What's new

Analysis: How to wipe out Islamic terror

I feel the same for you..... but then again I cant blame you.... as you don't want to be identified by Islam......
Is it not part of every Muslims faith to believe in past Prophets and Books (Irrespective of their current state)?
So you think it is not our job to spread the message of what we believe in ?

You got me wrong. I don't want Islaam to be identified by the idiot that I am.

To the rest: oh well I should've known nerds are only good at cramming stuff, not piecing it together! Bhaai jaan, the various Messengers in the chains of Ibraahiim AS's progeny came only to their own tribe/nation/people. His grandson Ya3quub AS's children grew in such a prolific mannr that the whole people of bahii Ya3quub i.e. Banii Israa2iil wre raised. These were sent a number of Messengers, in fact a large number, among them being Yuusuf AS, Muusaa AS and 3iisaa AS. But the message remained and was strictly meant to remain 'within the family'. Other people in other places at the same time had different circumstances and were sent different sharaa2i3, and each time, everywhere, the message once again stayed within the family.
 
.
KAFIR:
According to wikipedia...

I rest my case.
Quoting from Wiki is hardly academic, but even so aren't we both saying the same thing?

You don't become kaafir by being born in a say Hindu family, but by coming to know that Islaam is in fact the truth and then hiding / not admitting this knowledge.
 
. .
The point is that I'm not calling myself a non-muslim but a bad-muslim.

Still, were you able to comprehend my explanation that all Abrahamic faiths did not come for all humanity?
 
.
I think you contradicted yourself... he did not have the last laugh

He did recovered Jerusalem back from Crusaders, then Muslims lost it again to British then Jews. Correct me if I am wrong but crusade was not just about Jerusalem, it was about the whole of Holy lands.
 
.
The point is that I'm not calling myself a non-muslim but a bad-muslim.

Still, were you able to comprehend my explanation that all Abrahamic faiths did not come for all humanity?

And I too never meant that....
But then again modern Christianity has indeed spread way outside its original audience and many Priests do claim its message is universal (something I dont agree with).

Now happy ?
 
.
He did recovered Jerusalem back from Crusaders, then Muslims lost it again to British then Jews. Correct me if I am wrong but crusade was not just about Jerusalem, it was about the whole of Holy lands.

They were only for Jeursalam.. the crusades I mean.
But the point is not in Muslim hands nowadays. I don't care who owns it as long every person who considers it Holy can visit it and everyone living there can live in Peace.
 
.
I think the west wants it back .......


True. Plucky Duck & Hamton J. Pig are truly a deadly combo and even their name is enough to struck fear into their enemy's heart:cheesy:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
.
They were only for Jeursalam.. the crusades I mean.
But the point is not in Muslim hands nowadays. I don't care who owns it as long every person who considers it Holy can visit it and everyone living there can live in Peace.

Transfer UN's headquarters there, making Jerusalem a neutral territory. Just one of may crazy ideas to end conflict in ME.
 
.
How ironic. The author in the OP draws a battleplan to exterminate Muslim terror, but in the end he only shows that India has its own fair share of hindu-extremist lunatics as well.
 
.
This is the father of all nonsense articles that have ever been posted on this forum. When did the Al-Qaeda leader said that india is the target??

I have been observing that india is trying very hard to somehow get involved in this WOT and get praises from the World. But they don't know the consequences yet. .

Yes - It's really a crap. Anyway it's India's internal matter, if they want to have Hindu radicals like Al-CIAda in their country than let them taste that as well.
 
.
Absolute rubbish article! As an Indian and a Hindu, I'm ashamed of these extremists - but believing in freedom of expression, I wouldn't as for a ban on it. It has come under a lot of criticism in India (thankfully!) and Hindutva in my opinion is as anti-India as all those waging a war on the state. I think by and large most Hindus do not subscribe to his views - just like most Muslims are not extremists. However, even one extremist can wreak havoc given the right opportunity so we (as concerned, peace loving citizens) on both sides of the border need to take religious extremism very seriously and root out the real evil in society.
 
.
You don't become kaafir by being born in a say Hindu family, but by coming to know that Islaam is in fact the truth and then hiding / not admitting this knowledge.

This is the source for all intolerance/terrorism. The "the" part which emphasized Islam alone is the truth and others are false.

When Muslims start thinking that Islam also is a path to God and not the only path to God, all violence will cease to exist.

How ironic. The author in the OP draws a battleplan to exterminate Muslim terror, but in the end he only shows that India has its own fair share of hindu-extremist lunatics as well.

They give the same excuse as the European right. I hope you know what I mean. Newton's third law holds true irrespective of religion.
 
.
Its very clear that Swamy is only playing the usual politics. He probably does not even believe in what he wrote.

Just 10 years ago, he wrote a piece pretty much castigating the RSS accusing of establishing a fascist state in India. Now he feels it will help him by stroking hatred against Muslims in India. It didn't help in politically then, and it will not help him politically now while he continues to be bitter as always.

For those who didn't know, do read this article.

The RSS game plan
SUBRAMANIAN SWAMY
Volume 17 - Issue 02, Jan. 22 - Feb. 04, 2000

A disillusioned and dispirited RSS has set the ball rolling for mid-term general elections in which it hopes that the BJP will gain an absolute majority and implement the Hindutva agenda.

SUBRAMANIAN SWAMY

THE situation in India today is characterised and manifested by creeping fascism. Never before in our history have we been confronted by such an almost invisible phenomenon. India has seen a crawling imperialism (1750-1947) when foreign traders turned me rcenary protectors, and then slowly became our masters. But that process took a century to consummate and another century to unwind. The Indian people have also experienced the Emergency (1975-77) that came upon the land in a flash and went out much the same way. Nevertheless we had got a taste of dictatorship of the modern state in that short period. We had felt it, hated it, but then the nation also revolted against it.

Today the creeping fascism of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) is coming upon us not as gradually as imperialism did, nor as suddenly as did the Emergency. Its spread is being calibrated adroitly by seven faceless men of the RSS, the RSS "high comma nd". We barely feel it. Some yesteryear civil libertyites such as Arun Shourie have been co-opted. Others are being wooed or chased.

But the RSS leaders are now in their late seventies, some not at all in good health, and so in a mood of frustration. Their glide to a total capture of Delhi's gaddi (throne) has been interrupted and put on 'hold'. Symbolically, the bhagwa dhwaj (saffron double triangle flag) does not yet flutter from the Red Fort; but the hated tricolour which no RSS office can hoist even on August 15, still does. The climb to total power is up a slippery slope. Having come so close, the RSS could lose it all in a sudden throw of the electoral dice. That is the frustration; so close yet so far. Last April, my tea party nearly put their goal out of reach. It was a close call.

So the RSS warhorses recently have chalked out a game plan: the "Final Solution". The Bharatiya Janata Party-led National Democratic Alliance (NDA) and the National Agenda for Governance, they concluded, cannot go on forever. It must be ended at some poi nt. Otherwise the danger is that the RSS may.

Between the 1998 and 1999 general elections, the BJP had for the first time in 15 years and after six general elections, hit a plateau in Lok Sabha seats won. Its tally was stuck at 182 seats. The tally of its "allied parties" - which do not believe in H indutva - rose in terms of numbers (18 to 24), as well in terms of seats won (80 to 120). This rang alarm bells in the RSS. For an organisation that has been banned three times in 15 years, the 1999 election results naturally, justifiably, caused neurosi s in the RSS. Under the compulsions of the coalition calculus, they have had to dilute their goals for the rewards of office. It was a trade-off: a BJP Prime Minister meant acquiring national and international legitimacy they never had before. It also me ant a conspiracy of silence of the intellectuals in the creeping advance of their Hindutva goals.

But then there is a downside to that trade-off: the RSS cadre is disillusioned and disspirited with the compromises and the stunting. India is nowhere the Hindu Rashtra that the high command had been promising, and on which they had been weaned and brain -washed. The cadres' patience is now wearing thin. They want to strike out on their own even at the cost of losing power. I have seen this mindset before. Between 1977 and 1980, in the undivided Janata Party, I had witnessed the agony in the cadre. At th at time the same trade-offs were pointed out to the disgruntled rank and file by the high command. But the welling of sentiment could not be capped. The seven (younger men then) had therefore to act. They had to abandon the compromises in order to keep t he Janata unity. They thus allowed the government to fall, and then went on their own to form the BJP.

The current situation for the RSS is also characterised by the same paradigm. The RSS has, according to reliable sources, made up its mind that the NDA has taken its cause about as far as it could. The trade-off is no more worth it. Therefore the groundw ork has to be laid clandestinely and in small doses for achieving an absolute majority for the BJP. In other words, in the not-too-distant future, I believe the RSS will call for a mid-term poll when it feels that the ground has been prepared. The RSS ju ggernaut is thus on the move, and the groundwork is already there for the discerning to see. For this to fructify, the RSS has drawn up a game plan which has three components.

THE first component of the game plan is to discredit the RSS' opponents but protect its converts. The First Information Report in the Bofors case is a classic instance of this strategem. In that FIR, Rajiv Gandhi's name figures in the list of accused (n ever mind the column). But those Cabinet Ministers who vetted and signed the deal, or had even held secret negotiations on the "financial parameters" with the Bofors company as representatives of Rajiv Gandhi, are prosecution witnesses. Naturally we can guess what they will say in the witness box. Then there is the case of Arun Nehru, whose hand has been in every cookie jar of every deal of that period. He is our swadeshi Quattrocchi, but then he has now bathed in the Ganga jal of the BJP. He too is a witness, not an accused. The motto is: "Join us and be free. Resist us and see you in court." By a series of such sham prosecutions and managed associate media leaks, the RSS expects to undermine the democratic Opposition in India. They hope to tak e full advantage of the factions of democratic parties as they did with the Janata Dal recently.

The second component of the RSS game plan is to shake public confidence in every institution that can circumscribe or act as a speed-breaker for the RSS juggernaut. The Law Minister has already initiated moves to emasculate the Supreme Court via the judi cial commission and by threatening political monitoring of judicial ethics. Just in case his ilk got too rebellious, he has threatened to amend the law (through an ordinance) to permit foreign lawyers to practise in Indian courts. Briefless Jaffna lawyer s are waiting to fill the vacuum.

The Human Resource Development (HRD) Minister has elevated an RSS activist to the post of a selector of teachers in the National Council for Educational Research and Training, a person who defends his credentials of valour by recording that he once had s hot dead a young Muslim girl to protect her honour and to end her misery while she was being gang-raped by Hindu youth during Partition. That, of course, is Hindutva justice: that is, the minorities can best look forward to liberation through mercy killi ng.

Christians are being targeted by the front organisations of the RSS in order to terrorise and ghetto-ise all minorities. Since Osama bin Laden is stalking the Hindustan peninsula with his millions of dollars and narcotics, for the wily and cautious RSS. Christians are an easy target because there are no Christian terrorists to retaliate. As the period of the Emergency clearly demonstrated, the RSS is astute enough to know when to hunt with the hounds and when to run with the hares. They are smarter than the German fascists in this respect.

The third component of the RSS game plan is to ready the blueprints for implementing the agenda. Of course they cannot implement it in the present Parliament, but it will be their USP (unique selling proposition) for the mid-term poll. They have already scripted the new history texts; they have sent into circulation amongst the faithful how the new Constitution of India should be structured.

ACCORDING to a draft circulated at the 1998 October conference of the Akhil Bharatiya Vidyarthi Parishad (ABVP), an RSS front organisation, the following measures are planned: The present bicameral Parliament would be replaced by a three-tier structure. At the apex will be a Guru Sabha of sadhus and sanyasis (read VHP activists) nominated by the President who is elected by a Lok Sabha constituted on a limited electoral college of primary and secondary school teachers, the rolls of which will be prepared by the HRD Ministry and not the Election Commission. All legislation and money bills will have to originate in the Guru Sabha and be passed by it before being sent to the Lok Sabha. The Guru Sabha will also be the judicial commission to nominate Supreme Court Judges, and impeach them. In between the Guru Sabha and the Lok Sabha, there will be a Raksha Sabha of serving armed forces chiefs and retired soldiers who can decide when to declare an Emergency. India would be, it seems, converted into a state w hich is a cross between the Taliban and the Vatican. It is for this scheme that they will seek a mandate in a mid-term poll.

The RSS game plan also has proposals to bridle the electoral system. Adult suffrage is out, but furthermore, the electoral college for the Lok Sabha will not vote for candidates, but for parties under a List System. Electronic Voting Machines (EVMs) will be used in all the constituencies. Perhaps it is then easier to rig the outcome. After all, in the 1999 general elections, the BJP and its allies won 34 out of the 45 Lok Sabha constituencies which had EVMs. On that ratio, the NDA should have won 405 se ats of the 544 Lok Sabha constituencies and not 292. EVMs have to be programmed by an engineer to tabulate the votes in its memory. It can easily be programmed to transfer votes of one candidate to another, or one party to another. The EVMs are entirely unsafeguarded today. I suspect it was rigged in the 1999 general elections.

The RSS game plan is thus ready. Only the D-Day for the blitzkrieg is to be determined. Since it appears that the RSS has already been generating momentum on religious fundamentalist issues (for example, Gujarat's Ram temple) and raised the fanatical emo tional temperature (chasing of Christian missionaries), my guess is that this campaign will be taken to a fever pitch by November 9, 2001 (the 1986 date for shilanyas) and then mid-term elections will be called.

Prime Minister Vajpayee will as usual waffle and wobble, but he will not resist. That is his nature; he is a mask for the RSS, as Commissar Govindacharya had once said.

Of course, the good news is that the game plan can fail. I live on the hope that in India, no well-laid plan ever works. India, after all, is a functioning anarchy. That has been the undoing of every attempt to straitjacket its society. That is why we ar e still the longest continuing unbroken civilisation of over 10,000 years. The RSS is, luckily, our counter-culture. The vibrations of Mother India will, I hope, be its undoing.

Dr. Subramanian Swamy is a former Union Law Minister who is now president of the Janata Party.
 
.
India belongs to all who live in her and who are willing to obey her laws. To correct certain people here, India may have the largest population of Hindus but it is by no means a "Hindu homeland". It is a secular country to which most Hindus who departed from India share no loyalty or allegiance to. It may be largely a holy land to Hindus but it does not belong solely to Hindu Indians. Out of India I find Muslim and other minorities more loyal to India than many of their Hindu fellow citizens. Suggesting that they be suppressed just to give good to some stupid religious ego is demented. People who think in this manner should seek an area in Pakistan (with respect to Pakistan) where they can bang their religious drums claiming that their religion is deserving of preference above others. Maybe even a Hindu blasphemy law for these radicals there but certainly not in India. Thank heaven that most sane Indians (of all religions) would reject this chain of thought as absolute garbage not worthy of recycling.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom