Archaeologists reject Indian research regarding Indus Valley Civilization

[Mugwop]

so? even today lot of traditional hindus eat beef and bury their dead, sign of continity...

lot??
IVC also has something else in common with the people of Pakistan "which indian hindus dont have"
It's called Hospitality

 

[Joe Shearer]

lot??
IVC also has something else in common with the people of Pakistan "which indian hindus dont have"
It's called Hospitality

We noticed quite a lot of it recently. Unmistakable. Absolutely engrained in the psyche.

 

[Srinivas]

Science is not politics!

Archaeologists reject Indian research regarding Indus Valley Civilization

• ISLAMABAD: Archaeologists in Pakistan have rejected Indian archaeologists' research stating that Indus Valley Civilization was 8,000 years old instead of 5,500 and originated from inland proper India proliferated and spread westward from India to the eastern border of Pakistan.

The research was conducted by the researchers of Archeological Survey of India and Indian Institute of Technology and presented through one of prestigious journal `Nature' with title "Indus valley civilization much older than thought".

Talking to APP, Archeology expert and former Director General of Archeology and Museums, Dr.Fazal Dad Kakar termed this research was based on false facts and was an intellectual aggression on the front of Indus valley civilization.

Dr Kakar, candidly refused to accept the age of Indus valley civilization as 8,000 year old and said that somebody surely twisted the reports of the scientists intentionally to create furor academicus, provoking excessive excitement over an intellectual issues.

Researchers most probably were referring to the dates of antecedents and formative stages of cultures from Mesolithic period through Neolithic (9,000-6,000)in this part of the world which culminated into mature bronze age (300 BC) Indus valley civilization at a date which might be estimated about (2,500-2,400 BC)termed at the sites of Harappa and Moenjodaro as the "Indus valley civilization", said Dr kakar.

He said a method of thermoluminescence was used as a means of dating ancient artifacts, particularly the property of some ceramics and other materials of becoming luminescent when pretreated and heated. This technique was used to date prothery shards of early Harappan time to 6,000 years and early Harappan and Hakra phase as far back as 8,000 years, quoted by Anindya Sarkar of deptt of Geology and Geophysics at IIT-Kharagpur.

He said the statement of the researchers that they have recovered perhaps the oldest pottery from the civilization is misleading. "They actually recovered pottery from a site but not civilization as single site which is even not named, do not constitute neither a culture nor civilization," he said.

Indian scientist trying to make believe the world that Indus valley civilization is originated from inland proper India proliferated and spread westward from India to the eastern border of Pakistan, comprising of Cholistan and Thar Desert which is wrong.

Dr Kakar, emphasized that "the basic aim of the Indian team of the scientists had actually set out to prove that the civilization proliferated to other Indian sites like Bhirrana and Rakhigarrhi in Haryana, apart from the known location of Harappa and Moenjodaro in Pakistan, and Lothal, Dholavira and Kalibangan in India".

He said the Archaeological milieu of the world knows very well that the sites of Balouchistan Plataeu and high land of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, represents all cultural levels such as pastoral, early farming village communities and sedentary urbanized village life.

He added these were the result of process of evolution from the Mesolithic period or stage lasting in this region from about at least 18,000 BC, known from Magdalenian painting and engraving and from some flint tools sites in region, transformed into Neolithic stage (Mehrgarh 9,000-6,000) than Chalecothic and finally to the Mature Bronze Age (3000 BC) stage.

Therefore the Balouchistan Plataeu and high land of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa is considered as the homeland for the development of various cultural, social and economic experiment that provided the necessary antecedents and formative stages for the rise of civilization in the Indus valley proper in Pakistan at Harappa and Moenjodro.

While at the later stage of Mature Bronze Age, Indus Civilization expended eastward beyond Saraswati or Gahkkar-Hakra river as attested at the sites of Lothal, Kalibangan and Dholavira etc, in India, he said.

 

[Spy Master]

koi yeh batayega , yeh 10th pass hai yah nahin ? Agar hai toh, kis madrasse ka scholar hai ?

Dont waste PDF bandwidth with your shitty posts you clown....!
@waz @Slav Defence @Oscar Can you ban this guy plz...!

If neutral western historians couldn't get through to them what makes you think these sadists will listen to Archaeologists in Pakistan?

IVC ate beef and buried their dead

Actually they will believe whatever sooth their false ego...!

 

[Arshad mahmood Hussain]

http://www.catchnews.com/india-news...-to-create-saraswati-1469211602.html/fullview

Myth of saraswati

 

[itachii]

lol pakistani archeologists ?? OP should have been more clear.

 

[Desist]

• ISLAMABAD: Archaeologists in Pakistan

There goes any credibility the article had.

And here I thought some internationally respected archeologists had said something.

 

[RPK]

Somebody whats know about Archaeology of India. Please Visit

http://asi.nic.in/

 

[barbarosa]

Indian historians archaeologists researchers scientists has polluted all the ancient history of the sub continent. They made hero to zero and zero to hero. They could not justice to our ancient heritages.

 

[Malik Usman]

Side effects of Bollywood Movie Mohnjo Daro.......it is still not released what will happen when it will be released.........

 

[AZADPAKISTAN2009]

You know the movie is garbage when you see Ritik trying to persuade people he is a native fella from Indus Valley

 

[ghazi52]

Despite Hindutva twists, it's clear that the Indus Valley flowered before the Vedas were written

Girish Shahane 10 August 2016

https://in.news.yahoo.com/despite-hindutva-twists-clear-indus-050000138.html

 

[Levina]

ISLAMABAD: Archaeologists in Pakistan have rejected Indian archaeologists' research stating that Indus Valley Civilization was 8,000 years old instead of 5,500 and originated from inland proper India proliferated and spread westward from India to the eastern border of Pakistan.

Obviously!!!
Why would Pakistani archeologists agree to the fact that IVC/SSC had originated from mainland India???
Would their sites not loose it's importance?
Indian archeologists had used the latest dating methods like Optically Stimulated Luminescence on animal remains and pottery fragments in IVC/SSC, so chances of them going wrong is very less.

 

[Stephen Cohen]

We will believe what our scientists and Archeologists have to say

 

[ghazi52]

Fair enough...................