Anti Hindi storm brewing in Tamilnadu

[Indrani]

we chose to spoke South indians in Hindi. They are perfect in Hindi, We never found any hurdle in communicating in hindi be it locals, Pakistanies, bangladeshies or southindians. All are perfect in Hindi.

That people accommodated you as a humvatan abroad does not mean that it will become so in India too. Try that stunt with the hubris that everyone will bow and scrape to your needs, and you will find a different story entirely.

 

[abjktu]

I do not do that. I am sure there are good things which are alien, but I have better stuff at my home itself. I do not lack self-respect like you.

Drugs tangondidara??????
wait a minute..who lacks self respect??.....if you hate that Persian Hindi so much,then why the f you speak it in your home??,though its not your mother tongue...nachige aagalva??

 

[Indrani]

Drugs tangondidara??????
wait a minute..who lacks self respect??.....if you hate that Persian Hindi so much,then why the f you speak it in your home??,though its not your mother tongue...nachige aagalva??

I speak many languages at home and no the occasion to use Persian or Arabic words does not rise in my speech. If anything I intersperse it with lot of Kannada words and like wise Kannada with Hindi words. Also I am not in the habit of shero-shayari so I do not get any opportunity to speak Urdu words at all.

Plus I am not against speaking of Urdu or Persian or whatever, just not officially bringing back the Moghul rule by making it the language of court or nation in this case.

 

[abjktu]

Anybody who thinks other wise is living in denial

Nothing but religious blindness...

 

[Indrani]

Nothing but religious blindness...

Nothing but identity crisis. Still wailing to be adopted by British I suppose.

 

[abjktu]

I speak many languages at home and no the occasion to use Persian or Arabic words does not rise in my speech. If anything I intersperse it with lot of Kannada words and like wise Kannada with Hindi words. Also I am not in the habit of shero-shayari so I do not get any opportunity to speak Urdu words at all.

.....Kaligaala....Kannada??..Kannada itself is a mixture of Tamil,Sanskrit Persian etc etc..

Nothing but identity crisis. Still wailing to be adopted by British I suppose.

its you...Thats why you speak both Kannada and hindi in your home.??.
.i don't have any identity crisis like you...

 

[Indrani]

.....Kaligaala....Kannada??..Kannada itself is a mixture of Tamil,Sanskrit Persian etc etc..

No Kannada is not a mixture of Persian. Kannada is a classical language of India. So no it is not an admixture of Persian. Take your sob story elsewhere.

 

[abjktu]

So no it is not an admixture of Persian. Take your sob story elsewhere.

Are you sure???
Persian-Kannada
1. jagir-jaaga,land
2.medaan-maidaana.,ground
3.ab o hawa-hawamaana,climate
YOU WANNA MORE...

 

[Indrani]

Are you sure???
Persian-Kannada
1. jagir-jaaga,land
2.medaan-maidaana.,ground
3.ab o hawa-hawamaana,climate
YOU WANNA MORE...

Jaga is taken from Jagat. World.

Havamana is a sanskrit word too.

Maidan is the only word you got.

 

[abjktu]

Jaga is taken from Jagat. World.

Havamana is a sanskrit word too.

Maidan is the only word you got.

hik hik...All those words are Persian..Classical tag doesn't means that the language is pure or devoid of any foreign influence...Even Kannada itself developed as a separate language from Tamil.....Malayalam is also a classical language but it has loan words from almost all language groups...

 

[Indrani]

hik hik...All those words are Persian..Classical tag doesn't means that the language is pure or devoid of any foreign influence...Even Kannada itself developed as a separate language from Tamil.....Malayalam is also a classical language but it has loan words from almost all language groups...

hik hik. No they are not. Jaga comes from Jagat and Jaganu. I checked the sanskrit dictionary before I replied. Likewise havamana is first mentioned in Rigveda.

Anyway as I said we do pepper our languages with loan words from other languages, point is how much? Spoken Hindi is basically indistinguishable from Urdu. Which is why the eternal quarrel on all public forum with Pakistanis claiming it to be urdu and Indians claiming it to be Hindi. Hindi also brings with it huge Islamic traits considering majority of Hindi belt are what can be called deracinated Hindus. You cannot claim the same for Kannada or South Indian languages.

 

[HeinzG]

This is a bad thing.
The conflict in SL has its origin in langauge. Tamils in SL feared a numerically superior Sinhala will one day dominate whole of SL and cause tamils to lose their language and culture, and identity as a tamil. That was the mentality of tamils then and still today. Imagine yourself as a tamil.

So in such a scenario asking them to learn sinhala is a stupid thing that can cause more issues. What we need at the moment is guarantee them that tamil language, culture will be protected in Sri lanka as an equal to sinhalese. And making sure that Tamil identity can be preserved in an umbrella sri lankan identity. That should be the first priority in any reconciliation task.

What? Then Sinhalese learning Tamil is not bad? Do we loose our language and culture if we learnt Tamil? So likewise Tamils should not loose their language and culture just because they learnt Sinhalese. Look how many Tamils in Colombo area and in the plantation areas know Sinhalese. Have they lost their language and culture? I bet they didn't.

However minority should always learn the majority language. That is how they always progress. That is the same reason why we learn English. I do not think any English speaker would like to learn Sinhalese or Tamil unless absolutely necessary.

@Gibbs,
your question that if majority is like 70% and whether they can have their own language as national language, i think no they still cant. If the 30% of the others have historical claim, we cannot.

WTF? Then what is the use of the majority. Back in the days of the British Raj there were equal representation in the governors office. That was for 1 representative each for Sinhalese, Tamils, Moors and Burghers despite the actual population representation. I bet you like that system too.

 

[Lord ZeN]

since even Christ spoke Tamil, it should rightfully be honored as the national language of India

Great ... We will make Tamil our national language. U happy now.

does knowledge of a language script got any relevance to the issue debated ? As Jesus too spoke Tamil , then why should Tamil learn an inferior foreign lingo - Hindi or have it imposed upon them ?

Since when did Tamils start worshipping Jesus ? Troll harder dear Sri Lankan Muslim who claims to be a Tamil.

 

[Lord ZeN]

I have met tamilians and knows pretty well how they feel towards people from northern india and the fact the most of the top brass in Delhi , army and bureaucracy are from north despite the fact Tamils are more educated , sophisticated and civil people.
Delhi will have to change its approach towards south otherwise khalistan , Maoists and tamilians are gonna screw this Modi sarkar big time.
Congress was learnt enough to manage such issues but bjp is gonna sink Indian boat if it pursues the current policy of one man show.
People want equal rights irrespective of religion, creed and cast and area no body will buy this one core united Hindu bullshit if it means power in few hands only.
Tamil Nadu has great potential if independent Modi and his blind followers should keep that in mind.

Really ? Most top bureaucrats from north ?? I far as I know most top bureaucrats are mallus inspite of constituting just 3% of indian population.

 

[illuminatidinesh]

I have met tamilians and knows pretty well how they feel towards people from northern india and the fact the most of the top brass in Delhi , army and bureaucracy are from north despite the fact Tamils are more educated , sophisticated and civil people.
Delhi will have to change its approach towards south otherwise khalistan , Maoists and tamilians are gonna screw this Modi sarkar big time.
Congress was learnt enough to manage such issues but bjp is gonna sink Indian boat if it pursues the current policy of one man show.
People want equal rights irrespective of religion, creed and cast and area no body will buy this one core united Hindu bullshit if it means power in few hands only.
Tamil Nadu has great potential if independent Modi and his blind followers should keep that in mind.

Dont know where u guys get these sort of stupid ideas? Khalistan, Maoist and comparing TAMILs with that? Poor fellow