The exercise involved was AE 2008, and for those criticising that the dates for the PAF and Italian participation don't match, well, all i can say is that patience is a virtue. The fact is that Israelis who were to participate that year withdrew or some say they were banned.
In any case, PAF was asked to fill in the slot and joined the exercise along with US, Italy and off course Turkey. This meant the participation by the PAF was much earlier than originally planned and reported.
To sum it up, there were three set ups and in all three, PAF pilots from No 9 Squadron (Griffins) zapped three Italian Typhoons.
I have had the priveledge to find out the name of one of the Typhoon shooters, He is Wing Commander Fawad Masood, a 2000 hour viper driver presently assigned to the Air HQ, another pilot with a Typhoon under his belt has been posted on the new Blok-52s while remaining are in Sargodha. The best part is all the HUD footage of the Typhoons getting zapped is with No. 9 Squadron. Just like to add that Wing Commander Fawad Masood also participated in Red Flag and Green Flag exercises.
Thanks to WJ, HC and Adnan.