So the whole world talk about 10 tribes, Christianity believe their return would mark the beginning of Armageddon, the "Jews" believe their return would be classed as their final redemption and here you are talking absolute BS.
Again you rape the reality and brings opinions of shady people who were wrong to "prove" your ideas.
The Ten Lost Tribes is a myth from the Mishnah and Talmud!
The whole world has adopted many things from Jews,even Armageddon is a corruption of Jewish prophecy that there will be war at Har Megiddo (Mount Megiddo),Rabbinic Judaism in the Diaspora developed the myth of the return of the ten lost tribes at the salvation,and again,dividing the tribes by the kingdoms:
United kingdom of israel
--------------------------------
1.)Reuven
2.)Shimon
3.)Yehuda(the leader)
4.)Dan
5.)Naftali
6.)Gad
7.)Asher
8.)Isaschar
9.)Zvulun
10.)Binyamin
11.)Menashe
12.)Efraim
Northern kingdom of israel
------------------------------------
1.)Reuven
2.)Dan
3.)Naftali
4.)Gad
5.)Asher
6.)Isaschar
7.)Zvulun
8.)menashe
9.)efraim(the leader)
Kingdom of judah/judea
---------------------------------
1.)Yehuda(the leader)
2.)Shimon
3.)Binyamin
*The tribe of Levi is distributed among all the tribes
Do you see 10 tribes of israel????do you know math???????
The Afghans entertain strong prejudices against the Jewish nation, which would at least show that they have no desire to claim – without just cause – a descent from them. [Sir Alexander Burnes, Travels into Bokhara, Vol. 2:139-141.]
Burnes was again in 1837 sent as the first British Envoy to the Court of Kabul. For some time he was the guest of King Dost Mohammad Khan. He questioned the King about the descent of the Afghans from the Israelites. The King replied that "his people had no doubt of that, though they repudiated the idea of being Jews.
Thomas Ledlie wrote an article in the Calcutta Review, which he subsequently elaborated and published in two volumes. He expressed his views on the subject very clearly: "The Europeans always confuse things, when they consider the fact that the Afghans call themselves Bani Israel and yet reject their Jewish descent. Indeed, the Afghans discard the very idea of any descent from the Jews. They, however, yet claim themselves to be of Bani Israel." [Thomas Ledlie, More Ledlian, Calcutta Review, January, 1898]
Ledlie goes on to explain: "Israelites, or the Ten Tribes, to whom the term Israel was applied – after their separation from the House of David, and the tribe of Judah, which tribe retained the name of Judah and had a distinct history ever after. These last alone are called Jews and are distinguished from the Bani Israel as much in the East as in the West." [Ibid., 7]
Shalva Weil, anthropologist and senior researcher at the Hebrew University of Jerusalemsaid "Of all the groups, there is more convincing evidence about the Pathans than anybody else, but the Pathans are the ones who would reject Israel most ferociously. That is the sweet irony"
There are people who consider groups or nations to the descendants of the children of Israel, in Japan, China, India, Afghanistan, Pakistan, the Caucasus, Iran, Iraq, Australia, Turkey, Kenya, Uganda, Nigeria, Tanzania, Canada, USA, Brazil, Peru, Bolivia , Asian, Native American, black, Aboriginal people.
So what? It means that they are right?
Some groups / nations / people think like that because all kinds of discovers and researchers told them that.
Some because missionaries.
There are many reasons.
There are also those who adopted Jewish practices, which did not exist at all during the period of Israel and Judah, but only 1,000 years later, where it came from ??
Various researchers have also decided that we, "Mountain Jews", are part of the ten lost tribes, because they did not know we lived in the mountains in the Caucasus, so they thought we were lost, we told them that our path is:
Israel-Judea-Babylon-Persia-Caucasus-israel
They made genetic testing, archaeological and historical investigation
And finally discovered that we were right, and if we get married, we have to do genetic testing, because we are all from the same ancestor Israeli mother, and that can create problems for the baby, like my parents did for example.
For Pashtuns, maybe they were Jews who converted to Islam, I don't know if there is a connection between them to the Jews of Afghanistan,maybe..., they have some Talmudic traditions, whether they are from the kingdom of Israel, how they maintain later traditions?
The story of the ten tribes as the bible tells it is pretty basic: After the death of King Solomon and under the rule of his incompetent son Rehoboam (r. c. 930– c.915 BCE), the Kingdom of Israel split into two. In south, two of the tribes that were of Jacob’s offspring, Judah and Benjamin, formed the kingdom of Judah around the capital in Jerusalem. In the north, the other ten created the kingdom of Israel and built a new capital in Samaria. In 721 BCE, the Assyrian king (actually Sargon II, who reigned 722 – 705 BCE, though the Bible says it was Shalmaneser V [r. 727 to 722 BCE])—sacked the city and destroyed the kingdom. The ten tribes went into exile. Only Judah and Benjamin remained to tell the story. A little over a century later, Judah was also destroyed by the Babylonians, and went to its own exilic period captivity. But miraculously these exiles returned to Jerusalem from “the rivers of Babylon,” and rebuilt their temple when Persian emperor Cyrus allowed them to do so. This turn of events was in accordance with the prophecies of the great prophets Isaiah, Jeremiah, and Ezekiel, who promised return to Jerusalem. But the ten tribes never came back. They were lost, seemingly without a trace.
The source you brought is inaccurate,as i said before,3 tribe in judah,9 tribes in israel.
Another inaccurate is:
Shalmaneser conquered the rest of the kingdom of Israel apart from Samaria(shomron)
Meanwhile Sargon replaced him and he is the one who conquered samaria(shomron).
*according to the bible(the hebrew one)
Another inaccurate is:
"
The ten tribes went into exile" "But the ten tribes never came back. They were lost, seemingly without a trace."
In the kingdom of israel(the northern)there were 350,000 people,the assyrians exciled 40,000 by two waves
13,000&27,000 elites(citizens) and soldiers to Babylon, Nineveh and other cities,so atleast 300,00 people stayed in their land.Moreover, immediately after the destruction, the people of the Kingdom of Israel made a pilgrimage to Jerusalem(capital of judah) to celebrate the Passover.
Hezekiah king of Judah called for Israeli residents to reunite with their brethren, and they heard his call and agreed.
Hezekiah then annexed to his kingdom territories from Israel.
The population of the kingdom of Judah grew 5 times because assimilation of Israelis in Judea.
The population of Jerusalem has grown 10 times until it had a majority of Israelis.
When the Babylonians deported a few tens of thousands of people from Judah to Babylon, they were reunited with some of the "Assyrian exile". Some of those exiled to Assyria also returned together with the Judean exiles to Jerusalem, following Cyrus declaration.
Some chose not to take part in the "return to Zion"(shivat zion), and remained in exile.
They(not all of them) returned to the land of Israel/state of israel following the geopolitical changes and the modern "return to zion"(shivat zion) and the zionism.
From around 700-600 BCE there were no more tribes,they were all mixed!!!!!
There were no 10 tribes!! there were no lost tribes!!!
.
For most Jews the return of the ten tribes meant final redemption. For most Christians it was a sign of the apocalypse
It is a myth,a legend,some kind of tradition,mainly from the talmudic era,by orthodox rabbis.
Christianity is a copy,past and change of judaism.
To say that Isreal and Judah were not enemies is like stamping yourself to be a complete idiot.
In the first about 50 years atfer the split israel and judah found themselves in wars between them or more correctly
the house of David against the house of Ephraim, Jeroboam against Rehoboam,because Jeroboam rebelled against Rehoboam.
Then the house of omri took the royalty,put an end to rebellion and made peace with Judah.
Since then they were married to each other, fought together against their enemies, etc.
The house of Daud (David) split because of the inter tribal rivalry. The inter tribal animosity has always been there.
Yes, there was an inter tribal rivalry much before the kingdom era(it is very logical btw)
No, it is not why the united kingdom of Israel split.
The kingdom split because of the high taxes policy of Rehoboam who didn't listen to his own people(the advisors) to low the taxes,because he wanted to show that he is a strong king.
This is something you wont understand because you are a jew, a khazar jew, you lost your tribal ways but in reality you were never part of it.
As i said my "community" made genetic tests because we all from the same ancient israel mom,my genes are levantines,my bones are the same as ancient bones that found in israel,they also close(Only one mutation is different) to the Phoenicians.
The khazar theory invented,developed,spread and used by anti-semites,you are probably one of them!
you probably said that and it is common with muslims/arabs in the last 100 years to say that, because the bnei(bani)israel are mentioned in the quran as the people of allah who drove them out of egypt to the promise land,the land of israel,and since you can't denied the quran,you trying to deny my nation and our connection to our land.
You can talk till tomorrow,it won't help you,
Here some bani(bunny) israel for you
Pakthoon even today have the same inter tribal rivalry and vengeance.
The same as billions of people around the world
You even dont dress up or look like the Bani Isreal of ancient. Where is your turban gone dude and how the turban got replaced by that cowboy hat??
First how you know my clothes,are you hiding in my closet? please,get out of the closet!
and cowboy hat??
good you didn't said sombrero
ay yay yay!!!!
And always remember, like most of the humanity, the Hebrews, their ancestors, were originally a tribe of Indus.
No no,you are from indus tribe who conquered by arabs who changed your religion and more
Yes what is your question?
where is your original religion???
Please don't answer i'm out
lantai bottt hum mardooon ka saloon ki baat kar raha tha
