What's new

Aman ke Asha – A Cornerstone of the new Indian Cold Start Strategy?

.
What A Popular Blogger has to say about the same:

Bhai Bhai | Random Thoughts of a Demented Mind

Bhai Bhai

Waking up on January 1 and with my eyes falling on the front page of the TOI, I chanced upon the announcement of an initiative to bridge fences between India and Pakistan through people-to-people interaction.

Immediately the monster hangover I was nursing from the rum-coke just took a turn for the worse.

I understand that we just entered a new decade but the old decade, was like, here just a day ago. A decade which started with a dastardly hi-jacking, warmed up with attacks on our Parliament and continued with sporadic acts of urban violence and ended with 26/11, all of them originating, beyond any scope of reasonable doubt, from a single land-mass to our West. Being that the case, the kind of amnesia that makes us want to “talk peace” with Pakistan, in a “people to people Track 2″ kind of way makes my mind boggle, in the same way that Jaani Dushman–Ek Anokhi Kahani did.

I absolutely understand the need to move ahead and forget the hurts of the past though I would not have the balls to stand in front of Lt Saurabh Kalia’s family or a camp of Kashmiri Pandits and say this. The problem here is of course that this initiative is asking us to ignore the present. A present where those that perpetrated 26/11 are allowed to walk free in Pakistan like heroes. A present where ISI has been trying to make the Indian economy collapse by introducing massive amounts of fake currency.

Of course I know the response. This is Pakistan “the establishment” that is doing this. Not Pakistan “the people”, who as the poll shows overwhelmingly do not desire armed conflict with India. And that somehow exchanging sweets on the Wagah border and having a trade delegation in Karachi and having joint musharafs sorry mushairas will somehow soften the China-Pakistani army to dump the billions they have pumped into the proxy war against India over decades and even prompt Kayani to act in Bhatt movies.

That is if he is not doing so already.

But maybe I am being too pessimistic I thought. So I started reading the joint statement. But then right at the top, there is a gentle reminder of the love that our Pakistani brothers have for us. A love that they are willing to spread by paying money to Google, who using their super-smart contextual super-semantic algorithm, have placed their banner-ad straight on top of this missive of goodwill.



No prizes for guessing what the answer to the rhetorical question (circled in red) was.

But then again I told myself that this is precisely the kind of things that such acts of brotherly bonhomie will strive to clean up and perhaps the said hate-site is run by Pakistan the “establishment” (a disembodied zombie-like organization that apparently has no popular support for its policies) and not by Pakistan “the people”.

So I read on.

There was this impassioned rhetoric to rescue the fate of the two nations from “warmongers” followed by an interesting mea-culpa.

We believe the media can serve as facilitators in fostering greater understanding between people. Unfortunately — and TOI cannot entirely escape blame — we tend to focus far too much on the negative. In the process, the good that people do is drowned out by the sensational, and by the constant flow of death-and-destruction headlines.

Sounds good. And fair.

Having read this, I decided to make a visit to the Jang site, hoping to see a reflection of these thoughts (namely that India and Pakistan press are partially to blame for the escalation of rhetoric) and of the importance of this initiative.

On the Jang site however, to my surprise, any reference to the historic project was way at the bottom of the page (the last link in the Opinions section) at the same time when it was being prominently displayed on the TOI site.

And then I went through what the other side had to say. Throughout the article with politically sensitive references to Kashmir and Bangladesh, the underlying tone was anything but shared responsibility of history. Then in sharp contrast to the tone of the TOI article, there was this killer line

Given the hardening of positions after the Mumbai massacre and particularly the anti-Pakistan tone of the Indian media,

In other words, according to the Pakistani sponsors of this initiative, it is the Indian media which is exclusively anti-Pakistan and not the other way round even though a 2 second googling throws up so many lovely examples of pro-India Pakistan reporting that they are not worth linking to , not to speak of the intellectually weighty analysis of Mr. Z. Hameed, Pakistan’s pre-eminent public intellectual.

The reason I mention this is not to do a “gotcha”. I do it because this is precisely the reason why a people-to-people solution will never work.

The people of Pakistan refuse to acknowledge the truth of the complicity of their citizens and their administration in acts of terrorism in India for decades.

Nothing surprising about this though. This kind of refusal to accept the truth, even in the face of mountains of evidence accepted beyond doubt, is a trait commonly exhibited by perpetrators—from the last cross-cultural ambassador from Pakistan we have been honored to host (Kasab) to Policeman Rathore.

However this does make it impossible to reason with them or to make a play for their heart and minds.

Now if a Pushtoon tribal man who never went to school and likes to watch Haseena Atimbum felt that the malignant entity that promotes terrorism in India is India itself and that India controls Afghanistan, I would have understood. However in Pakistan, it is the elite of the elite, the well-healed and the educated who in other countries would form the “liberal” cabal typically prone to gratuitous self-flagellation, who are curiously the most loathe to accept the culpability of the nation they belong to.

Take for example Pakistan’s rock/pop scene, usually one of the most progressive sub-cultures of any nation, as shown in this video article by New York Times . No doubt to make themselves acceptable and marketable, their songs are all exclusively about how Pakistan is a victim in the war of terror (”All the turbulation (sic) in Pakistan it is not us, it is the outside hand” )and that Pakistan is not responsible for any kind of terrorism (a song that supposedly decries terrorism says “It is not us. It is not us. The story that is being spread in our name is a lie”) .

There is full support for the Taliban with one superstar going as far as to support Taliban’s bombing of girl’s schools and another saying that Taliban is a very small problem for Pakistan compared to the “others”.

Not that there are not sane voices in the video (mostly from music critics who do not have an audience to pander to) but what one cannot get around is that what these musicians are doing is that, perhaps in order to sell more, is to echo what people in Pakistan feel. The elite, the educated and the “Westernized”. The same people who are supposed to be the target for such outreach programs.

The reason why musicians sprout anti-Western/anti-Indian rhetoric is the same as why democratic governments in Pakistan are typically the most virulently anti-India (it was Benazir Bhutto who initiated the pogrom against Kashmiri Pandits).

India hatred is popular. Simple. It wins elections and it sells records. And a few cultural programs and flag-painting on faces wont change the fact.

Of course I am not saying there is nothing for us Indians to do. For one we can hold the feet of our political masters to the fire on matters of national security in a continuous and sustained fashion, as opposed to the impassioned SMS-s and bluster of not playing cricket that immediately follows an attack and then dies after three news-cycles. This should be accompanied by a realization that we will continue to have a neighbour whose hostility will only increase as our economic might increases and that the only way to control the situation is in us securing the nation through investments in the modernization of the intelligence and internal security infrastructure (perhaps a bit of the Rs 300 crore our honorable ministers spent on domestic and foreign travel might have been better used) rather than expecting the world to declare Pakistan a terrorist state, which it will not do because it is not in their best interests, even though when push comes to shove (i.e. their lives at stake) they will show Pakistan their place [Link]

Indeed there are a hundred one things that can be done to protect ourselves. Each needs planning, thought and strategizing. Each alas is more complex than eating laddoos together or an India-Pakistan match where Rani Mukherjee is dressed as a man.

However we as a nation continue to treat relations with dangerous nations with a kind of child-like naivete which would be cute only if it did not lead to consequences that are tragic. Forgetting Govinda’s famous advice “Control yaar” we swing between the emotional extremes of “Let’s go to war” and “Let’s mend bridges by hugging” and projects like this one, despite being born from good intentions, unfortunately do play their part in consolidating the myth of simple-minded Alok Nathization (”Aaj humare dil mein gajab ek uljhan hai, gaane baithe gana saamne Ilyas Kashmiri hai”) as a solution for the most complex of problems.

Lest I be misunderstood, I like most polled citizens of the two countries, do not want war.

Not because it is not politically correct to desire peace but because conventional war in today’s world, as proven by Afghanistan and Iraq, has only disaster as its consequence—-sometimes even more for to the victor.

However at the same time, I do not also endorse the tokenism of similar Bhai-bhai peace initiatives simply because, given recent history and the current situation, they will not work.

Why? Because they have never worked before. Not with China. Not with Pakistan.

The forces of politics, history and economics are too strong for that.
 
.
Look at the picture-look at all these idiotic romantic cruckwits. They have have nothing better to do except weaken Indian resolve to defend itself against repeated **** attacks?

I would request TOI to Please STOP this nonsense. How many times must Indians get fooled by Pakistanis? They clearly do not want peace because it is political suicide in Pakistan to ask for peace with India. So much for the 'common peaceloving' man in Pakistan wanting peace. Just Shut the border, build a gigantic fence and do not allow any Pakistani to set foot in India, unless on humanitarian grounds. As for the terrorist attacks on Pakistan now, they do not bother me one bit. In fact I am happy when I see Pakistani people being targeted by their Islamic heroes. Let them go through another 50 years of terrorist hell and then mabye they might voluntarily give up their nonsense of Islamic expansionism.

That isn't a good post. Because of the misguided actions of a few people you want to shut off an entire nation? On the counter I would suggest that India and Pakistan starts dialogue asap. The terrorist attacks in Pakistan is nothing to gloat about. Innocent people are being massacred on a regular basis by animalistic humans. Do you have any Pakistani friends? Do you have any Muslim friends? I think not. I suggest that you befriend a few Pakistanis and Indian Muslims and re examine your views a few months down the line from then. One of my Pakistani expatriate friend lost his soldier brother to the terrorists in an army operation. I cried with him as he cried with me when I lost my brother to an Indian airforce mishap a few years back. The people you curse are our family. They share the same heritage we do. The biggest threat to India and Pakistan are not the terrorists who maim and kill our people. It is the self serving politicians who drum up hatred and anger in our people against each other to earn votes on how they plan on teaching that other Hindu/Muslim country across the border a lesson. Yet when we leave India or Pakistan we become dhost dhost or bhai bhai in other continents? Share the land, pass the water and feel the love :smitten:
 
.
what i fail to udnerstand is why are we always initiating peace why is PAKISTAN SO DESPERATE to TALK PEACE! when clearly india takes it as a sign to belittle us & say stuff like dus kadam pakistan khatam! & deepak kapoor to say in 48 hours we can enter pakistan!

AMMAN KI ASHAAA is a farce it will just make us think india is really accepting us as friends! we made this mistake before the KASAB INCIDENT! ven though pakistani government nor its people were involved india started saying cra p against the whole country & nation!


for god sake stop fooling yourself there can be no peace until kashmir is resolved! kashmir will never be resolved so peace will never come....accept reality stop this nonsense!
 
.
a slightly biased article IMO.

while we can not really blame the author for believing that the indian defence procurements are pakistan centric( too much bad blood between the 2 nations) he is wrong in the regard.
india now plans to offset the military advantage that china enjoys over it. the places where the IAF is improving infrastructure can be instructive.



i am not sure when indian jets flew in pakistan skies. could someone enlighten me about which incident this refers to?

most of indians procurements are placed close to our borders not chinas for example your sukhois!

secondly last time your planes flew in our skies he is implying the events after the attack on mumbai! where clearly our government and ordinary pakistanis were not involved! and yet instead of trying to stand by pakistanis the indians forgot all the CBMs and started saying stuff like duss kadam pakistan khatam!

PEACE is a ply india gets us involved in so that we relax & turn a blind eye towards what india is doing! (i.e. build dams on jhelum river)!
 
.
most of indians procurements are placed close to our borders not chinas for example your sukhois!

Dito for Pakistan....all Pakistani Defence procurements are targetted towards india...

Do you know that Indian sukhois are also based along China Border....
IAF to post Sukhoi war planes near China border


secondly last time your planes flew in our skies he is implying the events after the attack on mumbai! where clearly our government and ordinary pakistanis were not involved! and yet instead of trying to stand by pakistanis the indians forgot all the CBMs and started saying stuff like duss kadam pakistan khatam!
Well the whole world and even your Pakistani leaders have agreed that Pakistanis were involved...and the GOP has attested and trying 7 People for Mumbai Attacks....

Pakistan charges seven suspects over Mumbai attacks - Haaretz - Israel News
Pakistan charges 7 in Mumbai attacks Kuwait Times Website

But you don't read newspaper ...do you...


PEACE is a ply india gets us involved in so that we relax & turn a blind eye towards what india is doing! (i.e. build dams on jhelum river)!

Remember Kargil....and tell me who back stabbed...
 
.
Dito for Pakistan....all Pakistani Defence procurements are targetted towards india...

Do you know that Indian sukhois are also based along China Border....
IAF to post Sukhoi war planes near China border



Well the whole world and even your Pakistani leaders have agreed that Pakistanis were involved...and the GOP has attested and trying 7 People for Mumbai Attacks....

Pakistan charges seven suspects over Mumbai attacks - Haaretz - Israel News
Pakistan charges 7 in Mumbai attacks Kuwait Times Website

But you don't read newspaper ...do you...




Remember Kargil....and tell me who back stabbed...

from your first link i guess you didn't read the indian SUKHOIs are placed

Halwara (Punjab) and Jodhpur (Rajasthan) in the west!


so 1 squadron in Assam is nothing given the size of your border with china!

second link well seems like you don't read newspaper little boy

India wont hand over Malegaon suspect to Pak, says its an internal matter

Pak may bring up Lt.Col. Purohit’’s role in Samjhauta blasts at Interior Secretaries” meet


and before you remind me kargil please recall 1984 SIACHEN! We did Kargil after learning from your famous operation in 1984 where you entered siachen! so we just did the same....now go read history before you come here and rant about back stabbing!
 
.
from your first link i guess you didn't read the indian SUKHOIs are placed

Halwara (Punjab) and Jodhpur (Rajasthan) in the west!


so 1 squadron in Assam is nothing given the size of your border with china!

second link well seems like you don't read newspaper little boy

India wont hand over Malegaon suspect to Pak, says its an internal matter

Pak may bring up Lt.Col. Purohit’’s role in Samjhauta blasts at Interior Secretaries” meet


and before you remind me kargil please recall 1984 SIACHEN! We did Kargil after learning from your famous operation in 1984 where you entered siachen! so we just did the same....now go read history before you come here and rant about back stabbing!

What are you trying to imply? That Pakistan realised some 15 years later that India took over Siachen? :what:
 
.
Somebody itching for these cheesy Bhai Bhainess, first needs to sitdown with the curricullum text books of both the countries, do proper evaluation based on neutral observations, compare without personal biases and then proceed to make proper ammendments before hoping anything other than the colossal mistrust and heatred that we have sown in our boys and girls through our own acts. And unfortunately the otherside doesn't seems interested too much.

Asides: A very Happy New Year to all the known and unknown readers.
 
.
Boy,not able to stand the Aman ki Aasha **** in TOI.So my 2 cent rant that the average pakistani fanboy thinks

"Why would someone who ruled India for 1000 years ,eat non-veg daily,6ft tall with 10 inch stiff beard will make peace with someone who are banias, weak,not able to fight(1:10ratio)to fight us.Why should we make peace?Why should we?..
Answer:Idiotic banias so weak ,so gullible,so stupid.Just to organize ourselves and defeat them.stupid banias,so weak,so gullible
he...he.."
End of rant

MY VIEW:
Moronic exercise in futility
 
.
That isn't a good post. Because of the misguided actions of a few people you want to shut off an entire nation? On the counter I would suggest that India and Pakistan starts dialogue asap. The terrorist attacks in Pakistan is nothing to gloat about. Innocent people are being massacred on a regular basis by animalistic humans. Do you have any Pakistani friends? Do you have any Muslim friends? I think not. I suggest that you befriend a few Pakistanis and Indian Muslims and re examine your views a few months down the line from then. One of my Pakistani expatriate friend lost his soldier brother to the terrorists in an army operation. I cried with him as he cried with me when I lost my brother to an Indian airforce mishap a few years back. The people you curse are our family. They share the same heritage we do. The biggest threat to India and Pakistan are not the terrorists who maim and kill our people. It is the self serving politicians who drum up hatred and anger in our people against each other to earn votes on how they plan on teaching that other Hindu/Muslim country across the border a lesson. Yet when we leave India or Pakistan we become dhost dhost or bhai bhai in other continents? Share the land, pass the water and feel the love :smitten:

Sir I have nothing ill feelings for Muslims and Islam. I have many Muslims friends with whome I eat in same plate. And even they are sick of all the pakistani sponsored acts of terrorism in India. Even my muslim friends curse pakistan for what they have done to our country. They used terrorism for political gains and now they are reaping what they have sown earlier. Nothing out of the obvious.

Loss of innocent lives is really sad but this is what they fostered and they have to deal it themselves. We are not part of the problem and let us not try to be part of the solution as well. Let them do what they want to do.

It is a known fact that ever since pakistan got occupied in its own mess, there has been not a single terrorist attack on India. Pakistan kept occupied internally for next couple of decades implies direct peace dividend for India and no more train, temple and school bomb blasts anymore in India. This sounds fair to me as a policy maker, keeping my national interests on top priority.

I have a big :tup: for Hindu Muslim unity, why not let us unite India and pakistan again into greater India and 'Share the land, pass the water and feel the love'.

This is my humble opinion.
 
Last edited:
. .
Hey abu, you have lost to me on many ocassions and yet want your @ss to be kicked by me??

I dont no how to fccuk myself. Tell me exactly how you fccuk yourself. I know you are a "think tank" so you must be thinking hard on such issues.

???????

you're an indian. Nuff said!!!


and you need to learn how to speak English. Your post was garbage, I called you out.


Now, i want you to get lost. :sniper:
 
.
???????

you're an indian. Nuff said!!!


and you need to learn how to speak English. Your post was garbage, I called you out.


Now, i want you to get lost. :sniper:

before it goes further, my sincere request to both of you to stop this?
 
.
I had a gre score of 1480. So I must be knowing better English than you.

As far as typing mistake is concerned, I think it is for the fools not to understand out of the typing mistake.

As English is not my first language, and assuming you really received a 1480 on the GRE, I would not argue for one second that you must "be knowing" better English.


I hope you can come back after you receive your Masters degree, hopefully a bit more knowledgable and useful for the forum. But maybe I am being a bit overly-optimistic!



regards...


:pakistan:
 
Last edited:
.

Latest posts

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom