chief adviser to the Assam citizens’ rights protection committee, said there were enough reasons to fear that hundreds of thousands of people would become stateless once the final NRC list is published within the next few months.



Various political parties and organizations will view these stateless people as nothing other than “illegal Bangladeshis” and put pressure on the central government to deport them.

Syed Muazzem Ali, the Bangladesh high commissioner to Delhi, told reporters in an informal briefing that the matter had Dhaka worried. He said he was monitoring the situation in Assam and was keeping Dhaka updated.

http://www.dhakatribune.com/world/s...list-ticking-time-bomb-india-bangladesh-ties/

 

[Bilal9]

Have you seen how he is now trying to divert ,saying that BD'shis are migrating to his dump for other reasons than better employment prospects? Maybe it is for the glorious Indian culture of open defecation that attracts BD'shis from their homeland?

Since he will never come up with a link please see below:

https://paycheck.in/main/salary/minimumwages/assam

BD does not have a minimum wage in agriculture since one is not required as labour supply is tight. This has meant that pay has rocketed to over 7 dollars a hour in Cox's Bazaar in the far south. The garments industry required a minimum wage in BD due to surplus of female labour which drove wages down to below subsistence levels.

Our comparison has to be like for like. So an unskilled farm labourer in BD gets 600 Taka a day which works out to be 7.3 dollars. In the supposed Assamese paradise for poor landless BD'shis they get 250 Indian Rupee as of last year - it is unlikely to have gone up in just one year. This 250 Rupees is just 3.9 dollars, which is just over half that can be earnt in BD.

So we are supposed to believe that landless and uneducated BD'shis will go from their own country where they can earn around twice as much, into a bigoted foreign land where their earning power will be around half?!
These Indian trolls must think that everyone was born yesterday!

If this moron ever comes up with BBS fake statistics nonsense again, then we only need remind the forum that BD unskilled agricultural wages are twice that of Assam, and then all fair and neutral posters will see his lies for what they are - lies from a butt-hurt loser.

Lies and more lies. These trolls are a bunch of shameless 'cleft-lipped' liers. Keeps coming back for more shameless slaps every day.....